Now they love us

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Oct 24, 2008
Posts
1,056
Likes
781
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Arsenal
#27
The majority of the media have have no real insight and don't really care to thoroughly analyse anyone but the top sides, their favourite teams and their players , preferring instead ride the waves of fashionable opinion that they manufacture themselves half the time, perpetuating myths so they can lazily fall back on them instead of doing any real research or work and instigating beat-ups....a bunch of shallow, reactionary wankers and glorified gossip columnists ..:thumbsdown:
this.
this, this, this, this, this!!
i was going to write my own comment about how i've turned off the views of journos over the past year and a half, but this says it so perfectly.
rating less and less what they have to say, questioning more, finding more fault, wasting less time reading it.
having said that, bigfooty isn't exactly a better place to hear legitimate and justified opinion, haha.
 
Joined
Sep 22, 2009
Posts
233
Likes
38
Location
Rowville
AFL Club
Richmond
#28
Still believe we can make the 8 obviously I am delusional but in reality I believe in what we are doing I was told weeks ago that 8 wins is our target so lets see. I love all that has begun to happen wait to you all see what Ive seen, Can we really make the 8 probably not but while we are winning anything is possible. I told Ben C and he laughed until I said until we cant we can. And what about the cuz almost back to his best making the play hitting targets with precision and most of all smiling while doing it.
 

gaelictiogar

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Apr 23, 2006
Posts
8,358
Likes
3,405
Location
east melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
#29
I dont see the same negative agenda towards Richmond that others do.

If we are not performing then there are few on field positives to talk about and the negatives are the only things that will keep us in the papers.

If we ever rise up the ladder they will sell the shit out of it. I always thought Channel 7 pumps us up when we are worth being pumped up.

Guys like Parko and BT just playing devils advocate to lame ex players who have just joined the media on good money to just call every young player a future champion.
I agree. There is no media bias against Richmond. The Victorian media and the media in general would like to see an up and running Richmond because they coud sell the story. Melbourne jump into contention....so what? North get going....so what? Richmond get going....headline copy!!!!
 

coke_zero

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Posts
7,639
Likes
54
Location
chadstone
AFL Club
Richmond
#30
Still believe we can make the 8 obviously I am delusional but in reality I believe in what we are doing I was told weeks ago that 8 wins is our target so lets see. I love all that has begun to happen wait to you all see what Ive seen, Can we really make the 8 probably not but while we are winning anything is possible. I told Ben C and he laughed until I said until we cant we can. And what about the cuz almost back to his best making the play hitting targets with precision and most of all smiling while doing it.
calm down, 8 wins would be massive. Dont think we will get 8 though. Lets think about finals next year.
 

TigerGlory

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Posts
7,726
Likes
956
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Bonbeach Sharks
#31
YES!! finally some sense we dont have to waste the year lets just try the kids and play them at all costs to see if they are any good the wins will look after themselves
We're pumping games into the kids anyway.

We are winning games by playing kids, Damo is awarding the best players with gametime. We want to install a successful culture. So wins are paramount. I dont want to be the side tanking for draft picks, because its not always fool proof and we dont need to embarrass the club that way.

Everybody getting a game deserves one at the moment. Whilst I agree that we should be pumping games into kids, we should also be continuing to reward the guys who work hard and keep performing with games. Playing guys in the 1s just because they are kids dosent really instill a hard working culture. Everybody should be made to earn and then keep their spot in the side, regardless of whether they are 18 or 30. :thumbsu:
 

MightyTiger

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jun 21, 2010
Posts
8,185
Likes
7,186
AFL Club
Richmond
#32
One player i would love to see given a few games is taylor.

I think this kid could be something special, and is exactly what we need.
 
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Posts
225
Likes
2
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
#33
The season is shot and finals out of reach. I am sure Damien has the bigger picture in sight. Rest some kids try a few others to see how they go and get the best possible pick in this draft.
 

doddy87

Senior List
Joined
Apr 14, 2009
Posts
294
Likes
36
AFL Club
Richmond
#34
now that is tanking and exactly what us pro tankers are on about.
the season is shot play as many kids as possible play them in different positions lets see what they have to offer.
tambling is one who has supposedly had injury all yr send him of for an early break or operation or whatever. dont rush foley back give him the extra time those who need ops can go early give cuz a break play morton midfield etc etc its the ideal time to do these sorts of things.

to be honest i would prefer the media bagging us that way at least expectations are not raised prematurely.

its really unbelievable 3 wins and lets be honest they have been against some very ordinary sides and all of a sudden we have the players we need to take us to sustained success. its as if the first part of the yr didnt happen.
yet people come on here and claim we dont need early picks or dont need the best possible chance of gaining another martin or cotchin but in the same breath think we are in for another low finish next yr . where did we finish again that enabled us to snare the quality of martin cotchin deledio.

we are coming off a spoon yes we all know melb would have finished above us if they were dumb enough to win a couple of games. and we are heading for another spoon have few quality players and lack depth in almost every position except small forward or small back.
ffs last yr we had the exact same debate from the precious deluded fools. we have had the denate since wallace arrived. every yr its the same foolish arguments and the following yr the same thing happens.

its simple CATTLE FIRST YEP CATTLE BLOODY FIRST. get enough quality into yr system get enough of the right players then take the que out of the rack.
who here really believes we have a list or are even close to having the list to take us to a regular top 4 berth.
who here is willing to forgo a crack at another martin or deledio aand for that matter a ryan bastinac because when it comes down to it thats what people are asking just so they can say hey we beat port or hey we beat wce by 50 points.
Wow there are actually some intelligent posters on BF... couldnt agree more! The ones saying how good it was we won the last 9 from 11 games where did that get us??? NOWHERE
We need gun players comming in through the draft dont give me this winning culture bullsh1t, how was St Kildas winning culture before they picked up goddard and reiwoltd etc in the draft??? Look at them now...
 

YellowandBlackBlood

Bigfooty Superstar
Joined
Jun 25, 2007
Posts
1,689
Likes
9
Location
Parts unknown
AFL Club
Richmond
#35
Wow there are actually some intelligent posters on BF... couldnt agree more! These same morons are the ones saying how good it was we won the last 9 from 11 games where did that get us??? NOWHERE
We need gun players comming in through the draft dont give me this winning culture bullsh1t, how was St Kildas winning culture before they picked up goddard and reiwoltd etc in the draft??? Look at them now...
Read my post a page or two back and argue the points I put forward.:cool:
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2009
Posts
104
Likes
0
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
#36
There are two differences between winning games in the second half of the year a few years ago and now.

One has already been highlighted, in that we're playing kids which will use the confidence and grow for it, not 30 year olds in the twilight of their carreers which have no improvement left.

The second is that, in my opinion, our recruiting is not top notch. Last draft is an example of this, where pick 71 has turned into an absolute steal. I'd love to have a look at other picks around there and see if they look anything like what we've found in Nason.
Before, we'd win the meaningless games but more importantly BOTCH THE RECRUITING AS A RESULT. I really don't think we're going to screw up our recruiting as a result of a pick one or two higher this time round. :thumbsu::thumbsu::thumbsu:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

_RT_

Hall Of Famer
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Posts
34,865
Likes
42,918
Location
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
#37
Wow there are actually some intelligent posters on BF... couldnt agree more! These same morons are the ones saying how good it was we won the last 9 from 11 games where did that get us??? NOWHERE
We need gun players comming in through the draft dont give me this winning culture bullsh1t, how was St Kildas winning culture before they picked up goddard and reiwoltd etc in the draft??? Look at them now...
It was 2000-2002 that they finished at the arse end of the ladder, during which time they picked up Goddard Riewoldt Ball Kosi Dal Santo.

In the 5 years before the Saints picked up these guys: in 95 they finished 14th, in 96 they finished 10th, they finished top in 97 and played in a GF, 6th in 98 playing in the semi finals, 10th in 99 missing the finals by 1 game and %.

Come 2003 they won 11 games finished in 11th, 3.5 wins ahead of Geelong & 4 wins ahead of us, 2004 they finished 3rd, 2005 they finished 4th, 2006 they finished 6th, 2007 they finished 9th missing the finals by half a game, 2008 they finished 4th and last year they finished runners up.

So outside the 4 years where they finished 14th(95), 16th(2000), 15th(2001) & 15th(2002) they haven't finished any lower than 11th since the middle of the 90's. Thats 11 years of mid table finishes or better and yet people like to use them as an example of how tanking works. If anything the Saints are an example of how creating the right culture at a club and having everyone do all they can to maintain that culture can bring sustained success and keep a side in with a chance of ultimate success.
 

Spluff

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
May 3, 2009
Posts
9,455
Likes
6,266
Location
Geelong
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Steelers
#38
So you're telling us that by them bottoming out deliberately until they have rebuilt and therefore being propelled up the ladder for the rest of the decade, they are an argument not to tank?
 

coke_zero

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Posts
7,639
Likes
54
Location
chadstone
AFL Club
Richmond
#39
So outside the 4 years where they finished 14th(95), 16th(2000), 15th(2001) & 15th(2002) they haven't finished any lower than 11th since the middle of the 90's. Thats 11 years of mid table finishes or better and yet people like to use them as an example of how tanking works. If anything the Saints are an example of how creating the right culture at a club and having everyone do all they can to maintain that culture can bring sustained success and keep a side in with a chance of ultimate success.
Most teams finish mid table for 5-6 years each decade. And when they bottomed out they got some very good players that brought them back up the top of the ladder.
 

_RT_

Hall Of Famer
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Posts
34,865
Likes
42,918
Location
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
#40
So you're telling us that by them bottoming out deliberately until they have rebuilt and therefore being propelled up the ladder for the rest of the decade, they are an argument not to tank?
Most teams finish mid table for 5-6 years each decade. And when they bottomed out they got some very good players that brought them back up the top of the ladder.
You could argue that since 2004 we've had our time down the bottom, and while we didn't do it the way others have by rorting the PP system we have still managed to pick up Deledio Cotchin Martin Vickery & Riewoldt, a group that is could be argued is the same as Riewoldt Kosi Goddard Dal Santo & Ball were to the Saints back in the early '00's i.e. a group that a side could be built around.

Yet people still insist that we need to go out and add another 1-3 players of this ilk before we should even think about winning games and moving back up the ladder. Tell me since the Goddard draft which superstar first round draft pick have the Saints picked up to really top off the likes of those 5 named above.
 

mcuzzy

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 16, 2007
Posts
15,214
Likes
13,971
Location
9th
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Dimma's wife
#41
Still believe we can make the 8 obviously I am delusional but in reality I believe in what we are doing I was told weeks ago that 8 wins is our target so lets see. I love all that has begun to happen wait to you all see what Ive seen, Can we really make the 8 probably not but while we are winning anything is possible. I told Ben C and he laughed until I said until we cant we can. And what about the cuz almost back to his best making the play hitting targets with precision and most of all smiling while doing it.
love your optimism


So you're telling us that by them bottoming out deliberately until they have rebuilt and therefore being propelled up the ladder for the rest of the decade, they are an argument not to tank?
fremantle argueably didn't tank, they tried to get their players with a winning mentality but never were good enough to win that many games. they finished bottom half got a fair few years and they're rebuilt. no need to aim for the spoon imo.
 

coke_zero

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Posts
7,639
Likes
54
Location
chadstone
AFL Club
Richmond
#42
You could argue that since 2004 we've had our time down the bottom, and while we didn't do it the way others have by rorting the PP system we have still managed to pick up Deledio Cotchin Martin Vickery & Riewoldt, a group that is could be argued is the same as Riewoldt Kosi Goddard Dal Santo & Ball were to the Saints back in the early '00's i.e. a group that a side could be built around.

Yet people still insist that we need to go out and add another 1-3 players of this ilk before we should even think about winning games and moving back up the ladder. Tell me since the Goddard draft which superstar first round draft pick have the Saints picked up to really top off the likes of those 5 named above.
If you have the chance to add more "ilk" to your team you take it. Chances are we are going to trade some of our players for picks. We probably wont get the PP but saying pick 6 is just as good as pick 4 is wrong.
 

_RT_

Hall Of Famer
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Posts
34,865
Likes
42,918
Location
Southern Stand Punt Road End
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies Premiers 2010
#43
If you have the chance to add more "ilk" to your team you take it. Chances are we are going to trade some of our players for picks. We probably wont get the PP but saying pick 6 is just as good as pick 4 is wrong.
Given what some of the draft watches are saying regarding this years kids it is.
 
Top Bottom