Opinion Non-Crows AFL 9

[FR0GGY]

Even our "Crows fans" midfield is poor. Not a bad forward line though...

Surely chuck Mackie on the ball and fire Hampton into the Sun?

 

[TRP1996]

First time I’ve thought of Jordan Murdoch

31

Jordan Murdoch

Age

33

Ht

190cm

Wt

87kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

13.9

4star

K

8.3

3star

HB

5.6

4star

M

3.5

4star

T

3.4

5star

MG

273.3

4star

No current season stats available

D

13.8

4star

K

8.2

4star

HB

5.6

4star

M

4.0

4star

T

3.0

5star

in quite some time.

 

[ltdamn]

Always remember this from 1997 and the Andrew Mackie story. Such a smooth looking player.
I always thought the Crows never took the draft seriously and preferred to exchange picks for average players. The swap of pick 12 to PA in 2000 for Bode and they picked up Burgoyne with that pick. Kane Cornes later on.


View attachment 1830148
View attachment 1830153

Never knew about Jesse Hogan supporting the Crows.

 

[FR0GGY]

Never knew about Jesse Hogan supporting the Crows.

There was talk here at one stage about this, I reckon before he went to freo?

 

[50BC]

HAHAHAHA

Gunston wants to return to Hawthorn

Crikey! You would have thought he was fully weaned by now, but apparently not. What ridiculous little man

 

[El Doederino]

Doesn’t Geelong have a preseason draft pick ahead of Port, so if he wants to go down this path they can pick him up anyway?

Can someone do me a Craig David and fill me in?

 

[PeterSalt]

Doesn’t Geelong have a preseason draft pick ahead of Geelong, so if he wants to go down this path they can pick him up anyway?

Can someone do me a Craig David and fill me in?

More likely the ND

 

[dogs105]

Doesn’t Geelong have a preseason draft pick ahead of Geelong, so if he wants to go down this path they can pick him up anyway?

Can someone do me a Craig David and fill me in?

Geelong's PSD pick is the same time as Geelong's.

 

[El Doederino]

Geelong's PSD pick is the same time as Geelong's.

Please don’t amend my posts to make me look stupid

 

[dogs105]

Doesn’t Geelong have a preseason draft pick ahead of Port, so if he wants to go down this path they can pick him up anyway?

Can someone do me a Craig David and fill me in?

I believe Geelong have a PSD pick ahead of Port.

 

[Mr_Moogle]

Hang on… where’s Mitch McGovern?

Kane's sharing his pr0n.

 

[DJ75]

Hang on… where’s Mitch McGovern?

Kane a bit thirsty?

 

[ams4crows]

Kane a bit thirsty?

Would you call Rohan a specimen?? I know my list would look a lot different to his....

 

[DJ75]

Would you call Rohan a specimen?? I know my list would look a lot different to his....

Not a list I would spend anytime on what so ever.

 

[StonesThrow]

I reckon Harley Reid JHF match up would be pretty good to watch in coming years.

 

[Vader]

I believe Geelong have a PSD pick ahead of Port.

They do... but is anyone really stupid enough to think that they'd select Ratugolea, just to spite him & Port?

 

[adelaidecrows]

They do... but is anyone really stupid enough to think that they'd select Ratugolea, just to spite him & Port?

I think they will trade him for Ports second round offer. Geelong have been over playing their hand acting like a petulant child. How many players and I mean star players have they poached from sides for minimal outlay? Geelong need to let him go.

 

[Crowked]

I think they will trade him for Ports second round offer. Geelong have been over playing their hand acting like a petulant child. How many players and I mean star players have they poached from sides for minimal outlay? Geelong need to let him go.

im not sure what’s more puzzling, Ports desperate need to get him or Geelongs reluctance to let him go.

He’s very bloody average. Doesn’t make much difference to Geelong and won’t make much difference to Port either.

 

[daniel_4tw]

I just don’t get why Port didn’t negotiate prior to trading their F1. It’s like they traded in the picks they think would get it done, and now Geel have said no, they’re up the creek. They could have gotten more than what they did if they held off…

 

[Bearded Clam]

I just don’t get why Port didn’t negotiate prior to trading their F1. It’s like they traded in the picks they think would get it done, and now Geel have said no, they’re up the creek. They could have gotten more than what they did if they held off…

It is increasingly sounding like geelong told them that their F1 is what Rat is worth and is what geelong will be asking for..

not only that.. geelong told them this for weeks or possibly months in advance..

and the arrogant flog Chris Davies decided that the best course of action would then be to trade their F1 (which they did in a deal that was just horrible value for them) and then turn to geelong and say “sorry, F1 is now gone, you can have the 23 we got with it”.. thinking geelong would simply accept that.

its backfired massively..

suck sh*t to them. Port need to learn that not everyone is gonna put up with their scummy behaviour..

 

[Sanders]

Port can walk him through the ND (not PSD) with pick 24

An option not available to teams looking to trade future picks for players

 

[MarcusP2]

Port can walk him through the ND (not PSD) with pick 24

An option not available to teams looking to trade future picks for players

Luke Ball style.

 

[Crow_68]

It is increasingly sounding like geelong told them that their F1 is what Rat is worth and is what geelong will be asking for..

not only that.. geelong told them this for weeks or possibly months in advance..

and the arrogant flog Chris Davies decided that the best course of action would then be to trade their F1 (which they did in a deal that was just horrible value for them) and then turn to geelong and say “sorry, F1 is now gone, you can have the 23 we got with it”.. thinking geelong would simply accept that.

its backfired massively..

suck sh*t to them. Port need to learn that not everyone is gonna put up with their scummy behaviour..

That pick 23 is already at 25 and will likely become 27 during the draft (GC only have one matching pick before).

So it was 2024/1, which could easily fall in the 8-12 range, for Freo’s 2024/2 (in the mid-late 20s) and potentially pick 27.

They haven’t played this well at all.

 

[adelaidecrows]

im not sure what’s more puzzling, Ports desperate need to get him or Geelongs reluctance to let him go.

He’s very bloody average. Doesn’t make much difference to Geelong and won’t make much difference to Port either.

This is what makes me think Geelong are posturing. They will ride this out to the 11th hour before magically agreeing. Port are offering way overs here as it is to help Geelong play ball. Geelong just playing the game for more.

 

[adelaidecrows]

That pick 23 is already at 25 and will likely become 27 during the draft (GC only have one matching pick before).

So it was 2024/1, which could easily fall in the 8-12 range, for Freo’s 2024/2 (in the mid-late 20s) and potentially pick 27.

They haven’t played this well at all.

It is increasingly sounding like geelong told them that their F1 is what Rat is worth and is what geelong will be asking for..

not only that.. geelong told them this for weeks or possibly months in advance..

and the arrogant flog Chris Davies decided that the best course of action would then be to trade their F1 (which they did in a deal that was just horrible value for them) and then turn to geelong and say “sorry, F1 is now gone, you can have the 23 we got with it”.. thinking geelong would simply accept that.

its backfired massively..

suck sh*t to them. Port need to learn that not everyone is gonna put up with their scummy behaviour..

Just because Geelong has a demand, Port are under no obligation to meet it. Clearly F1 was a joke and Rat is not even close to being worth a 3rd rounder on a good day. They were never ever going to get f1 even if Rat was their only target. Geelong know this. They are just wanting to see what else Port will offer.

Also if this draft is so poor, just a thought, does that mean Reid could turn into a bust and purely be over rated?