Overrated and underrated players in 2016 draft

[briztoon]

Shhhh. Exactly where I want him

Where a lot of teams are looking at him.

 

[eDPS]

Underrated: Corey Lyons, Jy Simpkin, Jake Waterman. Overrated: Daniel Venables, Jack Maibaum, Shai Bolton

 

[saintkildaman]

Overrated: SPS
Underrated: Sam Fisher

 

[Old navy]

Haven't seem Dylan play much other than a few highlights. But from player reports, I was made to believe in thinking that Dylan doesn't possess the same quickness as his brother? Hence only really an inside player. While Ryan is both inside/outside.
Is he just Ryan Clarke without the speed?

Think Dylan is more your contested ball and clearance beast, also has a reasonable left boot for an inside mid.
Ryan words " my younger brother is in a better position then I was in my draft year. "
Think he means Dylan is looking like a first round pick, were Ryan was always predicted to go around the 2nd round.

 

[MightyDons4]

Overrated: Venables, English, Villis
Underrated: B.Cox, Hampton, Fisher, Long

 

[Nuggs Bunny]

Priddis is an excellent disposer of the ball, Dangerfield can kick the ball 60+ so his disposal is irrelevant when he's gaining 100+ meters per disposal. Fyfe raised his disposal from 55% to 67% when he won the brownlow, which is actually above the competition average. Brodie is 189cm so he is no where near Fyfe's size inside a stoppage, nor is he anywhere near as clean as Priddis or has the explosiveness as Dangerfield.

189cm not near 190cm??????

 

[jackenny]

189cm not near 190cm??????

It's a game of centimetres.

Seriously, Ainsworth is overrated. Brodie is underrated.

 

[WCE_phil]

Think jeremy goddard is the most underrated player in this draft crop. Easily the best ruckman in this pool. English has a big bad case of gorringe about him and i think will likely be a bust. Goddard will be a beast and is both very aggressive and a very good tap ruckman for his age.

Of the WA players (the ones i watch most) Goddard, Fisher, SPP and Waterman are underrated while English is the most overrated player in the draft imo while SPS and Bolton are both overrated imo as well. I'd probably take Ryan over Bolton at this stage.

 

[TerryWallet]

Over-rated: Jordan Gallucci. Can't see much scope in him.

Under-rated: Until recently, Griffin Logue.

PS: I like how the Essendon boys are talking down the PEGS kid Venables. Good luck with 19. Kid might be an AFL star.

 

[The Bomb]

I love Powell-Pepper as his best he is bloody insane, Ainsworth is bloody good at times also, they just need consistency.
Scharenberg, Clarke & Lyons are consistently very good players, just not game breakers like the 2 above.
Graham should be spoken about more then he has been

These 6 could become the steals of this draft.

Garthwaite looks solid as a rock, but keep in mind the tall forwards look pretty pathetic.

Overrated is Jarman, Brayshaw I can't see anything in them at all.

 

[Two Planks]

Overrated SPS should be a 2nd rounder

Underrated Jack Scrimshaw should be top 5

 

[Southseas]

Zac Fisher is underrated - on the smaller side, but puts his body on the line and is good around stoppages. Have heard from people close to him that carlton are interested

 

[Danger in Texas]

Underrated: Fisher, Logue (rate him top 10), Atley, Stengle, Piper
Overrated: Villis, Rotham

 

[bird_man]

Overrated - SPS
Underrated - SPP

I also think that Taranto should be ahead of Brodie but has only really been talked about as a top ten in the last couple of weeks.

 

[Tippa43]

Zac Fisher and Jack Graham really underrated. Dont worry about Fishers size, hes going to be a good player. And its just glossed over the fact that Graham won the Larke medal.

 

[The Bomb]

Bailey Banfield Eagle father son I believe, just flying under the radar nicely for WC, I don't know much about him but know he is going really well.

 

[MightyDons4]

Over-rated: Jordan Gallucci. Can't see much scope in him.

Under-rated: Until recently, Griffin Logue.

PS: I like how the Essendon boys are talking down the PEGS kid Venables. Good luck with 19. Kid might be an AFL star.

Laverde MKII

 

[bergholt]

Zac Fisher and Jack Graham really underrated. Dont worry about Fishers size, hes going to be a good player. And its just glossed over the fact that Graham won the Larke medal.

The Larke has a pretty good strike rate but not perfect by any stretch:

https://www.draftguru.com.au/awards/larke-medal

 

[WCE_phil]

Bailey Banfield Eagle father son I believe, just flying under the radar nicely for WC, I don't know much about him but know he is going really well.

Different bailey banfield unfortunately. Can see bailey going anywhere from pick 40 to completely missing out.

 

[kangatragic]

Marshall looks very overrated from what I've seen of him. Surely not a top 10 pick.

 

[Sunraysia]

Brad Scheer - definitely underrated !
Not in todays game - so not in top 50...???
Suns laughing all the way to the bank.....

 

[JG22]

Marshall looks very overrated from what I've seen of him. Surely not a top 10 pick.

It's a long term investment
Blokes a few years away from senior footy

 

[Thewlis Dish]

It's a long term investment
Blokes a few years away from senior footy

The whole GWS academy stuff probably added to the hype.

 

[Arr0w]

Watching Will Brodie live his foot skills are a serious issue. I don't understand how a player can be rated so highly when he can't do a fundamental skill required in the game.

Completely agree, I don't rate him in the top 10


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JG22]

Completely agree, I don't rate him in the top 10


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

If he can do it even ok then he will be a very good player