Patrick Cripps - The Captain

[Pinnell]

Why cause he took a mark tonight ? You know Judd is a premiership captain , something Cripps won't ever be

You’re a Collingwood supporter who’s only watched football since 1986. Cripps bleeds Carlton. Judd was a champion player - but he was all about Judd. No contest as to who is/was a better captain for our club.

 

[Worm4]

Why cause he took a mark tonight ? You know Judd is a premiership captain , something Cripps won't ever be

Cripps is a better Captain than your little princess. At least he fronts up every week . Your leader breaks a nail and he is out for 3 weeks. What a fraud

 

[LordLucifer]

Take it from fans who watched judds captaincy every week, and Cripps captaincy every week; Cripps has been better.

Yeah ............ don't know about that one !!!

 

[jakson68]

Cripps is a better Captain than your little princess. At least he fronts up every week . Your leader breaks a nail and he is out for 3 weeks. What a fraud

C'mon Wormy be better.
This isn't the banter thread. Old mate thought Judd was a better captain than Cripps (both guns in my opinion) and your retort, is to just have a crack at the captain of that posters team.
Which has nothing to do with his statement, it was just an opportunity for you to attempt to get one up.

 

[Chip Scab1]

Nice fantasy bro. Just a reminder, this Hawthorn team has done just as much as nothing as Carlton has done during Cripps' tenure.

Except for Jack. He's excluded and a marvel. But some of the other blokes act like the were part of the 3-Peat.

It's nauseating.

 

[RAPPA]

Why cause he took a mark tonight ? You know Judd is a premiership captain , something Cripps won't ever be

You’re confusing the comparison. The debate is their quality as a captain, not necessarily a measure of performance.

On a pure captaincy level, Judd was the smarter of the two but Cripps evoked more emotion and drive from his teammates. Also on a personality front I’d have Cripps ahead.

From the perspective of output, Cripps at Carlton has been superior to Judd at his time at Carlton. West coast Judd was ridiculously elite. By the time he arrived at Carlton he was the equivalent of an iPhone battery with a maximum charge of 80%

 

[Magpie Since 1986]

You’re confusing the comparison. The debate is their quality as a captain, not necessarily a measure of performance.

On a pure captaincy level, Judd was the smarter of the two but Cripps evoked more emotion and drive from his teammates. Also on a personality front I’d have Cripps ahead.

From the perspective of output, Cripps at Carlton has been superior to Judd at his time at Carlton. West coast Judd was ridiculously elite. By the time he arrived at Carlton he was the equivalent of an iPhone battery with a maximum charge of 80%

Im not confusing anything, up until 3-weeks ago half your supporters were saying Cripps is a greater player but not a greater leader, how the leaders don't stand up when it counts etc etc. Apparently one great mark and goal changes all that.

 

[RAPPA]

Im not confusing anything, up until 3-weeks ago half your supporters were saying Cripps is a greater player but not a greater leader, how the leaders don't stand up when it counts etc etc. Apparently one great mark and goal changes all that.

Half our supporters eh? Nice broad brushed statement. And when were the same supporters proclaiming Judd as the better leader?