(Please be warned: Self harm, family separation, and pregnancy loss discussed.)
To me Jonathan Brown is severly overrated.
Because he played in the Lions 3-peat he gets rated a lot higher he should if you take a stats look at it both JR & Hawkins are notch above him.
He also was beaten up & cooked by 256 games, where as both Tomahawk & JR have played 300+ games & had longevity.
Jack more versatile and probably the better overall player.
Tom probably the better full forward though in its traditional form.
Both great, hard to split.
Combined goals and goal assists have Riewoldt ahead, as he's pretty handy in that area himself (only 0.09 per game behind Hawkins).Sure Hawkins is more of a FF in the traditional sense now but he used to play ruck and also play up the ground.
He's also 2nd all-time for goal assists. Not sure what makes Jack more versatile and better overall.