Our top 10: You decide

[Close to 17]

No 3
No 5
No 8
No 40
No 12
No 30
No 4
No 13
No 6
No 19

 

[Silvagnis]

I guess Gibbs isn't in our top ten.

 

[BlueTouchPaper]

Good to see you back!!

(Honestly) I still didn't see it after last night... Played a good last quarter though.

I guess I'm just looking for the wrong things in him and expecting/wanting him to do things he won't - He'll convince me soon enough, I'm sure!

 

[gandaal]

I guess Gibbs isn't in our top ten.

Not at present, no.

 

[Muji]

Carrots is really forcing his way in the first few games this yr.

If this rich vein of form continues, dont be surprised if he was added in many top 10s.

 

[GordonBlue]

Carrots is really forcing his way in the first few games this yr.

If this rich vein of form continues, dont be surprised if he was added in many top 10s.

He is third in mine and that was based on last year. I gave the reason why about 2 weeks ago in this thread.

 

[pepalenko]

Easy!

1. Andrew Walker
2. Lachlan Hansen
3. Marc Murphy
4. Jordan Russell
5. Matthew Leuenberger
6. Luke Blackwell
7. Andrew Carrazzo
8. Adam Hartlett
9. Adam Bentick
10. Josh Kennedy

11. Sam Sheldon
12. Aisake O'Hailpin
13. Paul Bower
14. Eddie Betts
15. Chris Judd

I'm sorry, but I was bored and in the interest of injecting some levity into the week, I came across this amazing prediction by the General. Number 15 hey.

 

[gbatman]

Well in recent times.

1. Heath Scotland
2. Andrew Carrazzo
3. Chris Judd
4. Marc Murphy
5. Brock Mclean
6. Eddie Betts
7. Kade Simpson
8. Mitch Robinson
9. Michael Jamison
10. Lachie Henderson

Honorable Mentions
Chris Yarran, Andrew Walker, Jarrad Waite, Bryce Gibbs, Dennis Armfield, Matthew Kreuzer.

 

[zeeCFC]

1. JUDD
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Betts
5. Yarran
6. Kreuzer
7. Simpson
8. Scotland
9. Walker
10. Garlett

11. Carrazzo
12. Gibbs
13. Laidler

From April this year...

1. Judd
2. Murphy
3. Betts
4. Carrazzo
5. Yarran
6. Henderson
7. Simpson
8. Scotland
9. Jamison
10. Cloke

 

[smashbox gill]

Based on Ability and Actual Output

1. Murphy
2. Judd
3. Carrazzo
4. Simpson
5. Scotland
6. Betts
7. Waite
8. Kruezer
9. Yarran
10. Gibbs

 

[FlowersByIrene]

1. Murphy
2. Judd
3. Carazzo
...............................^^^hard to split those three^^^..........................
4. Simpson
5. Betts

6. Waite
7. Walker
8. Kreuzer
9. Gibbs
10. Jamison

 

[Big Sim]

Top dozen (10 means leaving out people who shouldn't be left out) selected every week in no particular order:

Judd, Murph, Gibbs, Carrots, Simmo, Kruze, Hendo, Betts, Walker, Yarran, Jamo, Scotland.

Waite is not there because he is mostly not there.

 

[Muji]

3 years on from the last few posts..

Current top 10 as follows imo:

1. Cripps
2. Murphy
3. Tuohy
4. Simpson
5. Gibbs
6. Docherty
7. Kreuzer
8. Everitt
9. Jamison
10. Curnow

 

[P_Crippy]

First post is sad reading

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Our current top 10..? Well from the end of last season it would be...

1. Cripps
2. Murphy
3. Gibbs
4. Docherty
5. Simpson
6. Kreuzer
7. Casboult
8. Everitt
9.... ahhh i dunno?

 

[gbatman]

1. Cripps
2. Murphy
3. Simpson
4. Gibbs
5. Curnow
6. Touhy
7. Everitt
8. Docherty

Now it gets tough...

9.
10.

Any of these players...

Kreuzer, Kerridge, Thomas, Jamison, Casboult, White, Walker

Hopefully some surprises...

 

[gandaal]

1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Simpson
4. Cripps
5. Docherty
6. Touhy
7. Kreuzer
8. Curnow
9. Kerridge
10. Jamison

 

[james Dean]

1 - Murphy
2 - Cripps
3 - Gibbs
4 - Simpson
5 - Doc
6 - Jamison
7 - Kreuzer
8 - Touhy
9 - Daisy
10 - Casboult

Urgh, that's an uninspiring list

 

[Procrastinator35]

Jesaulenko
Nicholls
Doull
Walls
Southby
McKay
Johnson
Fitzpatrick
Kernahan
Bradley

 

[HBF]

1. Cripps
2. Murphy
3. Jamison
4. Kreuzer
5. Gibbs
6. Simpson
7. Casboult
8. Touhy
9. Kerridge
10. Curnow

 

[HBF]

Jesaulenko
Nicholls
Doull
Walls
Southby
McKay
Johnson
Fitzpatrick
Kernahan
Bradley

If that's in order you have Sticks way too low. Easily top 3 with Doull and Nicholls.

 

[DaVillaBlues]

1 Murphy
2 Cripps
3 Simpson
4 Doc
5 Everitt
6 Simpson
7 Tuohy
8 Jamison
9 Gibbs
10 Walker (when fit obviously)

 

[Procrastinator35]

If that's in order you have Sticks way too low. Easily top 3 with Doull and Nicholls.

Not in order.... Jezza is still the best blue I've seen.....Could play anywhere.

 

[HBF]

Not in order.... Jezza is still the best blue I've seen.....Could play anywhere.

Not old enough to have seen Jezza play, and barely remember Doull.
I find it hard to split Williams and Kernahan as the best Carlton player I have seen live, but my favourite all time Carlton player is Wayne Johnston.

 

[Procrastinator35]

Not old enough to have seen Jezza play, and barely remember Doull.
I find it hard to split Williams and Kernahan as the best Carlton player I have seen live, but my favourite all time Carlton player is Wayne Johnston.

Great finals player "The Dominator'..... Always remember him & Buckley tearing my Hawks apart, time after time, between 1979-1983....Bastard.