Remove this Banner Ad

Non Lions Discussion 2026

  • Thread starter Thread starter 010203
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I know I'm biased, but is any Carlton player actually good enough to be in our best 23 right now ?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I know I'm biased, but is any Carlton player actually good enough to be in our best 23 right now ?

Forklift weitering
Le pittonet de Gaul on a good night

END of list.
 
Give me dizzy and froggy over Forklift any day. Forklift will bankrupt the club because he'll kick on an obvious phishing email and somehow drain the club's coffers.

It’s why Chris Scott got him involved in the origin team. He planned to phish forklift to boost Geelong’s coffers.
 
Give me dizzy and froggy over Forklift any day. Forklift will bankrupt the club because he'll kick on an obvious phishing email and somehow drain the club's coffers.
My biggest criticism of Weitering is that nearly every time I have seen him play, he plays selfishly in the sense that his only goal is to make sure his direct opponent wont get a touch. He doesn't seem to leave his direct opponent often to get involved in the play and help his teammates out. Very much a yeah we lost but my opponent didn't kick any, so if all you guys shut down your guy like I did then we would be fine. I have seen him let player/s streak towards goal when he was the closest Carlton player that should've been attempting to do something. Instead he just sits on his man and an easy goal is kicked.
 
Carlton are the most "finish 13th" team in the comp. They'll bully the apocalyptically shit teams like West Coast and North but once they come up against a team that can put pace on the ball and expose their slow midfield they'll fall apart.

Luckily they've got plenty of prime time night games because it wouldn't shock me if they melted in the sun.
 
My biggest criticism of Weitering is that nearly every time I have seen him play, he plays selfishly in the sense that his only goal is to make sure his direct opponent wont get a touch. He doesn't seem to leave his direct opponent often to get involved in the play and help his teammates out. Very much a yeah we lost but my opponent didn't kick any, so if all you guys shut down your guy like I did then we would be fine. I have seen him let player/s streak towards goal when he was the closest Carlton player that should've been attempting to do something. Instead he just sits on his man and an easy goal is kicked.

Has no attacking capability either. In that we got Zac out of Schache, I reckon we won the 1-2 comparison in that draft.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

My biggest criticism of Weitering is that nearly every time I have seen him play, he plays selfishly in the sense that his only goal is to make sure his direct opponent wont get a touch. He doesn't seem to leave his direct opponent often to get involved in the play and help his teammates out. Very much a yeah we lost but my opponent didn't kick any, so if all you guys shut down your guy like I did then we would be fine. I have seen him let player/s streak towards goal when he was the closest Carlton player that should've been attempting to do something. Instead he just sits on his man and an easy goal is kicked.

This is EXACTLY his MO and it is why his AA jumper over Harris was so egregious. Yeah, he had great defensive stats in 2024 individually but Carlton as a team had the worst defensive record of any team that played finals.

They conceded the 5th most points against that season, only conceding less than Richmond, norf, west coast and essendon!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom