Our 10 best players?

[jod23]

Who are WC's ten best players?

I would say.

1. Cousins (just...awesome midfielder and would stroll into any side in the comp)

2. Wirrpunda (at the end of the year could be in front of Cuz)

3. Jakovich (still one of if not the best CHB in the competition)

4. Kemp (gets better with age, i wish he was 100

)

5. Gardiner (top 5 ruckman in the league and could really make his mark this year)

6. Morrison (all-australian beckons)

7. Braun (hes down at 7 prolly cos of injury, when back at best goes head to head with cuz)

8. P. Matera (slowing down, used to our best player with the like of Jako Bluey Mainy Louie Whoosha all in there prime and thats saying something)

9. Cummings (Coleman medal speaks for itself but can he recapture that form)

10. Banfield (With Jones now a regular he sort of plays off the HB line, but still a great tagger)

Thoughts?

------------------
All the people in the broken homes dont wanna fight no more. All the people nursing shattered bones dont wanna fight no more. But theres no profit in peace so we gotta fight some more.

[This message has been edited by jod23 (edited 20 March 2001).]

 

[eagleskickass]

I think you are pretty spot on there jod23. Good effort.

 

[ah_19]

i would put gardiner higher though

 

[TigerTank]

Originally posted by jod23:


5. Gardiner (top 5 ruckman in the league and could really make his mark this year)

They must be selling some good sh!t in Perth at the moment.

Gardiner better than Jeff White, Steven King, Matthew Allan, Brad Ottens, Ben Marsh, Clark Keating, Matthew Primus, Greg Stafford, Peter Everitt?

They must be selling some REALLY good sh!t over there!

------------------
TT - Obligatory bad-tempered Richmond supporter

 

[Pessimistic]

Watch out for Richard (Dickie Knee) Taylor...

 

[ah_19]

we are following the words of most victorian proffesionals actually on this matter
yes he is better
at round 14 before he was injured last year he was the leading ruckman in the afl
this year hes bulked up about 5kg more, and is fitter than ever
add it up if u can

any logical counter?

 

[MDB]

1. Wirra
2. Cousins
3. Gardiner
4. Braun
5. Morrisson
6. Jackovich
7. Kemp
8. Peter Matera
9. McIntosh
10. Banfield

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

I probably would have liked to see Phil Matera on that list. He kicks bout 50 goals a season, does the 1 percenters and makes it very hard for opposition defences to clear the ball.

But our top 10-15 players are pretty good. Pretty much equal to any in the competition. It's the rest of the list that will determine where we finish this season.

------------------
"I'm not going to waste my life trying to prolong it"

 

[jod23]

D4E, i had Phil Matera at 11, unlucky to miss out. TT you just make a statement with no proof, you have nothing that says Gardiner isnt a top 5 ruckman? Until you do kindly go away.