Remove this Banner Ad

Pakistan vs Australia (in the UAE)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

No issue with that catch for me. Once the batsman moves the field should be allowed to react.

As far as match-fixing goes, it's not "win the game" vs "lose the game" that they fix. Spot fixing is much more subtle than that.
 
No issue with that catch for me. Once the batsman moves the field should be allowed to react.

As far as match-fixing goes, it's not "win the game" vs "lose the game" that they fix. Spot fixing is much more subtle than that.

Agreed. People should really read 'Bookie Gambler Fixer Spy' before making comment. It's all about the manipulation of betting brackets - the thing that was overlooked in the Aamir/Asif scandal was that it was a demonstration of power - nowhere, not even in illegal Indian bookie markets can you bet on a specific event such as a no ball occurring on a particular delivery of the match.

However, 'Bookie Gambler Fixer Spy' does have some fairly strong allegations that the India-Pakistani World Cup Semi was fixed - speculated that it most likely as per an agreement of the two governments to avoid Pakistan playing in a World Cup final in Mumbai.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Not even classed as an FC match? Strange considering it's a 4 day A team match.

Both sides can use every player in the squad (though only 11 on field at a time and only 11 can bat per innings)
 
Would Hilfy ahead of Siddle be worth it?

Depends who can bowl the longer spells, that might be Hilfy but Sidds does bowl a good line and length.

On these wickets surely MJ, one of Hilfy/Siddle, Marsh (A/R), plus two spinners in O'Keefe/Lyon. Surely that is the attack.
 
O'Keefe making his case. 3/76 so far.
I know a few people (who have seen a lot more of him than me) around here are quite critical of his bowling. Did you or anyone else see much of the innings to see how he was actually going?
 
I know a few people (who have seen a lot more of him than me) around here are quite critical of his bowling. Did you or anyone else see much of the innings to see how he was actually going?

Not telecast or streamed anywhere.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Was a few highlights on Fox Sports News, but not much going around. May be something put up on CA website at some stage if we're lucky.
 
If the pitches are going to be dead - need both SOK and Lyon IMO

Marsh is good enough to be the third trundler.

Johnson
SOK
Siddle
Lyon

would be my four bowlers.

The 6th batsmen is more the quandry. What I will say is - bowlers are generally swapped around based on the pitch - why aren't batsmen?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Has to be 5 bowling options with either Marsh or Maxwell playing and at least two of them to be spinners. If Marsh can bowl, then it will be Johnson, Siddle, Lyon, SOK and Marsh, you'd think.

Batting depends on who is fit I suppose. Warner, Rogers, Doolan, Clarke, Smith, Marsh, Haddin, SOK, Johnson, Lyon, Siddle seems like the most likely side if everyone is fit.
 
I know a few people (who have seen a lot more of him than me) around here are quite critical of his bowling. Did you or anyone else see much of the innings to see how he was actually going?

The criticism is he is very round arm which means he is accurate but on pitches that don't offer much he doesn't get wickets. That said the pitches in the UAE are perfect for him.
 
Siddle isn't quick enough anymore
From all reports they were working with him to get it back? Either way he still deserves to be there or thereabout. The competition for spots is enough to ensure that if he doesn't do enough to keep it, he won't.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Pakistan vs Australia (in the UAE)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top