Nick Malceski or David Rodan

[scaryness]

Both had the LARs knee surgery and have had great comebacks from them.

Nick Malceski
Career stats:
92 games/42 goals for Sydney
Avg. Disposals: 17.4
Avg. Marks: 4.8
Avg. Tackles: 2

2010 stats:
7 goals, 9 behinds
Avg. Disposals: 22.6
Avg. Marks: 5.3
Avg. Tackles: 2.5
140 contested possessions
116 rebound 50s

David Rodan
Career stats:
65 games/43 goals for Richmond
85 games/73 goals for Port Adelaide
150 games/116 goals overall
Avg. disposals: 14
Avg. Marks: 2
Avg. Tackles: 3

2010 stats:
10 goals, 12 behinds
Avg. disposals: 16.7
Avg. Marks: 1.5
Avg. Tackles: 5.2
145 contested possessions
80 clearances
58 inside 50's

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Malceski hasn't had a relapse, so it's a pretty easy choice...

 

[Schulzenfest]

I love the D-Rod, but had to go with Malceski.

 

[Dangas]

Eski, unbiased opinion