Opinion Our best defender in Modern era

ChoppyGun

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2020
5,673
10,063
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Sorry all but this list management stuff gets consuming.

So I'd like to ask who have been our best defenders since say, 1970?

I was only born in 1981 so never remember Dench etc.

Top 3, tall or small, and give a reason why?
 

Passmore

Brownlow Medallist
May 22, 2001
23,595
75,867
The Gasometer Wing
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Norf
Sorry all but this list management stuff gets consuming.

So I'd like to ask who have been our best defenders since say, 1970?

I was only born in 1981 so never remember Dench etc.

Top 3, tall or small, and give a reason why?

Dench. Reinvented the position of full back.
Glendinning. Would probably be a midfielder nowadays. Supreme rebounder.
Archer. Hard as *. Underrated skill wise.
 
Last edited:

ChoppyGun

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2020
5,673
10,063
AFL Club
North Melbourne
I'll start.
1. Mick Martyn. Beat or nullified the very best fwd of all time.
2. Glenn Archer. Tough and played tall.
3. Robbie Tarrant. Under pressure for years but steady as and such a cool head.
 
Jul 26, 2007
93,508
161,869
The Tree
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Coney Island Warriors
Thommo over Tarrant?

Hell yeah. Thommo is one of my all time favourites. He's got 80 games on Taz (more probably as a pure defender) and was All Australian for a reason.

Tarrant is a clear 4th.
 

ChoppyGun

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2020
5,673
10,063
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Hell yeah. Thommo is one of my all time favourites. He's got 80 games on Taz (more probably as a pure defender) and was All Australian for a reason.

Tarrant is a clear 4th.

Yep love Thommo too.

But no I'd have Tarrants best over Thommo.

Tarrant should be a multiple All Australian.
 

ChoppyGun

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2020
5,673
10,063
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Remember small defenders too.

Rawlings a very good stopper
 

Heaps of fun

Goatered on the sticks
Sep 13, 2013
23,853
62,248
AFL Club
North Melbourne
1. Troy Makepeace
2. Turtle Harding
3. Jess Sinclair
 

Thewlis Dish

Cancelled
10k Posts
Sep 9, 2003
27,578
28,761
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
FGR
Started supporting in 1993 and Tarrant is the best all around I've seen. I'd love to have seen him take up his post younger and in some of our better sides.

Pickett also sensational, although he could pretty much play anywhere.
 

ChoppyGun

Norm Smith Medallist
Jul 19, 2020
5,673
10,063
AFL Club
North Melbourne
1. Troy Makepeace
2. Turtle Harding
3. Jess Sinclair

All goers for sure.

Makepeace especially underrated imo
 
Jul 26, 2007
93,508
161,869
The Tree
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Coney Island Warriors
Yep love Thommo too.

But no I'd have Tarrants best over Thommo.

Tarrant should be a multiple All Australian.

Not really gonna be much of a discussion then with three - can't deny Tarrant, Martyn, Archer and Thompson as a top four.
 
Dec 18, 2014
3,970
10,867
Victoria
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Pierce & Pierce, Stratton Oakmont
Luke Delaney
 
Dench - skilled, athletic and rarely beaten one on one. He'd be in the conversation as one of the all time best defenders.

John Law deserves a mention - not as skilled as others but as tough as anyone, including Archer.
 
Jun 9, 2001
37,642
145,026
Fogarty Street
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
St Johnstone
Chapter 1...

Mick - played in a golden age where every team had a solid (or better) key forward. Not ruckmen playing out of position or 3 metre tall Americans.

In any given week Mick could be facing Gary Lyon, Ablett Sr, Dunstall, Modra, Merrett, Kernahan, Rocca, Lloyd, Brownless, Neitz, Tredrea, Richardson, Loewe, Lockett, Wheildon, Grant et al. All dangerous on their day.

Mick destroyed plenty of opponents before hoofing it 50 metres in any direction upfield in a sort of "get the hell out of here" move. Sure there were times he got beaten - but that was only going to happen when the opposition midfield were at full throttle and his opponent played a blinder. Mick was never going to willingly give his opponent an inch.

Archer - just the complete flank player. Control his man on the ground and in the air and burst out with a short pass to clear the area. Extreme courage and physicality and an exceptional intercept player before it became trendy as well as a 3rd man up spoiler - and not just a spoil but a "kill the ball" type of action.

Just to top it off he could swing forward when needed and turn momentum our way like clockwork. Exceptional player.

Choppy/King - neither probably rated off the charts for minding an opponent but there's a reason we never even had to worry about rebound in the 90s with these 2 roaring out of defence. Each in their own way would just get and go, brutalising an opponent on the way before charging upfield and turning the play our way. Guns.
 
Jun 8, 2004
13,673
30,236
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
1. Dench - changed the game
2. Archer - enough said
3. Mick - took on the monsters. Beat them regularly.

Probably have Glendenning ahead of Mick but it’s hard to argue with your list.

If you want a small to midsize sized defender then it’s hard to go past Blakey.
John Law was also a very good player.
 

Thewlis Dish

Cancelled
10k Posts
Sep 9, 2003
27,578
28,761
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
FGR
Choppy/King - neither probably rated off the charts for minding an opponent but there's a reason we never even had to worry about rebound in the 90s with these 2 roaring out of defence. Each in their own way would just get and go, brutalising an opponent on the way before charging upfield and turning the play our way. Guns.

That 1999 side was incredible for small/medium defenders. You also had Pike and Blakey, four tough hombres.
 
Back