Analysis Non-Swans - GAMEDAY DISCUSSION

[mikey_san]

Leon the master coach has taken Zac Williams from one of the best running half backs in the comp to a completely absent forward.
What a dickhead. Williams spent about quarter at half back and looked great. The rest of the time he may as well be in a Carlton cafe.
THIS IS COSTING ME SUPERCOACH POINTS Leon !

 

[robbieando]

This GWS team is done as a group.
Dismantling them & rebuilding will be what's needed now.
Too many big heads & egos.

2013

There is genuine ill-feeling in the Swans playing group about their cross town rivals. Ben McGlynn in particular will be keen to make an impression on the Giants after defender Tom Bugg sledged him in their round one match in 2013 asking him where his premiership medal was?

Maybe we should ask to see where all their medals are.....oh right

2016/2017

Mumford made light of Franklin's mental health issues

and

Sledging was again an issue; GWS veteran Heath Shaw apologised after calling Tom Papley a "f***ing *".

Such leadership at this franchise, no wonder it has rubbed off with the stellar leadership example from Coniglio.

 

[swanssince2002]

Stick a knife with this Giants core tbh. They spent their energy trying to make it last year and since they fell well short in the GF they never recovered. Like worse than 2014 bad. At least we won it 2 years earlier.

 

[caesar88]

Jack Steele has been the best player in the comp this year IMO

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Stick a knife with this Giants core tbh. They spent their energy trying to make it last year and since they fell well short in the GF they never recovered. Like worse than 2014 bad. At least we won it 2 years earlier.

Victorian clubs will be circling like vultures around a carcass.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Jack Steele has been the best player in the comp this year IMO

From GWS academy.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Hanners back into finals action

 

[caesar88]

From GWS academy.

Missed opportunity for us

 

[bedford]

Jack Steele has been the best player in the comp this year IMO

IMHO he has not , but been St Scums best

 

[S120]

Hanners back into finals action

Must be honest, although it was delightful to see him so happy, it hurt a little to see him so jubilant in another jumper.

 

[bedford]

Must be honest, although it was delightful to see him so happy, it hurt a little to see him so jubilant in another jumper.

This

 

[Tedeski]

IMHO he has not , but been St Scums best

Best player in a team that's made the finals because of an ********* year due to Covid.
In a format that suits the more seasoned clubs with more seasoned players.
Cats, Tigers, Saints, Port, West Coast, Pies.
Brisbane & Dogs have done well as they have relatively young lists.
Just my opinion of course.

2020 Asterisk Football League Premiership Season

 

[bedford]

Best player in a team that's made the finals because of an ********* year due to Covid.
In a format that suits the more seasoned clubs with more seasoned players.
Cats, Tigers, Saints, Port, West Coast, Pies.
Brisbane & Dogs have done well as they have relatively young lists.
Just my opinion of course.

2020 Asterisk Football League Premiership Season

Asterisk ! will be one of the great wins whoever wins it and hopefully that's not the Filth ,Saints , Port , Bulldogs, WC

 

[MarkP]

Best player in a team that's made the finals because of an ********* year due to Covid.
In a format that suits the more seasoned clubs with more seasoned players.
Cats, Tigers, Saints, Port, West Coast, Pies.
Brisbane & Dogs have done well as they have relatively young lists.
Just my opinion of course.

2020 Asterisk Football League Premiership Season

Everyone played under the same rules. Whoever wins it does so with full validity. Specious argument, if we were in it we would take it and rightly so.

 

[caesar88]

Everyone played under the same rules. Whoever wins it does so with full validity. Specious argument, if we were in it we would take it and rightly so.

Uhhhh actually that's not the case at all. Brisbane & Gold Coast have had basically the entire season in their home state. The NSW clubs got, what, five home games? The Perth clubs got to play in front of 30,000 fans while the Victorian clubs played to empty stadiums in the few weeks they actually got home games.

If there's anything this season's rules haven't been, it's consistent. And I get it, it had to be done this way if a season was to be played and the profits were to be made. But this season has been a joke from the get-go.

 

[bedford]

Uhhhh actually that's not the case at all. Brisbane & Gold Coast have had basically the entire season in their home state. The NSW clubs got, what, five home games? The Perth clubs got to play in front of 30,000 fans while the Victorian clubs played to empty stadiums in the few weeks they actually got home games.

If there's anything this season's rules haven't been, it's consistent. And I get it, it had to be done this way if a season was to be played and the profits were to be made. But this season has been a joke from the get-go.

SWESS

 

[swansfan51]

And I get it, it had to be done this way if a season was to be played and the profits were to be made.

Serious LOL if you think the AFL is making a profit this year.

 

[caesar88]

Serious LOL if you think the AFL is making a profit this year.

Haha yeah profit wasn't the right word. More like 'avoidance of a total and insurmountable loss that would never be recovered from'.

 

[ScrewInStuds]

I'm actually looking forward to seeing Melbourne play Essendon today to try and keep their finals hopes alive; when a stoppable force meets a moveable object.

 

[dosser]

I'm actually looking forward to seeing Melbourne play Essendon today to try and keep their finals hopes alive; when a stoppable force meets a moveable object.

I think the ball will be bounced and all the players will stand around it while the most adventurous ruckman gives it a nudge with his toe to see what happens.

 

[Kapers]

Essendons premiership window is so far open that its gone through time a space to be firmly closed once again.

North and essedon to be competing for the wooden spoon next year

 

[bedford]

Essendons premiership window is so far open that its gone through time a space to be firmly closed once again.

North and essedon to be competing for the wooden spoon next year

I bet you Essendons not

 

[Tedeski]

Yeah nah!
* for me.
That's how I feel about it, that's all. No big deal really.

 

[ScrewInStuds]

Hawthorn and Norf will be bottom 2 in 2021 imo

 

[caesar88]

I think West Coast, North Melbourne, Richmond, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, Gold Coast, St Kilda, Fremantle, Collingwood, Brisbane, Adelaide, Carlton, Essendon, Geelong, Western Bulldogs, Melbourne and GWS will all be in the bottom seventeen next year.