One year too many.

[james Dean]

Michael Walters although not completely done is a shadow of what he was.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Marc Murphy
Kyle Hartigan
Robbie Gray

 

[NetworkNerd]

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

On the contrary, some plaudits for career revivals and survivals this year:

Tex Walker - obvious, 2nd in the Coleman, great field kicking and pressure too

Grant Birchall - not just up in Brisbane sitting back, he's well and truly earning his cheque

Cale Hooker - his 2nd best goalkicking year ever already, on track to be his best ever, =5th in the Coleman and helping Wright and Jones out massively

Jesse Hogan - why I thought to post it. Still a lot of water under the bridge but he's back playing and both his games have been good

Tom McDonald - not a retire option, but gone from trade table at the end of 2020 to key player in the top side

Tom Hickey - AA ruck case for him

Probably chuck in Aaron Hall off HB after being very average for years.

 

[Truckosaurus]

Ben Cunnington's hairline. It's been a brave fight but time to face the music.

 

[HairyO]

Marc Murphy
Kyle Hartigan
Robbie Gray

Hartigan is the reason why we lose by a few goals each week not get flogged.

We are -20 on inside 50s week in, week out.

 

[M Malice]

 

[who_let_the_dogs_out]

Not necessarily one year too many, but wtf has happened to Johannisen? He looks like he is 38 years old

His last 2 games have been good, last night especially. Turned the after burners on quite often, massive chase down tackle through the middle. Has shown he can kick a goal or 2 as well. Definitely still in the 22.

 

[The Nostradamus]

David Zaharakis 2 years too many

 

[Sky]

Zach Guthrie has gone 5 years too long with another few to come before because his brother has become a star in the past two years

Donnarumma effect.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Zach Guthrie has gone 5 years too long with another few to come before because his brother has become a star in the past two years

Donnarumma effect.

He has played well the last 3 games...

 

[The Nostradamus]

Zach Guthrie has gone 5 years too long with another few to come before because his brother has become a star in the past two years

Donnarumma effect.

Part of cam Guthrie’s contract negotiations is his brother must get an extra year

 

[Blue1980]

Marc Murphy
Kyle Hartigan
Robbie Gray

Murph was the most accurate call of the 3 until his great 3rd quarter instrumental getting us over the line v hawks.

 

[Schauermann]

Michael Walters although not completely done is a shadow of what he was.

Don't think it is too long yet. But he surely is down on his best.


Really difficult to judge at times. Mundy 2016 or Taylor Walker in 2020. Nobody would have been surprised about a retirement after those season. Still...

 

[Sky]

He has played well the last 3 games...

He was the substitute in the previous game against a terrible club. What do you expect? St Kilda are also awful.

 

[Schauermann]

Zach Guthrie has gone 5 years too long with another few to come before because his brother has become a star in the past two years

Somehow makes me think of Claye Beams...

 

[Art Vandelay_]

He was the substitute in the previous game against a terrible club. What do you expect? St Kilda are also awful.

He did his job and is trusted by Scarlett, that’s good enough for me.

More useful than bloody Clark.

 

[Sky]

He did his job and is trusted by Scarlett, that’s good enough for me.

More useful than bloody Clark.

They’re both poor mans Jackson Thurlow. Look how his career panned out.

 

[Seeds]

He has played well the last 3 games...

Only if you bar is really really low.

 

[Seeds]

He did his job and is trusted by Scarlett, that’s good enough for me.

More useful than bloody Clark.

He was dropped after his last full game. Clearly Scarlett thought his performance wasn’t good enough.


if Zac Guthrie created goals from smothers like Clark did you would be singing his praises through the roof.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Only if you bar is really really low.

He was dropped after his last full game. Clearly Scarlett thought his performance wasn’t good enough.


if Zac Guthrie created goals from smothers like Clark did you would be singing his praises through the roof.

What have I told you?
Shoo.

 

[Seeds]

What have I told you?
Shoo.

Why be so childish?

someone posted Zac Guthrie and you had to come in and defend Zac guthrie because well that’s just what you do. That’s not the point of this thread.

i came in to post burgoyne. And yet I see a Geelong board sh**fight.

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Why be so childish?

someone posted Zac Guthrie and you had to come in and defend Zac guthrie because well that’s just what you do. That’s not the point of this thread.

i came in to post burgoyne. And yet I see a Geelong board sh**fight.

Then post Burgoyne and move on, self moderate yourself and leave me the * alone.

 

[Kim Hagdorn]

I thought it was just my bad eyesight for a moment when I seen Frawley still 'moving' around out there.

 

[The Dougster]

View attachment 1135239

Not gonna lie. You couldn't of chosen a better photo!