Overated Players

[freak29]

Just interested in anyones thoughts about overated players ion the tac cup. I think Shane Neaves from calder is probably the most overated. Any others?

 

[Silky]

Joel Selwood

 

[freakshow]

Joel Selwood

you have to be kidding! i cannot believe you just said that, obviously know nothing about the game cos he is a freak! i would love to know who else you think is over rated and would also love to know who u rate highly.

 

[chewy-on-your-boot]

Just interested in anyones thoughts about overated players ion the tac cup. I think Shane Neaves from calder is probably the most overated. Any others?

Wow. Shane Neaves overated??? And no, there are no others. After tommorrow's game against the Rebels, ask the Rebel ruckmen how underated he is. (Does TELSTRA allow people in the country to have internet and phones?)

You know even less about footy than I do.

I haven't seen any exaggerated comments about him.

Shane, along with every other player in the TAC CUP is learning his craft and doing his best to develop his footy skills to the highest standard that they can achieve by the end of this season. He has missed a large part of this season with a collar bone fracture and is still trying to catch up with those guys who have had the whole season to develop and improve. And he is catching up really quickly.

And after he is drafted at whatever pick he goes, will he still be overated???

If he doesn't get drafted then he is only as overated as the 570 other TAC CUP players who don't get drafted.

I suggest that you get back to your freak show.

 

[Silky]

you have to be kidding! i cannot believe you just said that, obviously know nothing about the game cos he is a freak! i would love to know who else you think is over rated and would also love to know who u rate highly.

Saw him in the U/18 championships.... pathetic did not do anything. I think a fair few others will agree and have agreed in previous threads about overrated players.. So much hype for so little return... I didnt know what number he was until someone told me.. kept a close eye on him for the rest of the match and hardly touched it... against SA this is and when he did get the ball he didnt do much with it..... The only asset he has is that hes hard at the ball