Oppo Camp Non Geelong football (AFL) discussion 2021

[geelong_crazy26]

Do you also have Rowan Marshall - I know they say 1 month, but a stress injury in the foot, isn't necessarily the easiest if injuries to overcome

ST KILDA has been dealt a major blow with ruckman Rowan Marshall to miss the start of the 2021 season with a stress injury in his foot.

Marshall will be sidelined for at least the next month – that coincides with round one – with hope he will ramp up his recovery soon after.

nah don’t have him. Not many good ruckman at a low to moderate price. Didn’t go the pricey lock n forget of gawn or grundy like the world does. Will have to wait for pre season to see who to pick now. Maybe I will just throw in GWS replacement ruck now.

 

[you pick one]

I reckon he looks really good. Has talent and seems cocky enough to use it a lot.
That new guy Footscray has that we should've got is meant to be the next Buddy apparently.
So Izac might have some competition.

Imagine if he was allowed the the Buddy natural arc with the new rule where the man guarding the mark is super glue to the spot.

 

[Spazz Cat]

Imagine if he was allowed the the Buddy natural arc with the new rule where the man guarding the mark is super glue to the spot.

That's a good point. Everyone should develop natural arcs

 

[you pick one]

That's a good point. Everyone should develop natural arcs

Miers should be the first to apply.

 

[Down at K Park]

Needs a shoulder reconstruction, with recovery is expected to take four to five months.

This is good for us, because we have gws second round pick. I don’t think they have any other established rucks on their list. Bar mumford, who is so cooked the pot is melting. So they will probably play a novice ruck, or play a key position player as ruck. The further they slide, the better.

 

[cats_09]

This is good for us, because we have gws second round pick. I don’t think they have any other established rucks on their list. Bar mumford, who is so cooked the pot is melting. So they will probably play a novice ruck, or play a key position player as ruck. The further they slide, the better.

They have 34yr old Mumford ready to shoulder the load (pardon the pun)

 

[geelong_crazy26]

This is good for us, because we have gws second round pick. I don’t think they have any other established rucks on their list. Bar mumford, who is so cooked the pot is melting. So they will probably play a novice ruck, or play a key position player as ruck. The further they slide, the better.

they will be a bottom 8 side. sh*t coach, bleeded all the talent that has propt them up solo all those years.

things will get ugly quickly for them.

 

[Spazz Cat]

Miers should be the first to apply.

Not wrong.

 

[Down at K Park]

They have 34yr old Mumford ready to shoulder the load (pardon the pun)

I’ve never seen a footy player more cooked. He could barely even run last year. His ankles are stuffed.

they will be a bottom 8 side. sh*t coach, bleeded all the talent that has propt them up solo all those years.

things will get ugly quickly for them.

Let’s hope so. Means a better pick for us. And i do see them sliding further as well. Lost too many good players now.

 

[Premi3rship]

Shae McNamara is teeing off...

 

[goyoucatters]

Shae McNamara is teeing off...

So he's American. And he never played a game or kicked a goal. Which means you can easily imagine how 'understanding' the court of public opinion here in Australia is likely to be of his viewpoint...

 

[Premi3rship]

So he's American. And he never played a game or kicked a goal. Which means you can easily imagine how 'understanding' the court of public opinion here in Australia is likely to be of his viewpoint...

True.
Whether or not he played a game he was there though. Genuinely interested to see what Collingwood do with this. One thing I liked about Shae's thread was the insistence it was a case of righting the ship, not trashing a legacy. All clubs should stay on top of that stuff. Footy clubs at all levels should be about bringing communities together.

 

[goyoucatters]

True.
Whether or not he played a game he was there though. Genuinely interested to see what Collingwood do with this. One thing I liked about Shae's thread was the insistence it was a case of righting the ship, not trashing a legacy. All clubs should stay on top of that stuff. Footy clubs at all levels should be about bringing communities together.

I agree with all that you've said. I was simply making the point that those who want to endorse the status quo will denigrate his opinion on the basis that he wasn't a player of any note. Which of course has precisely nothing to do with whether his view is worthy of serious consideration.

 

[Partridge]

So he's American. And he never played a game or kicked a goal. Which means you can easily imagine how 'understanding' the court of public opinion here in Australia is likely to be of his viewpoint...

Not sure about that. Most people from what I can tell have been dead against Collingwood.

I've never heard of him.

 

[Turkey Tom]

So he's American. And he never played a game or kicked a goal. Which means you can easily imagine how 'understanding' the court of public opinion here in Australia is likely to be of his viewpoint...

Seems he was on Collingwood's list.

" McNamara is the fifth player to be born in the United States to be associated with an AFL club and the first American-born player to play for Collingwood "

Seamus McNamara - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[FredLeDeux]

Seems he was on Collingwood's list.

" McNamara is the fifth player to be born in the United States to be associated with an AFL club and the first American-born player to play for Collingwood "

Seamus McNamara - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Except for some bloke named O'Brien

 

[you pick one]

Except for some bloke named O'Brien

Isn't he Brazilian.

 

[Spazz Cat]

Isn't he Brazilian.

That is American. South American.

 

[catscollector]

you replied to tell me he won’t be a generational player because his short?? Wonderful detailed insights as always

Mate, your hopeless at rating talent. Rankine is a fu*king gun but a once-in-a-generational talent? Give me a break.
I'd pick Ben King to have the better career when all is said and done.

 

[Down at K Park]

So jarrod roughhead broke a st kilda players leg in a tackle. Thug still causing carnage after retirement.

 

[BIGANT]

Those that are interested with r1 not too far away vs the crows...they've an internal trial on tomorrow morning 10 or 11am start. Crows media will be streaming it on there website.

 

[David the Cat]

Mate, your hopeless at rating talent. Rankine is a fu*king gun but a once-in-a-generational talent? Give me a break.
I'd pick Ben King to have the better career when all is said and done.

+ geelong_crazy26

You're both entitled to an opinion...try and express your own without shitcanning another's opinion simply because it doesn't align with yours.

Solve this problem between you yourselves...unless of course you want moderators to solve it for you?

This regular and totally unnecessary sniping between the both of you simply won't cut it this year.

I'd direct you to the ignore function but I'm sure you're acquainted with it already.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Weitering wins the Blues B&F.

 

[cats_09]

Weitering wins the Blues B&F.

And 7 asks if that makes him the best defender in the game

 

[cats_09]