Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread Nick Daicos - Can he be the GTWEB? Part 2

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

You sound like you're arguing with me in a post praising Daicos. Being 3rd or 4th BOG in 3 finals before he even turns 23 is outstanding.
Just adding some more context to your post, as he has a 100% record of being 3rd or 4th BOG in finals games after his debut season.

Dominant in H&A from season 2, and carried form through to then also be in best players in every final (to date) in that period.
 
Just adding some more context to your post, as he has a 100% record of being 3rd or 4th BOG in finals games after his debut season.

Dominant in H&A from season 2, and carried form through to then also be in best players in every final (to date) in that period.
I already added the necessary detail and nuance, so you are shouting at clouds.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Oversight. It brings his votes per game average down a bit. Cheers for notifying me.
You are welcome, nuance is all about the detail 👍

Not sure why anyone would bother to create a per game avg when 50% of his games are from debut season?

The basic is after his debut season, Naicos is now 3 for 3 finals where he has been in the best according to coaches votes.
 
You are welcome, nuance is all about the detail 👍

Not sure why anyone would bother to create a per game avg when 50% of his games are from debut season?

The basic is after his debut season, Naicos is now 3 for 3 finals where he has been in the best according to coaches votes.
You can ignore any post you find no value in. None of this is intended to upset you.
 
True, I could simply choose to ignore your posts that are incomplete and present misleading and incorrect data.

Instead I choose to help you with nailing the finer details. You are welcome 🍻
You're getting pissy for no reason though. You found a missing match later that makes his average worse, when the original post was praising his few matches being in the best handful of players in finals. Yes it was misleading to forget the 2022 SF in which he didn't star. I am very apologetic for praising him too highly.

You are criticising me for including 2022 matches, then criticising me for omitting one of them accidentally. It's unclear what point you really want to make.

Your posting history is so joyless and pedantic.
 
Career AFLCA Gary Ayres Voting - Nick Daicos

2022
SF vs Fremantle: 0 votes
PF vs Sydney: 0 votes
Total: 0 votes

2023
QF vs Melbourne: 0 votes
PF vs GWS: 3 votes
GF vs Brisbane: 6 votes
Total: 9 votes

2024
No Finals Matches

2025
QF vs Adelaide: 5 votes
Total: 5 votes

Total so far: 14 votes (6 games), ave: 2.33 votes.
 
Last edited:
Career AFLCA Gary Ayres Voting - Nick Daicos
2023
QF vs Melbourne: 0 votes
GOATcos is so good, Lunchy is bagging him for failing to get coaches votes in a game he didn't even play in....

You should include finals from 2018, 2019 and 2020, just for the LOLs....
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Career AFLCA Gary Ayres Voting - Nick Daicos

2022
QF vs Geelong: 0 votes
SF vs Fremantle: 0 votes
PF vs Sydney: 0 votes
Total: 0 votes

2023
QF vs Melbourne: 0 votes
PF vs GWS: 3 votes
GF vs Brisbane: 6 votes
Total: 9 votes

2024
No Finals Matches

2025
QF vs Adelaide: 5 votes
Total: 5 votes

Total so far: 14 votes (7 games), ave: 2.0 votes.
You’ve left out the 2012 PF and the 2013 EF
 
GOATcos is so good, Lunchy is bagging him for failing to get coaches votes in a game he didn't even play in....

You should include finals from 2018, 2019 and 2020, just for the LOLs....
I've got an excel table at work that I got right after an initial omission. I might send it to Lunchy to copy it and add in some idiotic blank rows.
 
On the topic of Nick’s finals performances, and more relevant than his debut year, how about this comparison. GH is game high, TH is team high.

Player 1:
29d (GH), 11 CPs (GH-1, TH), 1.1g, 8 SIs (GH-1), 1 GA, 2 clearances, 3 i50s, 444m gained.

Player 2:
30d, 9 CPs, 1g, 11 SIs (GH-1), 0 GA, 5 clearances, 6 i50 (TH), 436m gained.

Player 1 is Nick in the 2023 GF, Player 2 is Ashcroft’s Norm Smith medal game in 2024. Nick was giving first possession to T Mitchell in 2023 so wasn’t high in the clearance game (except THAT famous one). One game was not like the other, make your own conclusions.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

GOATcos is so good, Lunchy is bagging him for failing to get coaches votes in a game he didn't even play in....

You should include finals from 2018, 2019 and 2020, just for the LOLs....
It appears our feline friends think they should be able to post whatever crap they want and not be corrected.
 
It appears our feline friends think they should be able to post whatever crap they want and not be corrected.
Leaving out his 2022 SF brings his voting average up, so if anything my fabrication was designed to give his numbers a boost. You're criticising me for overpraising Daicos.

I would even argue that 2022 results should be removed as it was his first year. Bad faith arguers like you will say "you forgot this 0 vote match in his first year of football - he's not as good as you say he is!". Really poor form by yourself.
 
That was my point.

Disengenuos feline posters attempt to create a career votes per game average, but can't even get the detail right.

Be like Naicos, and be better.
I still argue that his 2022 matches need not be included, but since you are being so pedantic about it, they have to stay. It's designed by you to bring his vote per game average down, but that's because you are quick to criticise Daicos for all sorts of ridiculous reasons. I just think you could stand to argue in better faith.
 
I still argue that his 2022 matches need not be included, but since you are being so pedantic about it, they have to stay. It's designed by you to bring his vote per game average down, but that's because you are quick to criticise Daicos for all sorts of ridiculous reasons. I just think you could stand to argue in better faith.

But if he polled AFLCA Gary Ayres votes in 2022 then his matches would be included by everyone. He didnt get votes in 2022 and thats that unfortunately.
 
It appears our feline friends think they should be able to post whatever crap they want and not be corrected.

What "crap" has Mr Meow said? All he said was that Nick Daicos didnt poll any AFLCA Gary Ayres Award votes for the Finals matches he played in for 2022. That is fact, Mr Meow isn't making this up.

Why can't you accept that? There seems to be a pattern in this thread that whenever people see things differently in regards to Nick Daicos and they put their opinion on here in this thread - a lot of Collingwood supporters get offended? I don't understand why. There's no need to have such an emotional connection to a player.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread Nick Daicos - Can he be the GTWEB? Part 2

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top