For the guys participating in the official big footy phantom, do you reckon that I could help you guys out. maybe we could do a discussion as the day draws nearer.
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
official phantom draft
- Thread starter StingaArmstrong
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Yep.
So far, the panel is:
StingaArmstrong
Demon37/lamby29
melbournemartin
and I think Deestroy.
Not sure about CFH and BT.
Anyway, discussion time, who do we take?
Here is how I see it:
(In order of preference)
pick 3: Sylvia, daylight, more daylight, Tenace, Walker, Ray, Bradley
pick 5: Tenace or Walker if still there, otherwise Dunn, Ray, Clarke, Bradley.
pick 36: CJ.
pick 52: Aaron Davey, Lachlan Smith, Koulorites (sp?)
So far, the panel is:
StingaArmstrong
Demon37/lamby29
melbournemartin
and I think Deestroy.
Not sure about CFH and BT.
Anyway, discussion time, who do we take?
Here is how I see it:
(In order of preference)
pick 3: Sylvia, daylight, more daylight, Tenace, Walker, Ray, Bradley
pick 5: Tenace or Walker if still there, otherwise Dunn, Ray, Clarke, Bradley.
pick 36: CJ.
pick 52: Aaron Davey, Lachlan Smith, Koulorites (sp?)
Deestroy
Norm Smith Medallist
I'm not keen on Davey at all. A pure athlete.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Deestroy
Norm Smith Medallist
He's also IMO an average footballer. Rookie list at best.
CowboyFromHell
Witchtripper
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2001
- Posts
- 13,582
- Reaction score
- 2,074
- Location
- Tin Shed at Junction Oval
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Denver Nuggets, Man Utd.
I'll be in this one! 
Sylvia at #3 is the go if he is still there. Not sure where to look after that. Tenace would be nice, but so would Walker, McLean, Dunn etc.
Pick #52 will be a good one. Have a look at Luke Buckland of the Falcons, plays forward or back, good hands, good veritcal leap as well.
Sylvia at #3 is the go if he is still there. Not sure where to look after that. Tenace would be nice, but so would Walker, McLean, Dunn etc.
Pick #52 will be a good one. Have a look at Luke Buckland of the Falcons, plays forward or back, good hands, good veritcal leap as well.
*koulagirl
Team Captain
Koulouriotis.
Deestroy
Norm Smith Medallist
Furthering this I also believe we should stay away from Koula, wouldn't take him in the rookie draft.
We should get a preferance order going for top picks. My suggestion would be Cooney, Sylvia, Tenace, Walker, Dunn, Ray, Bradley. That would cover our first 2 picks.
For pick 52 we would need to wait and see who is around at that pick. As I say I'm not keen on either Davey or Koula.
- Thread starter
- #12
In order of preference:
Pick 3 Sylvia, Tenace
Pick 5 Tenace, Mclean, Walker, Morrison, Clarke
I'm a big rap for both Mclean and Morrison but we would be picking them ahead of a lot of other good players.
Mclean is a good strong hard leader to stick into our midfield and Morrison is a very good player even though he was injured all year. Excellent draft camp results (and a Tassie boy
)
I dont see Lamb, Nicholson, Rogers, Molan, Holland and Neitz being around for too much longer so maybe we need an extra tall.
Pick 52 Adam Bentick - Don't know much apart from what the draft camp preview said. Good tackler with good vision and work ethic and one percenters.
Alex Gilmour another tassie boy whos good in and under and decent skills.
Aaron Davey, bit of pace on the forward line.
Others/Rookie
Josh Willoughby, Joel Cambell, Sam Pleming, Cameron Thurley, Brent Robinson
Pre Season
S.Harvey, R. Betheras
Pick 3 Sylvia, Tenace
Pick 5 Tenace, Mclean, Walker, Morrison, Clarke
I'm a big rap for both Mclean and Morrison but we would be picking them ahead of a lot of other good players.
Mclean is a good strong hard leader to stick into our midfield and Morrison is a very good player even though he was injured all year. Excellent draft camp results (and a Tassie boy
) I dont see Lamb, Nicholson, Rogers, Molan, Holland and Neitz being around for too much longer so maybe we need an extra tall.
Pick 52 Adam Bentick - Don't know much apart from what the draft camp preview said. Good tackler with good vision and work ethic and one percenters.
Alex Gilmour another tassie boy whos good in and under and decent skills.
Aaron Davey, bit of pace on the forward line.
Others/Rookie
Josh Willoughby, Joel Cambell, Sam Pleming, Cameron Thurley, Brent Robinson
Pre Season
S.Harvey, R. Betheras
Sounds like the new David Clarke!
No thanx, all the pace in the world won't help him if we can't get it to him.
Next!
Koulouritis at 52 I'd do, seen him dominate the SANFL on Foxtel a few times.
Originally posted by StingaArmstrong
In order of preference:
Pick 3 Sylvia, Tenace
Pick 5 Tenace, Mclean, Walker, Morrison, Clarke
I'm a big rap for both Mclean and Morrison but we would be picking them ahead of a lot of other good players.
Mclean is a good strong hard leader to stick into our midfield and Morrison is a very good player even though he was injured all year. Excellent draft camp results (and a Tassie boy
I dont see Lamb, Nicholson, Rogers, Molan, Holland and Neitz being around for too much longer so maybe we need an extra tall.
Pick 52 Adam Bentick - Don't know much apart from what the draft camp preview said. Good tackler with good vision and work ethic and one percenters.
Alex Gilmour another tassie boy whos good in and under and decent skills.
Aaron Davey, bit of pace on the forward line.
Others/Rookie
Josh Willoughby, Joel Cambell, Sam Pleming, Cameron Thurley, Brent Robinson
Pre Season
S.Harvey, R. Betheras
Bentick sounds good, wasn't he the Calder Cannons skipper? IF so he won't be around at 32 let alone 52.
The player we go for with 52, will depend on the type of players we get with our early picks. If we get the grunt we need (Sylvia,Dunn/McLean) then we can afford to go for a different type here.
- Thread starter
- #15
I put Bentick there as he hasn't been mentioned in any Phantom drafts...hopefully he is still around.
Deestroy
Norm Smith Medallist
I would be happy with Bentick, he was Calders captain, and footyman will tell us all about him I'm sure.
Similar threads
