Remove this Banner Ad

Next weeks teams vs Essendon

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

brilliant pies said:
well there both never gonna be dropped so get over it
Click to expand...
Malthouse actually singled out Woewodin (along with Williams) as players who did not take their chances , so I'm hoping you're wrong and it's a sign (plus the face like a smacked arse on TSFS.)
 
brilliant pies said:
well there both never gonna be dropped so get over it
Click to expand...

I know that they won't get dropped. I don't think I suggested that they would. Doesn't mean that I have to be accepting of their performances which on Friday night were terrible. Get over youself and accept that not everyone shares the same opinions.
 
bucksisbest said:
Malthouse actually singled out Woewodin (along with Williams) as players who did not take their chances , so I'm hoping you're wrong and it's a sign (plus the face like a smacked arse on TSFS.)
Click to expand...
If woewodin gets dropped we will be a 1-2 goals worse off.
 
While I think that Woey and Tarkyn have been poor (although Tarkyn has been alright) if I were the coach I wouldn't drop a player for one poor performance. I would talk to Woey and to a lesser extend Tarx and tell them that they are senior experienced players and expect better of them and tell them if they don't lift they are in danger of being dropped.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

jabso said:
While I think that Woey and Tarkyn have been poor (although Tarkyn has been alright) if I were the coach I wouldn't drop a player for one poor performance. I would talk to Woey and to a lesser extend Tarx and tell them that they are senior experienced players and expect better of them and tell them if they don't lift they are in danger of being dropped.
Click to expand...

Make him the Next Coach...

JABSO 2006!!! ;)
 
Woey probably deserves a run with Willy, but unfortunately there are hacks we need to drop before him.

So by the time we drop them and get to Woey, there is no point dropping him because we just don't have the depth to cover it.

It's a very sad plight.
 
Rozza44 said:
People said mcgough wasnt ready for debut, but wouldnt be surprised with a couple debuts on anzac day,
eg
2002: Mcgough
2004: C.Cloke

I agree with Brilliant Pies changes
Click to expand...
sorry to say tiger but mcgough didnt debut on anzac day he played his first game the game before essendon vs hawthorn and was best on ground
 
brilliant pies said:
If woewodin gets dropped we will be a 1-2 goals worse off.
Click to expand...
Bull******** , although I do recall one of his six touches on Friday night was mildly effective.
Just a footballer who has got a few of you sucked in on a reputation he got 4 or 5 years ago.
 
bucksisbest said:
Bull******** , although I do recall one of his six touches on Friday night was mildly effective.
Just a footballer who has got a few of you sucked in on a reputation he got 4 or 5 years ago.
Click to expand...
How old is Wowey?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

A mediocre game from Woewodin against the Dons, will have Woewy on a train to Williamstown, but I have stood up for him...he is a player..anyone who thinks he is the luckiest Brownlow Medallists knows ******** all about football...but he has had a bad start to 2005 after an awesome season last year, to shut out the critics, well...not on the Collingwood Board anyway.
 
Hoggy said:
He sure is.
Click to expand...

:D We have several. Some are better than others though :)
 
NICK THE PIE MAN said:
Woey probably deserves a run with Willy, but unfortunately there are hacks we need to drop before him.

So by the time we drop them and get to Woey, there is no point dropping him because we just don't have the depth to cover it.

It's a very sad plight.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately, Nick is on the money. No use talking about dropping Woey and Tarks if we don't have anyone to replace them. FFS, half our early draft picks are still playing in the ressies.
 
dunno4 said:
Unfortunately, Nick is on the money. No use talking about dropping Woey and Tarks if we don't have anyone to replace them. FFS, half our early draft picks are still playing in the ressies.
Click to expand...

Didak, King or H Shaw could do better. And if you're prepared to take a punt maybe so could Egan.

I'd drop Woey and Williams for sure. Tarks I'd keep in the 22, he's not playing that bad.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

ThatThis said:
Were ********ed
Click to expand...

it's "we're"...but yes we're ********ed now

explains why he was disappointing on friday night perhaps

oh well, the injury curse is striking again, but it gives someone like King or Heath Shaw a chance i would feel on the big stage in the biggest H&A game of the season against i side who will come out breathing fire
 
I'd still drop Woey and Williams

In T Cloke King Egan Didak
Out Rocca Wooewodin Williams Davis
 
hotpie said:
I'd still drop Woey and Williams

In T Cloke King Egan Didak
Out Rocca Wooewodin Williams Davis
Click to expand...

you reckon Egan will make the step up?

if woewodin is to be dropped, i dont know if Didak should step straight into the midfield

i dont think Woey will go
 
grayza said:
you reckon Egan will make the step up?

if woewodin is to be dropped, i dont know if Didak should step straight into the midfield

i dont think Woey will go
Click to expand...

Give him a go, he's no different in style to Lovett for Essendon. Just let him go and do his stuff, see how he goes. Didak played on the weekend and kicked a few goals, he'll come straight in.

Or promote H Shaw or even Lonie instead. I don't want to see Woey next Monday.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Next weeks teams vs Essendon

Similar threads

Jen2310
List Mgmt. Future Magpies - Collingwood's Next Generation & Father/Son Prospects
2 3 4
Replies
76
Views
3K
domus
domus

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top