Norm Smith Medallist
- Aug 17, 2015
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
look i dont think anyone would argue Paddy was a bust of a number one pick he obviously was but ill say our strick rate of picking dud players is well on par with every other club .. i mean no one talks about Patrick Veszpremi being taken before Cyril Rioli .... no one talks about Cale Morton being taken before Dangerfield...Jack Watts stands out there.
Two different discussions on McCartin's output for a #1 pick to if it was the right call for us or not. Still interesting to have a look at.
no one mentions Chris Yarren taken before Jack Ziebel or Aycee Cordy being picked over Luke Shuey
Trengrove over Dusty , Christian Howard,Jasper McMillan-Pittard, dan menzel, Luke tapscott, ben griffiths all taken befor Fyfe
Gorringe taken before Tom Lynch!!
EVERY club makes massive stuff ups in drafting our stuff ups are not and worse or any better than any other clubs stuff ups