List Mgmt. Our List 2014 - Trade, De-list and Draft - (keep it all in here)

Status
Not open for further replies.

gandaal

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 8, 2004
Posts
17,570
Likes
11,667
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
The first two are spot on, but thought Buckley had potential.
Potential for what?

Maybe a rookie option but we need hard runners who get plenty of the ball and use it well. Buckley is a flanker who probably averaged 10 posies a game in the twos. It recruiting for players like Buckley which has got us in this mess.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

HARKER

Hall of Famer
Joined
Oct 15, 2008
Posts
49,888
Likes
64,032
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Thread starter #8,133
Them 2 fighting it out is probably a good thing.

Geez i thought Buckley would be taking over Eddies position...

Mentioned by someone else on a different site but I thought it to be a good idea.

Buckley built up to play the role Simpson has.
Buckley has courage to burn and isn't a bad mark. Can also run and kick the ball 60 meters.
He just doesn't get enough of the ball but maybe he wouldn't have to playing in the back-line.
 

BM123

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 29, 2011
Posts
13,520
Likes
10,024
Location
Perth
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Golden State Warriors
Looking at the stats we were last for uncontested possessions this year. Really need to fix this since even the Bulldogs had a 100 more disposals then us when we played them.
 

KnobHead

Club Legend
Joined
Jul 5, 2011
Posts
1,174
Likes
1,949
Location
Ayahuasca Island
AFL Club
Carlton
On the whole, Mitchell & McCarthy haven't shown enough, whether it be for injuries or any other reason.

Thing is, with Waite at 30 and injury prone, Jamo at 27 & injury prone, do we need to hold onto these guys for one more year to see how they go because we lack key position options?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Sep 26, 2004
Posts
34,479
Likes
25,138
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
MUFC, LAL, PSG
Moderator #8,139
Is anyone able to explain to me how the compensation works? It seems to be made up as they go along, but maybe I'm missing something. I'm not very draft-savvy.

Compensation is awarded to clubs who lose a player, either restricted or unrestricted, via free agency. Compensation is in the form of draft picks and are handed to the club in an attempt to soften the blow of losing that player.

There is no set formula used by the AFL to determine the extent of compensation awarded, however certain factors are integral to their decision. The size and length of the player's new contract are both considerations, as is the age of the player. I believe performance is also a consideration, albeit a lesser one.

There are five types ("bands") of compensation - a first round pick, end of first round pick, second round pick, end of second round pick and third round pick. I believe the first round pick, second round pick and third round pick all fall directly after that club's original draft pick in that round.

Compensation can also be diluted or indeed cancelled out completely by that club's other dealings during free agency. The compensation received by said club would be determined by the difference between the player departing and the player gained.

For example, if Eddie is to leave we'd likely receive a compensation pick from one of the first three "bands". However if we sign Daisy Thomas, our loss is likely to be offset by our gain, which would almost certainly eradicate our compensation completely, meaning we wouldn't receive any compensatory selection.
 

thylacine60

Make me an Admin!
Joined
Jun 4, 2006
Posts
81,378
Likes
120,191
Location
Footscray
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Insert Token EPL Club
Compensation is awarded to clubs who lose a player, either restricted or unrestricted, via free agency. Compensation is in the form of draft picks and are handed to the club in an attempt to soften the blow of losing that player.

There is no set formula used by the AFL to determine the extent of compensation awarded, however certain factors are integral to their decision. The size and length of the player's new contract are both considerations, as is the age of the player. I believe performance is also a consideration, albeit a lesser one.

There are five types ("bands") of compensation - a first round pick, end of first round pick, second round pick, end of second round pick and third round pick. I believe the first round pick, second round pick and third round pick all fall directly after that club's original draft pick in that round.

Compensation can also be diluted or indeed cancelled out completely by that club's other dealings during free agency. The compensation received by said club would be determined by the difference between the player departing and the player gained.

For example, if Eddie is to leave we'd likely receive a compensation pick from one of the first three "bands". However if we sign Daisy Thomas, our loss is likely to be offset by our gain, which would almost certainly eradicate our compensation completely, meaning we wouldn't receive any compensatory selection.
That's why he's on the big bucks, folks. :thumbsu:
 

MEB_

Mumma Mebbie
Joined
Feb 6, 2013
Posts
45,530
Likes
72,565
Location
Locker #5
AFL Club
Carlton
Moderator #8,142
Compensation is awarded to clubs who lose a player, either restricted or unrestricted, via free agency. Compensation is in the form of draft picks and are handed to the club in an attempt to soften the blow of losing that player.

There is no set formula used by the AFL to determine the extent of compensation awarded, however certain factors are integral to their decision. The size and length of the player's new contract are both considerations, as is the age of the player. I believe performance is also a consideration, albeit a lesser one.

There are five types ("bands") of compensation - a first round pick, end of first round pick, second round pick, end of second round pick and third round pick. I believe the first round pick, second round pick and third round pick all fall directly after that club's original draft pick in that round.

Compensation can also be diluted or indeed cancelled out completely by that club's other dealings during free agency. The compensation received by said club would be determined by the difference between the player departing and the player gained.

For example, if Eddie is to leave we'd likely receive a compensation pick from one of the first three "bands". However if we sign Daisy Thomas, our loss is likely to be offset by our gain, which would almost certainly eradicate our compensation completely, meaning we wouldn't receive any compensatory selection.
Thank you!
 

marleyblue

Team Captain
Joined
Jan 7, 2009
Posts
524
Likes
607
Location
sydney
AFL Club
Carlton
Not really stooged on Jacobs - we got 33 and 67 (McCarthy and McInnes)

In terms of injury, Warnock is no spring chicken with a guaranteed 22 games in him next season.

I think the difference is our ruckman are contracted and therefore we don't have to trade whereas with Jacobs he was out of contract and nominated Adelaide - we had to bend over or he walked. Pick 60 is not adequate compensation for a contracted 24 year old ruck/forward (Hampson) and I'd be seriously disappointed if the club was willing to ship a contracted Warnock for pick 40
 
Joined
Nov 8, 2000
Posts
74,154
Likes
53,125
Location
Ask me tomorrow
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Cronulla, Dallas Cowboys, Forest
Moderator #8,145

Keyza

Premiership Player
Joined
Sep 12, 2009
Posts
3,944
Likes
3,797
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Compensation is awarded to clubs who lose a player, either restricted or unrestricted, via free agency. Compensation is in the form of draft picks and are handed to the club in an attempt to soften the blow of losing that player.

There is no set formula used by the AFL to determine the extent of compensation awarded, however certain factors are integral to their decision. The size and length of the player's new contract are both considerations, as is the age of the player. I believe performance is also a consideration, albeit a lesser one.

There are five types ("bands") of compensation - a first round pick, end of first round pick, second round pick, end of second round pick and third round pick. I believe the first round pick, second round pick and third round pick all fall directly after that club's original draft pick in that round.
Compensation is awarded to clubs who lose a player, either restricted or unrestricted, via free agency. Compensation is in the form of draft picks and are handed to the club in an attempt to soften the blow of losing that player.

There is no set formula used by the AFL to determine the extent of compensation awarded, however certain factors are integral to their decision. The size and length of the player's new contract are both considerations, as is the age of the player. I believe performance is also a consideration, albeit a lesser one.

There are five types ("bands") of compensation - a first round pick, end of first round pick, second round pick, end of second round pick and third round pick. I believe the first round pick, second round pick and third round pick all fall directly after that club's original draft pick in that round.

Compensation can also be diluted or indeed cancelled out completely by that club's other dealings during free agency. The compensation received by said club would be determined by the difference between the player departing and the player gained.

For example, if Eddie is to leave we'd likely receive a compensation pick from one of the first three "bands". However if we sign Daisy Thomas, our loss is likely to be offset by our gain, which would almost certainly eradicate our compensation completely, meaning we wouldn't receive any compensatory selection.
Compensation can also be diluted or indeed cancelled out completely by that club's other dealings during free agency. The compensation received by said club would be determined by the difference between the player departing and the player gained.

For example, if Eddie is to leave we'd likely receive a compensation pick from one of the first three "bands". However if we sign Daisy Thomas, our loss is likely to be offset by our gain, which would almost certainly eradicate our compensation completely, meaning we wouldn't receive any compensatory selection.
I believe that compensation picks may be scrapped from next year. In other words the club gets nothing.
I hope this is not the case as next year we have Gibbs, Walker, Murphy and Hampson all free agents.
Imagine if we lost all of them.
 
Joined
Sep 26, 2004
Posts
34,479
Likes
25,138
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
MUFC, LAL, PSG
Moderator #8,150
I believe that compensation picks may be scrapped from next year. In other words the club gets nothing.
I hope this is not the case as next year we have Gibbs, Walker, Murphy and Hampson all free agents.
Imagine if we lost all of them.

I hate that the compensation system exists. Clubs should not be 'rewarded' for failing to keep their players. Clubs that lose a player to free agency are given enough compensation in the form of alleviated salary cap pressure and the flexibility to chase other free agents.

We may suffer from it down the track but I'd absolutely support any move to abolish the system.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom