Nick Riewoldt

[krusden]

On your basis, being that midfielders are a dime-a-dozen, riewoldt therefore would be the number one player picked in the league. Under your basis Geelong should struggle as we have no stand out key forward.
Yet lets look at the facts, the saints winning ratio was no worse when he was out than when he played. Ablett has led his team to the last three grand finals and we have won two of those. Roo has lead his team to one, for no cigar. Roo is a mile behind ablett in both impact and in importance.

.... when was tom harley replaced as captain by garry ablett jr?

 

[Alatna]

Roo is a great player. Let's leave it at that.

Threads like this annoy me. In the words of Paul Dempsey:

Cause I know no quicker way, dear
To the shiny gates of hell
Than a room full of handsome devils
Comparing everything to everything else