Remove this Banner Ad

Paddywackers first round phantom draft.

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Paddywhackers

Cancelled
Jul 7, 2005
4,485
291
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Collingwood
1.) Melb - Watts.
Obvious choice super freak athlete and everyone knows he will be number one.

2.) WC - Natinui
Freak athlete West Coast need to replace Seaby

3.) Freo - Rich
The best available and a local boy.

4.) Port - Vickery
Very talented ruckmen which is just what the Power need with Lade getting old.

5.) Ess - Hill
Word is that the Bombers will take this man at number five.

6.) Carl - Hurley
Blues are in urgent need of a key backman so this is he obvious choice.

7.) Bris - Hartlett
Plays the game how Voss likes. Hard and tough!

8.) Rich - Trengove
The Tigers have built a young and talented midfield and will look for talls and this kid is a big talent.

9.) NM - McKernan
NM also have a decent midfield but lack quality talls. That is why they go for McKernan who is also the youger brother of Corey.

10.) Adel - Johnstone
Adel deperately need to go tall and this guy is just what they need. So many quality talls in this draft.

11.) Coll - Ziebell
Umbelievable that he slips to Collingwood. The steal of the draft. The only reason the Pies got him was because it is a super draft and other teams need to go tall. Hine strikes gold again!

12.) Syd - Swift
Swans take the gamble however kid has big upside.

13.) St. K - Sidebottom
Saints get the man they were looking for. A tough hard in and under.

14.) W.B - Cordy father and son

15.) Geel - Yarran
Just what the Cats want. A silky skilled indigenous player that will make Geelong even better to watch.

16.) Haw - Blease
Simply the best available.
 
I would love Ziebell but I doubt it will happen on Draft Day:(
 
A few things:

  • Its Lewis Johnstone
  • Seaby hasn't left the Eagles yet.
  • It's Trengove
  • You're putting Hill at 5 because it's what bigfooty has been saying recently, and
  • The Roos have more then enough talls.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Geelong might snatch up the best key defender option now that Egan is likely to discontinue his career.

I don't mind us taking McKernan, but saying that it's because we don't have any quality talls... oh and lol at the sweetener that he's the brother of Corey.
 
1
11.) Coll - Ziebell
Umbelievable that he slips to Collingwood. The steal of the draft. The only reason the Pies got him was because it is a super draft and other teams need to go tall. Hine strikes gold again!

I can't believe it:eek:

Oh and btw, there's little to no chance that the Crows will pick Johnston, they are apparently keen on Mckernan and Trengrove, but since both those are gone, since we go best available early, I'd think we'd go one of Ziebell, Swift, Sidebottom or Yarran, as we do need decent mids as much as we need decent tall forwards.
 
lol a Collingwood supporter makes sure his man drops to 11 hahaha
 
we have a quality midfield but are lacking talls?
is this opposite day?



yep i think you're alright for talls. Definitely need to start replinishing the midfield. Harris and Swallow are coming off bad years, Grant retires, Simpson is not far off. Sinclair gone as well.

Hale can play forward with Petrie and McIntosh in ruck. That sounds good. Defence is undersized but will hold because it has honest triers. Jessie Smith will bring back the run out of defence.



I think if Adelaide are keen on McKernan or Trengrove then they should get one of them. I reckon Johnston is the one they will get but i have not heard anything out of Adelaide so cant make a valid comment.

Can't see them falling earlier unless Essendon take Hurley and Carlton decide they want to go tall, and Richmond do the same.
 
lol a Collingwood supporter makes sure his man drops to 11 hahaha


It is no that difficult to see any given player drop. I also have ziebel going to collingwood especially if the rumours about Essendon being keen on Hill are true. In a draft with so many talented young player between the 4 and 20 bracket i really do wonder why you have to laugh when somebody thinks different to you.

Its probably too much to ask but would you apologise if a) ziebel did fall to collingwood, or b) fell past collingwood?
 
Saints have enough in and unders. We need some speedy outside midfeilders. Ball, Hayes, Armo, Jones.....

KPD or a fast halfforward/Midfeilder.

ie; Trengrove, Hill, Yarran or Blease
 

Remove this Banner Ad

LOL Ziebel falling to 11. The top 10 will comprise of these players:

Watts
Rich
Nat
Hartlett
Hill
Hurley
Yarran
Vickery
Ziebel
Sidebottem/Blease/Trengove
 
LOL Ziebel falling to 11. The top 10 will comprise of these players:

Watts
Rich
Nat
Hartlett
Hill
Hurley
Yarran
Vickery
Ziebel
Sidebottem/Blease/Trengove

One, that's twelve, not ten players, and two, you just can't be that sure. BF never gets it exactly right beforehand, not even close. Every chance two bolters, at least, make the top 10 that none of us saw coming.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

1.) Melb - Watts.
Obvious choice super freak athlete and everyone knows he will be number one.

2.) WC - Natinui
Freak athlete West Coast need to replace Seaby

3.) Freo - Rich
The best available and a local boy.

4.) Port - Vickery
Very talented ruckmen which is just what the Power need with Lade getting old.

5.) Ess - Hill
Word is that the Bombers will take this man at number five.

6.) Carl - Hurley
Blues are in urgent need of a key backman so this is he obvious choice.

7.) Bris - Hartlett
Plays the game how Voss likes. Hard and tough!

8.) Rich - Trengove
The Tigers have built a young and talented midfield and will look for talls and this kid is a big talent.

9.) NM - McKernan
NM also have a decent midfield but lack quality talls. That is why they go for McKernan who is also the youger brother of Corey.

10.) Adel - Johnstone
Adel deperately need to go tall and this guy is just what they need. So many quality talls in this draft.

11.) Coll - Ziebell
Umbelievable that he slips to Collingwood. The steal of the draft. The only reason the Pies got him was because it is a super draft and other teams need to go tall. Hine strikes gold again!

12.) Syd - Swift
Swans take the gamble however kid has big upside.

13.) St. K - Sidebottom
Saints get the man they were looking for. A tough hard in and under.

14.) W.B - Cordy father and son

15.) Geel - Yarran
Just what the Cats want. A silky skilled indigenous player that will make Geelong even better to watch.

16.) Haw - Blease
Simply the best available.
1 word NO
firstly Seaby is still an Eagle!!!!!!!
Secondly Woosh likes to develope Ruckman and we have enough.
Cox, Seaby, Sullivan, and Sneeden a NSW SS player.
We wont waste our first pick on potentual.
Sydney wont take a chance, unlike the rest of the league they cant drift so they will take sure things, They will pass on swift that is certain.
Yarran would be a perfect replacement for O'loughlin as his retirement isn't too far away.
However if as you guessed sidebottom is still available I have no doubts Sydney will take him.
Geelong- Need Defenders so why would they take a Small forward/ midfielder, Makes no sense they already have Varcoe and Djerrkura not to mention Stokes and Chapman.
I Think you tried which is good but next time mate look at the team requirements rather then who you want to slide so your team gets a good pick. :thumbsu:
 
1 word NO
firstly Seaby is still an Eagle!!!!!!!
Secondly Woosh likes to develope Ruckman and we have enough.
Cox, Seaby, Sullivan, and Sneeden a NSW SS player.
We wont waste our first pick on potentual.

I'm afraid the odds are you're going to look a fool come draft day. I've been Rich's biggest fan, but I don't think he's going to be running around in blue and gold next year.

I seem to recall using a certain draft selection #3 mostly on potential. What a dud he turned out to be.
 
1. melbourne............jack watts
2.w/coast...............n.naitanui
3.fremantle..............d.rich
4.port adelaide..........t.vickery
5.essendon...............yarren
6.carlton.................hurley
7.brisbane................swift
8.richmond................hartlett
9.nth melb................ziebell
10.adelaide...............trengove
11.collingwood............sidebottom
12.sydney...............mckernan
13.stkilda...................blease
14.western bulldogs......cordy
15.geelong..............lisle
16.hawthorn.................hill
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top