Our Current KPPs (Ideal spots)

[BringouttheGimp]

Current key position players or thereabouts re..

Scharenberg
Moore
Cox
Dunn
Reid
Mihocek
Mcclarty

Where do these guys belong on the pitch.. our best combo or whatever re.. there seems to be so much confusion in relation to this shit re.. interchangeable positions.. which players should be playing. Which shouldn't be.

Let's see if this thread lasts more than 2 pages.. normally they die on their ass re..

Ok go for it..

I find it an interesting topic.. for starters find really no use playing Cox in the forward 50.. predictable.. playing him outside the forward 50 and floating on wings is of more benefit to us.

 

[KillerMagpies]

FB Dunn
CHB Reid
CHF Moore
FF Mihocek (based on pretty limited form)

.... if everybody is fit. (Which is rarely the case )

 

[CFC2010]

Current key position players or thereabouts re..

Scharenberg
Moore
Cox
Dunn
Reid
Mihocek
Mcclarty

Where do these guys belong on the pitch.. our best combo or whatever re.. there seems to be so much confusion in relation to this shit re..

Let's see if this thread lasts more than 2 pages.. normally they die on their ass re..

Ok go for it..

I find it an interesting topic..

Scharenberg & Dunn in defence

Moore & Cox forward for me.

The rest are backup or not ready like McClarty.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Scharenberg & Dunn in defence

Moore & Cox forward for me.

The rest are backup or not ready like McClarty.

See I don't see a position for Dunn.. if he's there for experience.. I'd suggest he get in their ears on the training track rather than on the pitch.. far too safe an option for me to play him week in week out..

Then where does Reid play with Cox and Moore up front..

What's the status of Mcclarty and Mihocek if say Dunn and Reid are an auto selection..

What is our best combo.. I feel as though we've got everything else right.. this we haven't.. injuries have played a part of course.. but theres so much confusion as to who belongs where..

 

[BringouttheGimp]

FB Dunn
CHB Reid
CHF Moore
FF Mihocek (based on pretty limited form)

.... if everybody is fit. (Which is rarely the case )

How would you utilise Cox?

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Moore here Moore there.. Reid here Reid there.. Now with McLarty and Mihocek wanting a crack.. who on earth belongs where..

If we can somehow settle down on this spots we're a top 4 proposition.. i feel it!

We are pretty much settled in every other spot.

Get the combo right and we can really go for it.. why friggen not.

 

[KillerMagpies]

How would you utilise Cox?

Apparently, he’s really good at cutting up oranges.

 

[BEEG]

WHE always needs to be played as a lead up forward.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Apparently, he’s really good at cutting up oranges.

He's not a deep forward.. that's for sure. Drink half a slab and get him to jump around there.. still a similar result.

Play him outside the 50 for crying out loud.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

WHE always needs to be played as a lead up forward.

He's a gun re.

 

[KillerMagpies]

Apparently, he’s really good at cutting up oranges.

I like footballers.
Mihocek has been a B&F @ Port Melbourne under a good coach (Ayres) and showed excellent football intelligence and efficiency today. So, he’s in.
Reid’s kicks out of defence are beautiful. 40-50m hard, flat, lasers.
Dunn is a good kick, hard and tough.
Moore needs to play, so that we can get a decent pick for him so that he can get to Sydney (where he apparently wants to go) and we can use some decent picks to get our hands on Lynch (who is still a restricted free agent... Gold Coast will match any bids).

 

[CFC2010]

See I don't see a position for Dunn.. if he's there for experience.. I'd suggest he get in their ears on the training track rather than on the pitch.. far too safe an option for me to play him week in week out..

Then where does Reid play with Cox and Moore up front..

What's the status of Mcclarty and Mihocek if say Dunn and Reid are an auto selection..

What is our best combo.. I feel as though we've got everything else right.. this we haven't.. injuries have played a part of course.. but theres so much confusion as to who belongs where..

Dunn is our full back for now because he is the best we have got......the truth is he has frustrated me the last few weeks but we don't have anyone else to surpass him.

Reid plays until Moore is fit. Cox stays also because we don't have a backup for Grundy until Moore is fit.

The cupboard is quite bare Levendi......just pray we don't get anymore injuries to our KPP's.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Dunn is our full back for now because he is the best we have got......the truth is he has frustrated me the last few weeks but we don't have anyone else to surpass him.

Reid plays until Moore is fit. Cox stays also because we don't have a backup for Grundy until Moore is fit.

The cupboard is quite bare Levendi......just pray we don't get anymore injuries to our KPP's.

Frustrating yes.. would be awesome if they were all fit and available.. interesting to say the least as to who plays where..

 

[adammania9]

What does Dunn need to do to open doubters' eyes and prove he's a crucial player for Collingwood? He's an absolute lock in the 22, no negotiations. He's a very good defender.

 

[sr36]

Bloody tough question. At the moment, I can only really answer Shaz in defence. Not sure on all of the others.

Moore - I'd like to see him play a decent block of games in defence to know with him.
Reid - I don't think he's been great at either end over the last few years. A bit harsh, but maybe VFL while we have a look at Mihocek?
Dunn's a defender. He holds his own, but like I said, I'd like to see Moore play a block of games in defence and it would be at his expense.
Mihocek - great start up forward, but too early to call
Cox - depends on Darcy. If Darcy plays forward and ruck relief, Cox to dominate the VFL. If Darcy plays back, we need Cox up forward
McLarty - no idea

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

FB Moore
CHB Scharenberg
CHF Reid
FF De Goey

 

[Quicky]

For me -

FB: Dunn
CHB: Moore
CHF: Reid
FF: Cox

It'll be interesting to see if Mihocek holds his form but I feel he's just keeping the position warm for Reid. Did like his effort there though! Really put in.

Moore to CHB to provide some height and offer that match up. Also because I reckon it's his best position now. Although we need to see more of him there to better judge.

Scharenberg to play smaller.

 

[Moeydw]

What does Dunn need to do to open doubters' eyes and prove he's a crucial player for Collingwood? He's an absolute lock in the 22, no negotiations. He's a very good defender.

Some supporters must not be able to accept that an older, recycled player can be playing so well.

 

[Kreme Pie]

FB: Dunn
CHB: Reid
CHF: Moore
FF: Cox

Shaz to be permanent defender obviously.
Mihocek can play a role at both ends if required.
McClarty only to debut when decimated by injury to the above players. Or if he is dominating in vfl.

I think regardless of where we finish this year, we should be looking to draft KP players this year, and/or going hard for players like Tom Lynch, Peter Wright, Jeremy McGovern.
Especially if Moore wants out.

How long have Dunn and Reid got left in their bodies?

 

[legendstatus]

Mihocek playing with Reid allows Howe to
Pinch hit up forward if needed


Sent from my Warped mind [emoji89]

 

[rand corp]

Dunne FB
Scharenberg CHB

Moore, Ried raffle CHF with caviats

Cox FF pinch hitting in the ruck

Moore, Ried and Cox all need to do more and narrow the gap between their best and worst. For this reason I like the idea of getting games into Mihocek and McLarty

 

[The Magnificent Seven]

Just because Jamie Elliot ain't tall doesn't not make him a KPF.

 

[Football God]

Up forward once everyone is fully fit we are so unpredictable for opposition teams to assign their back men going in to a game. Who the hell is going to take care of our 7 ft giant? Probably their number 1 option. Surely you’ve all noticed, he can’t kick far. He stays deep in the forward 1 on 1 and 8/10 he will win the ball in the air.
Moore seems more athletic to be our FF target and really needs to pack on the Kgs if he is to be. Let him roam up the ground as a leading target as he is still very strong in the air.

This is the beauty of now having depth with Mihocek, let him clock some hours up in the seniors if he keeps scoring bags each week.
I haven’t properly watched the Freo game yet as I was working but does he actually suit the “key position role” ?

 

[Anzacday]

Just because Jamie Elliot ain't tall doesn't not make him a KPF.

Thanks Blairy.

 

[Bugglz]

FF: Lynch
CHF: Moore
CHB: Shaz
FB: McClarty

Would love to see that set up within the next few years, give us lots of versatility with Moore as back up ruck and the ability to swing into defence if needed.