Paul Haselby vs Daniel Kerr

[DOCKER MAN]

Who is a better player?

Both are in struggling teams and are the number 1 midfielders copping hard tags; this year however i think Haselby unlike Kerr has been able to stand up without good players around him, break tags and have a strong influence on games.
IMO Haselby

 

[Jonny27]

Kerr is such a shit player who cant even take a tag. Hasleby gets my vote for sure.

 

[numbat06]

has haselby even had a tag?

 

[Alvin Purple]

has haselby even had a tag?

Just about every week but you just don't notice it as much as because he doesn't spit the dummy like Kerr.

 

[Mattman93]

Is this a joke?

 

[Wizard]

Exactly mattman.
Hase is killing it this year and Kerr cant get a kick.

 

[Bert1]

In my opinion Kerr would have to be one of the most overated players in the AFL. Cousins and Judd made him look alot better than he is and now that he is no longer being breastfed by them he has been exposed as a pretty ordinary player.

 

[Jonny27]

In my opinion Kerr would have to be one of the most overated players in the AFL. Cousins and Judd made him look alot better than he is and now that he is no longer being breastfed by them he has been exposed as a pretty ordinary player.

 

[Claude Balls]

That Hasleby is winning this poll is mystifying to say the least... Kerr is far more talented.

 

[Wizard]

That Hasleby is winning this poll is mystifying to say the least... Kerr is far more talented.

True, but at the moment Hase is delivering and Kerr isn't.

 

[Claude Balls]

True, but at the moment Hase is delivering and Kerr isn't.

That's a reasonable assesment, but it doesn't mean Kerr isn't the better player.

 

[DOCKER MAN]

That's a reasonable assesment, but it doesn't mean Kerr isn't the better player.

ATM IMO Haselby has been playing better footy, breaking tags and having a big influence on games of footy. Kerr has done none of these things without the likes of Cousins and Judd around him, due to this i would think Haselby is a better player then Kerr.

 

[pinkus maximus]

has haselby even had a tag?

just his entire career

 

[MadMac]

Hase has better footy brains and is better in congestion. Kerr has more grunt, is better tackler and overall is harder player. May be a bit biased but I'd still rather have Hase at Freo than Kerr.

 

[Jatz]

kerr easily

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Kerr has more talent but isn't delivering, unlike Hase. Hase for me.

 

[adelaide_40]

That's a reasonable assesment, but it doesn't mean Kerr isn't the better player.

IMO a winning team would see kerr be the better player. He has talent but is a bit of a front runner, he cant seem to break tags

A struggling would see haselby. He is having more of a influence on matches while being tagged.


I'd go haselby.

 

[Spartan]

Haselby is underrated.

BUT

He has only played well this year when he hasn't been tagged. When hes been tag hes struggled as much as if not more than Kerr.

I'd take Kerr because a) I'm biased and b) Kerr is more talented.

 

[Wizard]

Did you watch the last half of the Sydney game when he had Kirk shadowing him.
He was injured and had Kirk running with him but was still super instrumental in our win.