On the Couch

[greatwhiteshark]

Anyone see the pathetic question and answer to Vlad last night on the couch?

Healy and Sheahan pandering to the CEO like they were his puppets which they probably are.

The biggest single issue in Football is the rules and not a question on it, talked about how they will spend countless millions on West Sydney, Norths clash strip and Grant Thomas.

The Public and fans are dissalusioned witht he new rules, its talked about constantly by all and sundry. Its a proble with the game and it was not mentioned. Unbelievable!!!!!!!

Whats the point of having the CEO on if you have not got the courage to ask the tough questions?

Just becomes another political outlet for the AFL this show. Weak as piss!

 

[Big Nasty]

Didn't he say last night that any star player that's traded to the Gold Coast, the club would only get a 2nd round draft pick in return?

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Didn't he say last night that any star player that's traded to the Gold Coast, the club would only get a 2nd round draft pick in return?

Yes they used the example of Reiwoldt, If he is out of contract and signs with the Gold Coast the best St Kilda can get is a second round pick.

 

[Daytripper]

Anyone see the pathetic question and answer to Vlad last night on the couch?

Healy and Sheahan pandering to the CEO like they were his puppets which they probably are.

The biggest single issue in Football is the rules and not a question on it, talked about how they will spend countless millions on West Sydney, Norths clash strip and Grant Thomas.

The biggest issue in football is GC17 and West Sydney - and by a long way too.

Who wants to debate rules ?
Its sleep inducing most of the time and pointless.

They're locked in for the season and there's nothing that can be done about it.

 

[Sanks]

The biggest issue in football is GC17 and West Sydney - and by a long way too.

Who wants to debate rules ?
Its sleep inducing most of the time and pointless.

They're locked in for the season and there's nothing that can be done about it.

Thanks for joining us Adrian

 

[The Boy From Brasil]

Yes they used the example of Reiwoldt, If he is out of contract and signs with the Gold Coast the best St Kilda can get is a second round pick.

Not that I would ever disagree with the great A Demetriou, but doesn't that apply on for 2010 and 2011? If my memory serves me correctly, clubs can still use their compensation pick for first round past 2011, provided the AFL ranks the player concerned of first round value.

 

[The Boy From Brasil]

Whats the point of having the CEO on if you have not got the courage to ask the tough questions?

Just becomes another political outlet for the AFL this show. Weak as piss!

As soon as they got rid of Walls and put in Hird, that was always going to happen.

The couch is now a football discussion show, its not a hard hitting opinion giving show. Not saying whether that is good or bad, just commenting about the changing dynamics of the show.

 

[Adam Selwood]

As soon as they got rid of Walls and put in Hird, that was always going to happen.

The couch is now a football discussion show, its not a hard hitting opinion giving show. Not saying whether that is good or bad, just commenting about the changing dynamics of the show.

Agreed

I don't mind Hird but he is too much of a nice guy to fit into a show like On The Couch.

Walls at least asked some tough questions, even if people dislike him.

Lack of any real opinion is hurting On The Couch, get Grant Thomas on board

 

[WALL-e]

Best part of the show was HEaly nd Hird continuosly shutting Mike down when he started talking about Neil Craig and the Crows.

Should stick to talking about teams you actually watch Mike.

 

[And_ROOS]

Yes they used the example of Reiwoldt, If he is out of contract and signs with the Gold Coast the best St Kilda can get is a second round pick.

Conversely, Geelong getting a 2nd round pick for a certain S. Byrnes is a win in my book

 

[Art Vandelay_]

What once was a great program with likable and knowledgeable people on it like Sheehan, Roos and Healy now has had its legacy pissed all over by how inane Riewoldt is in the media. Moron of the highest order and if he's smart Lewis should stop being his sidekick.

 

[And_ROOS]

What once was a great program with likable and knowledgeable people on it like Sheehan, Roos and Healy now has had its legacy pissed all over by how inane Riewoldt is in the media. Moron of the highest order and if he's smart Lewis should stop being his sidekick.

The problem is I don't even know which Riewoldt you are talking about because I haven't seen the show in ages but it applies to either.

 

[Big Bryza]

The problem is I don't even know which Riewoldt you are talking about because I haven't seen the show in ages but it applies to either.

Nicky got banned from Fox by his Misso, for getting too friendly with the Boundary Rider who was shipped back to Perth.

 

[Peters_Nuts]

What once was a great program with likable and knowledgeable people on it like Sheehan, Roos and Healy now has had its legacy pissed all over by how inane Riewoldt is in the media. Moron of the highest order and if he's smart Lewis should stop being his sidekick.

Lost a bit of interest when Riewoldt became the host. Stopped watching all together when Lewis joined.

Riewoldt is clearly knowledgable and is good for special comments, though is a horrible host and loves the sound of his own voice too much to let people get their opinion across.