Universal Love Our list is actually fcken lit, fam *chef kissy fingers*

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Oct 27, 2016
24
197
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really can't understand the constant underrating of Butters here. Last year - Limited preseason, immature body and one shoulder but showed breathtaking awareness, ball use and vision at times that is clearly elite.
Now leading the preseason stats and is in my view is clearly an elite mid in the making and could break out this year. (Could also have 2nd year blues but showing good early training signs....)

On SM-T830 using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

PJ Power

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 13, 2003
19,203
22,262
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really can't understand the constant underrating of Butters here. Last year - Limited preseason, immature body and one shoulder but showed breathtaking awareness, ball use and vision at times that is clearly elite.
Now leading the preseason stats and is in my view is clearly an elite mid in the making and could break out this year. (Could also have 2nd year blues but showing good early training signs....)

On SM-T830 using BigFooty.com mobile app
I agree. It will just take some more consistency and higher output in his second year to move him from a potential B to an A in my assessment of him.
At the start of 2019, he was the most exciting of our trio.
 

Powerade 08

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 10, 2008
11,037
9,176
adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Butters will be a full time mid similar to Zac Merrett. Outside of Houston and Rozee he is probably the safest bet if the young guys to become a top line player.
 

Chrizzt

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 17, 2009
7,693
15,258
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really can't understand the constant underrating of Butters here. Last year - Limited preseason, immature body and one shoulder but showed breathtaking awareness, ball use and vision at times that is clearly elite.
Now leading the preseason stats and is in my view is clearly an elite mid in the making and could break out this year. (Could also have 2nd year blues but showing good early training signs....)

On SM-T830 using BigFooty.com mobile app
Also struggled to get involved in games in large patches, quite frequently. Has potential, no doubt, but didn't have the best year
 

manureid

Laziest Poster on Figbooty
Nov 24, 2003
35,509
50,092
Deleted Threads
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Man United,Raiders
Also struggled to get involved in games in large patches, quite frequently. Has potential, no doubt, but didn't have the best year
Yeh, we may be overrating Butters a bit too early. Showed good signs, is promising, but was anonymous in a lot of games/periods of games. Lets see some more before we proclaim him the 2nd coming.
 

Macca19

Moderator
Jan 14, 2001
61,366
69,691
Albertr0n
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
MUFC, Orlando Magic
My theory is that every player on an AFL list should have the talent to get to at least Grade C. You don't get drafted if there isn't the hope that you can at least get to foot soldier level. It's about finding As and Bs which is the key.

This would be my potential ceilling list from our younger crew:

Midfield:
Wines - A
Duursma - A
Butters - A
SPP - B
Drew - B
Patmore - B
Mead - B
Atley - C
Burgoyne - C

Key Fwd:
Marshall - B
Georgiades - B
Buzza - C

Gen Fwd:
Rozee - A
Williams - A
Bergman - B
Farrell - C
Woodcock - C
Cox - C

Key Def:
Clurey - B
Grundy - C
Pasini - B

Gen Def:
Houston - A
Burton - A
DBJ - B
Garner - B
Bonner - C
Frederick - C

Ruck:
Hayes - A
Ladhams - B

Obviously that isn't all going to happen like that, but we kind of need it to go a good way there for us to be premiership material.

This is what I would like our list structure to look like in 3 years time, to be top 4 capable and premiership ready.

 

DaTBird187

Norm Smith Medallist
Feb 9, 2014
9,034
21,310
By the pool drinking Gin.
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Liverpool, Boston Celtics
My theory is that every player on an AFL list should have the talent to get to at least Grade C. You don't get drafted if there isn't the hope that you can at least get to foot soldier level. It's about finding As and Bs which is the key.

This would be my potential ceilling list from our younger crew:

Midfield:
Wines - A
Duursma - A
Butters - A
SPP - B
Drew - B
Patmore - B
Mead - B
Atley - C
Burgoyne - C

Key Fwd:
Marshall - B
Georgiades - B
Buzza - C

Gen Fwd:
Rozee - A
Williams - A
Bergman - B
Farrell - C
Woodcock - C
Cox - C

Key Def:
Clurey - B
Grundy - C
Pasini - B

Gen Def:
Houston - A
Burton - A
DBJ - B
Garner - B
Bonner - C
Frederick - C

Ruck:
Hayes - A
Ladhams - B

Obviously that isn't all going to happen like that, but we kind of need it to go a good way there for us to be premiership material.

This is what I would like our list structure to look like in 3 years time, to be top 4 capable and premiership ready.

I know Draft Pick (20) is going to be a star, but isn't he at the Crows? Do you foresee us trading for him?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Enviable Tradition

Professional Procrastinator
Oct 12, 2007
17,662
19,009
The Hills
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
My theory is that every player on an AFL list should have the talent to get to at least Grade C. You don't get drafted if there isn't the hope that you can at least get to foot soldier level. It's about finding As and Bs which is the key.

This would be my potential ceilling list from our younger crew:

Midfield:
Wines - A
Duursma - A
Butters - A
SPP - B
Drew - B
Patmore - B
Mead - B
Atley - C
Burgoyne - C

Key Fwd:
Marshall - B
Georgiades - B
Buzza - C

Gen Fwd:
Rozee - A
Williams - A
Bergman - B
Farrell - C
Woodcock - C
Cox - C

Key Def:
Clurey - B
Grundy - C
Pasini - B

Gen Def:
Houston - A
Burton - A
DBJ - B
Garner - B
Bonner - C
Frederick - C

Ruck:
Hayes - A
Ladhams - B

Obviously that isn't all going to happen like that, but we kind of need it to go a good way there for us to be premiership material.

This is what I would like our list structure to look like in 3 years time, to be top 4 capable and premiership ready.

Harsh on Georgiadis and Bergman not being a potential A grader.

Clearly our recruiting team disagree.

Other than that I agree on pretty much everything.

On SM-G960F using
BigFooty.com mobile app
 

NEGAN

Premium Gold
Apr 26, 2016
6,017
8,992
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really can't understand the constant underrating of Butters here. Last year - Limited preseason, immature body and one shoulder but showed breathtaking awareness, ball use and vision at times that is clearly elite.
Now leading the preseason stats and is in my view is clearly an elite mid in the making and could break out this year. (Could also have 2nd year blues but showing good early training signs....)

On SM-T830 using BigFooty.com mobile app
the only issue with Butters is our dumbass coach wants to tame him...

Let the boy play Ken...

Actually stay right away from him. At all times until we have an actual coach.
 

shewho

Club Legend
Oct 7, 2005
2,354
4,550
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Are there other teams?
Can’t disagree with a single post on this page- the most sense on this site in years. There is great potential in this list but a long way to go. We can’t afford to waste a pick soz Bergman and Georgiades have to work. No pressure but if this is a Butcher Moore Pittard draft not a Rozee Butters Duursma draft, we are rooted.
 

afl2004

Premiership Player
Feb 7, 2014
4,313
7,538
reynella
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Chelsea FC , Boston Red Sox/celtics
Lynch shouldn't have played the 1st month of this season , had no pre season he's everything we wanted from dixon
 

malcolm

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 8, 2004
9,955
10,673
holden hill
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
liverpool
The Power had four picks in the top 25, but none of the players they picked up is a Round 1 certainty at this stage. In fact the final player Port selected — father-son recruit Jackson Mead — might be the most likely candidate. A well-balanced midfielder with a booming kick, Mead played a few SANFL league games in 2019 and held his own. Fellow second-rounder Dylan Williams is an outside chance. Inconsistency and injury curtailed Williams’ campaign in 2019, but his upside is exciting and his natural talent is enormous. Miles Bergman is an exciting forward but will need time to develop in the SANFL, as will key forward Mitch Georgiades after missing all of 2019 due to injury.

 
Jun 11, 2019
252
345
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
The Power had four picks in the top 25, but none of the players they picked up is a Round 1 certainty at this stage. In fact the final player Port selected — father-son recruit Jackson Mead — might be the most likely candidate. A well-balanced midfielder with a booming kick, Mead played a few SANFL league games in 2019 and held his own. Fellow second-rounder Dylan Williams is an outside chance. Inconsistency and injury curtailed Williams’ campaign in 2019, but his upside is exciting and his natural talent is enormous. Miles Bergman is an exciting forward but will need time to develop in the SANFL, as will key forward Mitch Georgiades after missing all of 2019 due to injury.

I'd think Bergman is most likely to play thanks to his running capacity and need for his type in the team. The club mentioned how he was a great runner and compared him to duursma when we drafted him so I'd like to think he's a chance sooner rather than later.

Having said all that, we have a lot of players pushing for spots in the forward line so it may take an injury or two before he gets his chance.
 

Byrons Firen

Norm Smith Medallist
Dec 4, 2013
7,624
14,246
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
the maggies
The Power had four picks in the top 25, but none of the players they picked up is a Round 1 certainty at this stage.
None of last years were either 'cept maybe Rozee. As good as last yr was i'm predicting this year's to be better.
Gotta hunch we've really nailed this draft.
 

Adz2332

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 9, 2010
9,313
7,572
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
theres a hell of a lot of positions open for the taking at the mo

i can only see 15 players you can pencil in for 100% in round 1.

leaves 7 positions up for grabs. Couple in the Forward Line, Couple in the backline, Couple Mids, 1 ruck/ forward
 

Kiss from a Rozee

Club Legend
Nov 23, 2018
2,754
4,490
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
The Power had four picks in the top 25, but none of the players they picked up is a Round 1 certainty at this stage. In fact the final player Port selected — father-son recruit Jackson Mead — might be the most likely candidate. A well-balanced midfielder with a booming kick, Mead played a few SANFL league games in 2019 and held his own. Fellow second-rounder Dylan Williams is an outside chance. Inconsistency and injury curtailed Williams’ campaign in 2019, but his upside is exciting and his natural talent is enormous. Miles Bergman is an exciting forward but will need time to develop in the SANFL, as will key forward Mitch Georgiades after missing all of 2019 due to injury.

I reckon we’ll have 2 of the 4 play in round one and almost certainly see all 4 given games. Georgiades is perhaps the least likely, while Bergman is the most likely.
 

tribey

5 Wins In-A-Row Certificate Recipients '13/'14/'18
Mar 9, 2003
58,625
138,771
Queen St & Peter Rd
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
NUFC, YES.
I love Robbie like no other, but he wasnt elite, AA standard this year, which is what grade A is.
Yeah, I mean, let’s face it. He’s 32 with another gruelling preseason to come.

The days of him being a 500+ touch/30+ goal phenom are gone.

Which sucks.
 

Top Bottom