Pavlich vs Judd

[raskolnikov]

If I could pick one to come to the Dons it would be Judd.

 

[jod23]

Nine goals say different.

Not really no.

 

[SBI]

Not really no.

That is a silly comment.

You wouldn't say nine goals zip is the sign of a good player?

 

[ndot]

Judd!!!

 

[CyberKev]

Pavlich for sure.

Judd's good at what Judd does, but Pavlich is a complete package player and is the sort of utility player you can genuinely build a side around.

 

[raskolnikov]

Pavlich for sure.

Judd's good at what Judd does, but Pavlich is a complete package player and is the sort of utility player you can genuinely build a side around.

Yeah - Freo has been a gun team since Pav started playing for them.

 

[bluey17]

judd is and will be for a long time, the eagles best ever player ( a far more prestigious honour)

No

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Let's see now .. one is a match winning CHF, whilst the other is an over-rated dime-a-dozen midfielder who gets less of the ball than Pavlich does in a key position .. gee, tough choice

 

[davey_magik]

A more accurate comparison would be 'Judds best vs Pavlich's best'.

 

[Pav for AA]

Which of the two would you prefer on your list

If I was truly being honest I would take Judd in a heartbeat, the kid is once in a lifetime, someone we will talk about for a long time. He is essentially the carey of midfielders.
But I'm not being hinest so I'd say PAVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV

 

[Bentleigh]

A more accurate comparison would be 'Judds best vs Pavlich's best'.

No, its not.

Again - WHICH OF THE TWO would you prefer on your sides list.

 

[PAFC2004]

Two completely different positions... lets compare olive oil and spark plugs....

 

[jod23]

That is a silly comment.

You wouldn't say nine goals zip is the sign of a good player?

I never said Pavlich wasnt a good player??

Still rather Judd.

 

[Carn the Coasters]

I just watched Judd's goal v Brisbane again and now i need to change my pants.

 

[Bellablaise]

You are aware people play different position on a footy field, right?

 

[Bentleigh]

You are aware people play different position on a footy field, right?

Whats that got to do with

Which of the 2 would you rather on your list

?

 

[cs61]

Pavlich by a mile

 

[sinepari]

Which of the 2 would you rather on your list

?

Depends on what you need.

 

[fishbowl]

We have Hodge, we need Pavlich.

 

[cs61]

Can't believe its even a comparison. Pavlich is absolutely dominating. Judd does some brilliant things but doesn't dominate like Pav does. If you took Pavlich out of Freo and put Judd in, Freo wouldn't even be in the finals race. Same as if you put Pavlich in West Coast and took Judd out, West Coast would be almost unstoppable. Judd is an awesome player, but if offered an all australian centre half forward (will be this year) at 23 you take it over a high class midfielder.

 

[sabre_ac]

Bah
How can you compare a Midfielder and a CHF.
Hows this sound, would freo with Judd be as big as improvement as Eagles with Pavlich???
I think not.

Can't believe its even a comparison. Pavlich is absolutely dominating. Judd does some brilliant things but doesn't dominate like Pav does. If you took Pavlich out of Freo and put Judd in, Freo wouldn't even be in the finals race. Same as if you put Pavlich in West Coast and took Judd out, West Coast would be almost unstoppable. Judd is an awesome player, but if offered an all australian centre half forward (will be this year) at 23 you take it over a high class midfielder.

Oi that’s plagiarism.....

 

[jackson_rules]

Pavlich by a fair bit, judd will never be the player pavlich will be

 

[celtic_pride]

Pavlich .. Players like Pav can help win your team a flag .. Judd can't.