AFLW NMFC AFLW [Season 2022]

[Luke72]

Carey never polled particularly well in the Brownlow despite being recognised as the best player.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Kearney and Bruton are jets
Our midfield with those 2 garner, riddell with gavalas and Mia king rotating through is easily the best in the comp

 

[The Nostradamus]

Well that wraps up the 2020 season

Anyone know when the aflw draft is this year?

Assuming we take 3 picks we will need to cull 3 players

Wonder if there’s room to poach a star player and trade away our first pick. We are in premiership mode so would make sense

 

[Colbys Boots]

Well that wraps up the 2020 season

Anyone know when the aflw draft is this year?

Assuming we take 3 picks we will need to cull 3 players

Wonder if there’s room to poach a star player and trade away our first pick. We are in premiership mode so would make sense

The AFL didn't recognise Freo and North Melbourne as the clear best two teams when it was obvious to everyone that they had one week to conclude the season. Yet they will inevitably punish both clubs by dropping them to the bottom of the draft order. How does that work?

 

[Colbys Boots]

Same as the men’s the umpires are the wrong people to be doing the votes. Probably should be the coaches.

So what you're saying is the AFLCA MVP is the only credible award? I agree.

 

[DEVO]

North Melbourne Kangaroos leaderboard
Emma Kearney 11 votes
Jenna Bruton 10
Jas Garner 4
Kaitlyn Ashmore 2
Vivien Saad 2
Ash Riddell 1

Would like to see the round by round votes.

I wouldn't be surprised if three Richmond players got the votes after our 56pt win, the Umpires have no idea what was going on the field. Would explain some of the officiating during the game as well.

 

[DarwinRoo]

So a possible 30 votes out of 36. The Melbourne game maybe the only game where we didn’t poll any votes.

 

[Luke72]

So what you're saying is the AFLCA MVP is the only credible award? I agree.

Coaches have a better understanding of who is influencing the game. It might finally turn it away from a midfielders award.

 

[DarwinRoo]

 

[muttley45]

Did Richmond even win a game ? Conti with 7 votes and Garner only 4 seems legit

 

[The Warlord]

Disgraceful, fine, she wasn't guaranteed to win, but 4 votes?

 

[King Corey]

AFLPA AFLW MVP
413 votes: Jasmine Garner (North Melbourne)
227 votes: Madison Prespakis (Carlton)

vs

AFLW Best and Fairest top 10
Madison Prespakis (Carlton) 15 votes
...
Jas Garner 4

 

[scottywiper]

I understand the umps getting it wrong in the Brownlow...the men's game moves very fast and it is a midfielder medal the way the game is played these days.
The women's game at this stage moves much slower and the gap in ability between the players is very pronounced. The best players really stand out.
You only have to watch five minutes of North to know Garner is a class above her team-mates and most of the league.
I'm not sure how the umps could miss her so badly.

 

[La Flama Blanca]

Prespakis is a deserving winner, but wowee that's an uncomfortably low tally for Garner.

 

[DEVO]

Prespakis is a deserving winner, but wowee that's an uncomfortably low tally for Garner.

Embarrassingly low. Surely this shows that the umpires are not capable of officiating and rating a players performance at the same time. Even at AFLW level.

Ash Riddell only receiving one vote is a little weird as well.

 

[Luke72]

I reckon Bowers was better than Prespakis too. Goes to show you’re better off a good player in a poor team.

 

[DEVO]

Our Round by Round votes
ROUND ONE
Melbourne v North Melbourne
3. E.O’Dea (Melb)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. K.Hore (Melb)

ROUND TWO
North Melbourne v Greater Western Sydney
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Parker (GWS)

ROUND THREE
Richmond v North Melbourne
3. E.Kearney (Kang)
2. V.Saad (Kang)
1. J.Bruton (Kang)

ROUND FOUR
North Melbourne v Gold Coast
3. J.Garner (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Riddell (Kang)

ROUND FIVE
North Melbourne v Adelaide
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. K.Ashmore (Kang)
1. J.Garner (Kang)

ROUND SIX
Geelong v North Melbourne
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.O’Connor (Geel)

 

[The Nostradamus]

Lol round 6 Aasta got a vote for 10 touches in the ruck losing team 46 points

Garner 3 goals 18 touches Winning team that game got nothing

Round 1 i‘d argue garner was better than all 3 that got votes bar maybe hore

 

[SMaturin]

Our Round by Round votes
ROUND ONE
Melbourne v North Melbourne
3. E.O’Dea (Melb)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. K.Hore (Melb)

ROUND TWO
North Melbourne v Greater Western Sydney
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Parker (GWS)

ROUND THREE
Richmond v North Melbourne
3. E.Kearney (Kang)
2. V.Saad (Kang)
1. J.Bruton (Kang)

ROUND FOUR
North Melbourne v Gold Coast
3. J.Garner (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Riddell (Kang)

ROUND FIVE
North Melbourne v Adelaide
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. K.Ashmore (Kang)
1. J.Garner (Kang)

ROUND SIX
Geelong v North Melbourne
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.O’Connor (Geel)

wot

 

[Luke72]

wot

I know, I still reckon we were the better team for most of that game, just couldn’t get the score on the board.

 

[jarrod_island_doggies]

Our Round by Round votes
ROUND ONE
Melbourne v North Melbourne
3. E.O’Dea (Melb)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. K.Hore (Melb)

ROUND TWO
North Melbourne v Greater Western Sydney
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Parker (GWS)

ROUND THREE
Richmond v North Melbourne
3. E.Kearney (Kang)
2. V.Saad (Kang)
1. J.Bruton (Kang)

ROUND FOUR
North Melbourne v Gold Coast
3. J.Garner (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.Riddell (Kang)

ROUND FIVE
North Melbourne v Adelaide
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. K.Ashmore (Kang)
1. J.Garner (Kang)

ROUND SIX
Geelong v North Melbourne
3. J.Bruton (Kang)
2. E.Kearney (Kang)
1. A.O’Connor (Geel)

Ash no votes against Richmond...

areyouhavingalaugh.gif

 

[north_lad]

What the hell hahahahaha

 

[Hearts to hearts]

I reckon Bowers was better than Prespakis too. Goes to show you’re better off a good player in a poor team.

And men’s game or women’s, it helps to be a #1 draft pick. Great story with Huntingdon but I don’t know how that Saints AA forward wasn’t rookie of the year either.

 

[Teen Wolf]

Lol round 6 Aasta got a vote for 10 touches in the ruck losing team 46 points

On top of that, one of the dirtier players going around.

"Aasta O’Connor (Geelong) has been charged with Striking Vivien Saad (North Melbourne) during the fourth quarter of the match between Geelong and North Melbourne at GMHBA Stadium on Friday, March 13. The incident was classified as a $1,100 sanction as a third offence for the season."

 

[DEVO]

Some in the press noticed Garner's snub as well.

Jasmine Garner overlooked by umpires in AFLW best and fairest award despite dominant season