I would be.
Trade a 2nd rounder for tuohy and the equivalent for lids. Keep caddy.
I wouldn't be. Sounds like a win to me ...
IN: two mature gun players who fit our needs very well for the next couple of years while our premiership window is likely to be open
OUT: one younger player who has more career left but whose type we can cover pretty comfortably and who anyway in 6 years in the AFL hasn't reached the heights we were all hoping he would
One major problem with having all three, as I understand it, is the salary cap. I imagine that Caddy going out would probably free up a few $$$ to bring the other two in on.