Opinion Non-Crows AFL 8 - Daddy Donuts Delivers Dream Drubbing

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

A Collingwood win will all be worth it if they drop Mason Cox for the final
 
Missed 7 clear free kicks for GWS
Could probably say the same for Collingwood.


The chop of arm when NDaicos juggled the mark.

GWS player blocking a mark contest on the wing.

Why was Cox told to leave the ground to change jumper?


Umpires weren't great, but not really biased.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Giants got dudded. High tackling now legal apparently

Giants were also given a very soft 50 that gave them a goal.

There was a couple of kicks missed, but the frees were 12 all and GWS received 3 50 metre penalties to 1.

I think the umpiring after starting a bit rough ended up being pretty even.
 
Great game of footy..

pies deserve to play in the GF.. been the best team for the majority of the year.

Giants have been great the last month or so though.. they’ll take this sting and use it to motivate them next year.
This would've been my pick for best GF match up on form. I see Collingwood blowing out whoever wins the other one next week.
 
Giants were also given a very soft 50 that gave them a goal.

There was a couple of kicks missed, but the frees were 12 all and GWS received 3 50 metre penalties to 1.

I think the umpiring after starting a bit rough ended up being pretty even.
I agree, umpires always put the whistle away in finals like that too, that wasn't a GWS thing.

But there is nothing surer now than the AFL wanting Carlton in the final. Brisbane will get reamed.
 
Prelims are always more entertaining than the grand final. The GF always seems to be a boring blowout in comparison.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

No they weren't. GWS were trying to get it out. Why on earth do you think they were jumping on it. Collingwood literally spent 3 minutes doing what the afl dont want, diving on the contest. It was horrendous umpiring.
Last two minutes

1.58 GWS player receives ball takes on two straight to ground in backline

1.37 GWS on wing ball receive straight to ground.


Both sides doing it to create stoppage when there isn't a clean out.


Neither side could waste time. Both trying to score late.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Giants were also given a very soft 50 that gave them a goal.

There's nothing hard or soft about those fifties. There's a clear rule, and they're automatic. There's not supposed to be discretion.
 
What? Are you saying a former 100 goal full forward in a Collingwood premiership year wasn’t entirely impartial in a Collingwood preliminary final?

Surely not! 😂😂

Is that bias?

He just has a weird obsession with people not being on the bench, and fixates on it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top