Pavlich, Brown or Franklin?

[Bomber Man]

If you compare their 3rd seasons as 20 yr olds then Franklin is miles in front and considering thats all hes played so far thats all you can go on.

Brown had his best year ever this year and Buddy was just about as good.

See above post, 2002 was also Pav's 3rd season.

 

[Kochie 16]

BROWN! The best forward ATM!

Funny thing is if you conducted the same poll this time last year Pav would win probably!

 

[Bender571]

10 from 22 in 2002 was also the year he was AA Full Back.

Of course I forgot to mention Pav's AA's. 2002(fullback), 2003 (half forward flank), 2005 (centre half forward), 2006 (interchange) and 2007 (full forward),

See above post, 2002 was also Pav's 3rd season.

and 2007 was Pav's 3rd year as a forward, getting All-Australian honors in all 3 years.

But I'd choose Pav for his current run of 144 consecutive games, but thats just my opinion

 

[wce4premiership]

Would you really take Brown over Pav and Franklin?

I'm assuming your bias is against Pav cause he plays for freo?

Oh that was meant to be an equal sign