News Phil Walsh - New AFC Coach and Art Critic

(Log in to remove this ad.)

dylan123

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Posts
7,403
Likes
4,201
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Toronto Raptors
We haven't gotten much out of him since he was announced as the coach really!

He's got the same few lines he loves to stick to "striving for elite standards" "team defence" etc.

Not that I'm complaining as such as I'd much rather a side that performs on match day then a coach that says what we'd like to hear but I'd love for him to give us something! Can't get much out of him about any individuals, been quite surprised at how much of a closed book he's been. Probably wants to avoid being defined by saying something early as many other coaches have been.
 

Sanders

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Posts
25,438
Likes
32,836
AFL Club
Adelaide
Shaw having lots of strategies & confusing the players <> good strategist!

It's a main reason he was our worst coach.

Nothing wrong with my memory - unfortunately remember well as was hard attending those 2 seasons.
:rolleyes: geez...

I was being polite about the memory thing.

Shaw was appointed in large part because of his tactical nous, his demonstrated technical ability. He was a strategist, who had a reputation for being innovative with little cattle to work with. With a better set of players who just needed a bit of tough love to right the ship. That was the thinking. It didn't work, but he didn't become different type of coach because of it.

It doesn't really matter what your 7yr old self thought at the time ;)
 
Joined
May 21, 2001
Posts
49,519
Likes
38,511
Location
Floating around the Universe
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide Crows
:rolleyes: geez...

I was being polite about the memory thing.

Shaw was appointed in large part because of his tactical nous, his demonstrated technical ability. He was a strategist, who had a reputation for being innovative with little cattle to work with. With a better set of players who just needed a bit of tough love to right the ship. That was the thinking. It didn't work, but he didn't become different type of coach because of it.

It doesn't really matter what your 7yr old self thought at the time ;)
Re-read the 1st sentence of my last post. Actually, I will type it again...

Having lots of strategies does not equate to making a coach a good strategist come match day. Both Shaws (Robert & Tony) had a habit of changing the strategy frequently during the games, such that they became confused as to what they should be doing & lost the players.

Shaw may have come with a reputation of being a tactical genius, but in the end he was found out as not really having much of a clue match day. Only need to listen to most of the leadership group/past players comments on Shaw to have this confirmed.

It's also why when Blighty came in, his KISS method worked much better as clearer direction of what players needed to do & he usually only tweaked the strategy as required - rather than just to show he had a gazillion strategies in his head.
 

1970crow

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 7, 2011
Posts
26,724
Likes
27,450
Location
alice springs
AFL Club
Adelaide
:rolleyes: geez...

I was being polite about the memory thing.

Shaw was appointed in large part because of his tactical nous, his demonstrated technical ability. He was a strategist, who had a reputation for being innovative with little cattle to work with. With a better set of players who just needed a bit of tough love to right the ship. That was the thinking. It didn't work, but he didn't become different type of coach because of it.

It doesn't really matter what your 7yr old self thought at the time ;)
So he arrived with a reputation of having tactical nouse and left without it.
 
Joined
May 24, 2006
Posts
50,153
Likes
82,729
Location
Car 55
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
Moderator #3,032
I thought the perception at the time was that the skillful, handball happy, flowing South Australian style football of Cornes wasn't going to cut it in the big, tough Victorian league.

So that inferiority complex of ours told us that we needed a Victorian, any Victorian. We ended up with an average coach from an even more average club with the thinking that even an average Victorian must be better than a South Australian premiership coach who had taken us to AFL finals.

He clearly had some idea about the game. Continues to be employed in the industry and the players he blooded went on to win flags for us. Could obviously spot a good player and knew what type of player premiership teams needed. Tactically though?

Tony Hall, who I wish we heard more from because he is a smart bloke and excellent speaker, was asked about Shaw. He said he was great until we lost a game. Then he'd doubt himself and we'd change what we were doing. "I'm mystified" was Shaw's standard response whenever asked why something had gone wrong.
 

James_37

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 19, 2007
Posts
9,788
Likes
9,290
Location
Darwin
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
GCFC/Sturt/MLDFC
I thought the perception at the time was that the skillful, handball happy, flowing South Australian style football of Cornes wasn't going to cut it in the big, tough Victorian league.

So that inferiority complex of ours told us that we needed a Victorian, any Victorian. We ended up with an average coach from an even more average club with the thinking that even an average Victorian must be better than a South Australian premiership coach who had taken us to AFL finals.

He clearly had some idea about the game. Continues to be employed in the industry and the players he blooded went on to win flags for us. Could obviously spot a good player and knew what type of player premiership teams needed. Tactically though?

Tony Hall, who I wish we heard more from because he is a smart bloke and excellent speaker, was asked about Shaw. He said he was great until we lost a game. Then he'd doubt himself and we'd change what we were doing. "I'm mystified" was Shaw's standard response whenever asked why something had gone wrong.
Yeah, good post. Whilst I'm too young to remember it properly, I get the feeling even Cornes believed the "we need a Victorian Coach" line. We certainly moved quickly after the failure of 1994. Sadly had we given Cornes another year, we could have grabbed Chad Cornes Father-Son, such we're the rules those days.

In a way Shaw and Craig were same, same but different, where one was too flexible and quick to change up plans, the other was too rigid, but in the end bOth struggled when things didn't go their way. Hopefully Walsh can bring an awesome Plan A, but understand when plans B and C are and aren't required.

Craig had a lot of success having an intricate, well thought out game plan, however up against the best in finals, when even the best laid plans can fail, he had no answer.
 

Pdub

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Posts
7,065
Likes
16,724
Location
Gold Coast
AFL Club
Adelaide
So is this what "no-spin" "authentic" football club means?

Question on Facebook


then on the AFC website http://www.afc.com.au/news/2015-01-15/phil-walsh-qa

apparently the question was

You mentioned the need for 'man talks' with the leadership group, what exactly is that?

“Man conversations mean speaking your mind, even if you may not get what you want, so everyone knows where you stand on issues. That's the culture we want at the Adelaide footy club.”
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Pdub

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Nov 16, 2014
Posts
7,065
Likes
16,724
Location
Gold Coast
AFL Club
Adelaide
And you expected? What exactly?
Better. You can acknowledge a question and not answer it, you can say you won't bring private questions into the public. Don't answer a question that wasn't asked.

I know Phil is new to the media game, but you can't mention that there were disagreements and then not give any more information, it's what has caused massive speculation, particularly on this board.
 

DD#23

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 31, 2013
Posts
9,127
Likes
12,319
AFL Club
Adelaide
Better. You can acknowledge a question and not answer it, you can say you won't bring private questions into the public. Don't answer a question that wasn't asked.

I know Phil is new to the media game, but you can't mention that there were disagreements and then not give any more information, it's what has caused massive speculation, particularly on this board.
I agree that changing the question on the afc website is extremely dodgy, but private conversations are private conversations and I have no issue with the way it was answered by Phil.
 

Peter J

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Dec 24, 2008
Posts
15,665
Likes
27,977
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Better. You can acknowledge a question and not answer it, you can say you won't bring private questions into the public. Don't answer a question that wasn't asked.

I know Phil is new to the media game, but you can't mention that there were disagreements and then not give any more information, it's what has caused massive speculation, particularly on this board.
None of that provides any further information though.

I'm not really sure it matters too much how he says it's none of your business does it?
 

Apsaalooke

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 23, 2012
Posts
2,187
Likes
3,051
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Double Blues
Yeah, good post. Whilst I'm too young to remember it properly, I get the feeling even Cornes believed the "we need a Victorian Coach" line. We certainly moved quickly after the failure of 1994. Sadly had we given Cornes another year, we could have grabbed Chad Cornes Father-Son, such we're the rules those days.

In a way Shaw and Craig were same, same but different, where one was too flexible and quick to change up plans, the other was too rigid, but in the end bOth struggled when things didn't go their way. Hopefully Walsh can bring an awesome Plan A, but understand when plans B and C are and aren't required.

Craig had a lot of success having an intricate, well thought out game plan, however up against the best in finals, when even the best laid plans can fail, he had no answer.
Graham Cornes has even said that he offered to stay on as an 'honorary' club official for another year in order to qualify his sons for the Crows, but the club declined :(
 

Sanders

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Posts
25,438
Likes
32,836
AFL Club
Adelaide
So he arrived with a reputation of having tactical nouse and left without it.
Nah not really. Got hired straight back into Essendon in a tactical role. Very similar to the one we recruited Walsh from :p

Shaw wasn't ready for or couldn't handle the fishbowl atmosphere in adelaide at the time. The players all said that he started off great, but after a couple of bad losses, with the media on his tail he started to doubt himself. Became gun shy and lost his nerve.

This was back at the time when his house was being pelted with eggs, his kids were being abused etc. Nasty time all round, and he cracked.

Put it this way Terry Wallace is a tactician, and a lousy list manager. Just cause he sucked at richmond doesn't change the type of coach he was.

Shaw wasn't able to handle the pressure and we as a club could probably have done more to protect him in hindsight. But i don't reckon we expected it or knew what to do either. It was made worse cause he was Victorian too.
 

Geoffa32

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 17, 2007
Posts
42,832
Likes
34,567
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
The Autobots and Team America
Nah not really. Got hired straight back into Essendon in a tactical role. Very similar to the one we recruited Walsh from :p

Shaw wasn't ready for or couldn't handle the fishbowl atmosphere in adelaide at the time. The players all said that he started off great, but after a couple of bad losses, with the media on his tail he started to doubt himself. Became gun shy and lost his nerve.

This was back at the time when his house was being pelted with eggs, his kids were being abused etc. Nasty time all round, and he cracked.

Put it this way Terry Wallace is a tactician, and a lousy list manager. Just cause he sucked at richmond doesn't change the type of coach he was.

Shaw wasn't able to handle the pressure and we as a club could probably have done more to protect him in hindsight. But i don't reckon we expected it or knew what to do either. It was made worse cause he was Victorian too.

I reckon the pressure of being the head coach will be Walhy's biggest test.

He wont have issues tatically or with the players at training. It will be having to deal with the media and public.
 

The Sloane Ranger

Premium Platinum
Joined
Dec 22, 2008
Posts
25,944
Likes
31,810
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
CDFC
I reckon the pressure of being the head coach will be Walhy's biggest test.

He wont have issues tatically or with the players at training. It will be having to deal with the media and public.
Easiest way to deal with the media and public is to win games of footy
 

AFC979810

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Nov 5, 2009
Posts
6,406
Likes
4,667
AFL Club
Adelaide
I reckon the pressure of being the head coach will be Walhy's biggest test.

He wont have issues tatically or with the players at training. It will be having to deal with the media and public.
Disagree with the media part.

Fagan is fantastic with media dealings and has brought this to the club. Make absolutely no mistake this is 100% Fagan. From day one of his hiring - we have had the whole club singing the same tune. There is a very very clear and concise way that we are going to come across to the media and the public.

Fagan identified us as a club which was soft and tried to please everyone. We were more about marketing and 'spin' than results on the football field.

We are now an 'Authentic football club'. This means that we are mostly focused on getting results on the football - not being a nice club. We have a plan on how to do deal with the media / fans and thats already in play. Walsh will be under no pressure for how the media responds to him from the club. We have replaced the nice coach who has the players over for dinner (Sando) with a gruff guy who doesn't publicly thank our previous captain for a job well done. We have replaced our intelligent choir boy captain with a guy who had a mullet for 2 years and can barely construct a proper sentence.

This is one of the biggest turnarounds of a sporting clubs culture that I have seen in a 6 month period in professional sport.

And for all the discussion about Walsh and his 'Man Conversation'. This once again comes from the top and is a Faganism.
 

Geoffa32

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 17, 2007
Posts
42,832
Likes
34,567
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
The Autobots and Team America
Disagree with the media part.

Fagan is fantastic with media dealings and has brought this to the club. Make absolutely no mistake this is 100% Fagan. From day one of his hiring - we have had the whole club singing the same tune. There is a very very clear and concise way that we are going to come across to the media and the public.

Fagan identified us as a club which was soft and tried to please everyone. We were more about marketing and 'spin' than results on the football field.

We are now an 'Authentic football club'. This means that we are mostly focused on getting results on the football - not being a nice club. We have a plan on how to do deal with the media / fans and thats already in play. Walsh will be under no pressure for how the media responds to him from the club. We have replaced the nice coach who has the players over for dinner (Sando) with a gruff guy who doesn't publicly thank our previous captain for a job well done. We have replaced our intelligent choir boy captain with a guy who had a mullet for 2 years and can barely construct a proper sentence.

This is one of the biggest turnarounds of a sporting clubs culture that I have seen in a 6 month period in professional sport.

And for all the discussion about Walsh and his 'Man Conversation'. This once again comes from the top and is a Faganism.
I agree with you, and yes it does appear to be the line the club is taking. I just hope we stick to this and not falter under real pressure from the media and a worry about our image.

As The Sloane Ranger has said, if we win games this is not an issue and Walsh can do what he wants at pressers. But if we are losing that gruff exterior can wear thin when results are not being seen. Rooch will pick up on this quickly and drill him. His test will be holding it together and still wanting the job when times are tough.


I personally think he will be as good as Ken Hinkely with the media. Ken was also reluctant in the media when he started and was very "down the line" and does talk in cliches. But he has not been tested yet, no knives have come out. He has had a very good run. The real test will be if they start losing and in danger of missing the 8.

Walsh has his cliches and mannerisms, easy to control a presser now with them, will be harder when times are tough.
 

Red mist

Reynholm Industries
Joined
Jun 30, 2014
Posts
24,558
Likes
31,409
Location
The Winchester
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Tottenham Hotspur, East Side Hawks
Disagree with the media part.

Fagan is fantastic with media dealings and has brought this to the club. Make absolutely no mistake this is 100% Fagan. From day one of his hiring - we have had the whole club singing the same tune. There is a very very clear and concise way that we are going to come across to the media and the public.

Fagan identified us as a club which was soft and tried to please everyone. We were more about marketing and 'spin' than results on the football field.

We are now an 'Authentic football club'. This means that we are mostly focused on getting results on the football - not being a nice club. We have a plan on how to do deal with the media / fans and thats already in play. Walsh will be under no pressure for how the media responds to him from the club. We have replaced the nice coach who has the players over for dinner (Sando) with a gruff guy who doesn't publicly thank our previous captain for a job well done. We have replaced our intelligent choir boy captain with a guy who had a mullet for 2 years and can barely construct a proper sentence.

This is one of the biggest turnarounds of a sporting clubs culture that I have seen in a 6 month period in professional sport.

And for all the discussion about Walsh and his 'Man Conversation'. This once again comes from the top and is a Faganism.
Focused on getting results, not being a nice club reminds me of the unsociable football mantra another club uses.
 

Rorys458

Premium Platinum
Joined
Apr 20, 2001
Posts
25,822
Likes
8,765
Location
Adelaide Oval / Anfield
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide Utd,Liverpool, WWT Eagles.
:rolleyes: geez...

I was being polite about the memory thing.

Shaw was appointed in large part because of his tactical nous, his demonstrated technical ability. He was a strategist, who had a reputation for being innovative with little cattle to work with. With a better set of players who just needed a bit of tough love to right the ship. That was the thinking. It didn't work, but he didn't become different type of coach because of it.

It doesn't really matter what your 7yr old self thought at the time ;)
He was appointed because he was a hard nose Victorian as we were considered soft.
 

mattymac

GM of Awareness
Joined
Jul 9, 2009
Posts
12,942
Likes
21,019
Location
Yes
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
No
Just listened to the SEN interview. Good stuff. Now that we've got the introductions out of the way and he doesn't have to repeat his life story and philosophy in every interview we're starting to see a bit more of what he's like. No nonsense but talks a lot of sense and cracks a decent joke now and then. I like it. I think the media will too.
 
Top Bottom