You clearly don't know the rules. It doesn't matter one iota that Polec's hand ended up around Shuey's neck. The rule states that if the tackle starts legally and the person being tackled forces the tackler's arm up it's play on. Take a look at the AFL interpretation video and STFU!
Your a funny little clown, disagree if you like, the fact is in the day when things were straight forward instead of grey areas everywhere around the neck was around the neck , if your opponent beat you to the ball , as Shuey did then tough luck tackler!!!!!!!, and then you start raving about the written rules as they sit now, that no one, even f******g umpires can correctly interperate all the time .
So you go and have another look, and you make a decision in a tenth of a second , and you watch the replay that says it all , both players are buckle legged, so both dipping, maybe the Port bloke thought Shuey was going to duck, so evened up the contest , and by the way he scragged him around the neck and if the rule states that if it starts legal it finishes legal, that's the greatest load of garbage you've ever said, because if it started legal then it wasn't a free , but the umpires( 2 of them) saw the around the neck , bad luck, the other prancer saw nothing.
And this happens all the bleeding time!!?????
Don't talk to me about bloody rules .
I've been complaining about ducking for years, Selwood is a bleeding disgrace, by the way he's practised and practised his knee drop shoulder dip, its an art form for him and wrong. And some others have taken it on.
Its a grey interpretation for an umpire to make?
So you get and read all my posts, good ones and bad ones, quick ones and rants , but read them all, or you
Shut The F**k Up .
You rude individual. If you want a debate have one , not every body will agree with you and maybe , just maybe you are wrong sometimes, brother , me too, ever thought of that.
Maybe instead of STFU you should GrowTFU.
Why finish with a comment like that , you and I don't know each other from a bar of soap! Fair dinkum mate!