Remove this Banner Ad

Pick 1 2023 Trade value - What would it take?

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
WCE_phil said:
With the CBA almost certainly guaranteeing top 20 picks a min 3 year contract I don't see anything that would be enough to see WCE not selecting Reid at pick 1.
Click to expand...
Would that be this year (as in would it apply to Reid)?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Priddis Is Done said:
The circle jerk over Reid has slowed right down.

Unanimous acceptance now that Reid will be at WCE. Even the media has given up.
Click to expand...

Yeah and they’ll lose interest to the point Luke Darcy forgets his name and calls him Harlem Reid even if he turns into the best player in the league.
 
WCE_phil said:
With the CBA almost certainly guaranteeing top 20 picks a min 3 year contract I don't see anything that would be enough to see WCE not selecting Reid at pick 1.
Click to expand...
The risk with a "homesick" player isn't necessarily that they will leave. It's that they won't enjoy the lifestyle or reach their potential.

If North kept JHF this year then it wouldn't have been pretty. I think that they still would have traded him if he had 2 years left.

I'm not saying that this is actually the case with Reid, but if it was a concern for the eagles then they would be weighing up an unhappy, homesick Reid vs a happy, local Curtin or even McKercher if their evaluation of him is that he will be more happy to move.
 
JGreezy said:
The risk with a "homesick" player isn't necessarily that they will leave. It's that they won't enjoy the lifestyle or reach their potential.

If North kept JHF this year then it wouldn't have been pretty. I think that they still would have traded him if he had 2 years left.

I'm not saying that this is actually the case with Reid, but if it was a concern for the eagles then they would be weighing up an unhappy, homesick Reid vs a happy, local Curtin or even McKercher if their evaluation of him is that he will be more happy to move.
Click to expand...
apart from mckercher and sanders who are tasmanians and have to leave to play afl which victorian kid wnats to leave victoria?
Watson,caddy,dursma etc.
 
WCE In: Pick 2 and 4
WCE Out: Pick 1, F3

North In: Pick 5, 11,
North Out: Pick 2, 39

WBD In: F1 (Hawks)
WBD Out: Pick 11 and 18

Hawks In: Pick 1, 65
Hawks Out: Pick 4, 29 and F1

GC Suns In: F1 (Crows), 29, 39
GC Out: Pick 5, 65

Adel In: Pick 9, F3 (WCE)
Adel Out: F1 and 23

Ess In: Pick 18 and 23
Ess Out: Pick 9

Who kicks and screams?

1. H.Reid (Hawks)
2. D.Curtin (WCE)
3. Duursma (North)
4. Mckercher (WCE)
5. N.Watson (North)
6. C.Osullivan (Melb)
7. R.Sanders (GWS)
8. N.Caddy (Geel)
9. C.Windsor (Adel)
10. D.Wilson (Adel)
11. O.Murphy (North)
12. Hardeman (Swans)
13. Demattia (Saints)
14. J.Leake (GWS)
15. C.Edwards (Carl)
16. A.Roberts (Melb)
17. M.Edwards/W.Green (North)
18. A.Reid (Ess)
19. W.Green/M.Edwards (Pies)
20. Tholstrup (WCE)
21. T.Jiath (Adel)
22. Sanchez/Collard (Freo)
23. L.Morris(Syd)
24. G.Stevens (Ess)
 
chaddy22 said:
apart from mckercher and sanders who are tasmanians and have to leave to play afl which victorian kid wnats to leave victoria?
Watson,caddy,dursma etc.
Click to expand...
I don't know. I haven't spoken to them. I don't even know if Reid does or doesn't want to go.

I'm just saying that WC would be weighing up more than if they can get him to not demand a trade. They would be weighing up how much the away from factor will impact his personal development.
 
Keystone agony said:
WCE In: Pick 2 and 4
WCE Out: Pick 1, F3

North In: Pick 5, 11,
North Out: Pick 2, 39

WBD In: F1 (Hawks)
WBD Out: Pick 11 and 18

Hawks In: Pick 1, 65
Hawks Out: Pick 4, 29 and F1

GC Suns In: F1 (Crows), 29, 39
GC Out: Pick 5, 65

Adel In: Pick 9, F3 (WCE)
Adel Out: F1 and 23

Ess In: Pick 18 and 23
Ess Out: Pick 9

Who kicks and screams?

1. H.Reid (Hawks)
2. D.Curtin (WCE)
3. Duursma (North)
4. Mckercher (WCE)
5. N.Watson (North)
6. C.Osullivan (Melb)
7. R.Sanders (GWS)
8. N.Caddy (Geel)
9. C.Windsor (Adel)
10. D.Wilson (Adel)
11. O.Murphy (North)
12. Hardeman (Swans)
13. Demattia (Saints)
14. J.Leake (GWS)
15. C.Edwards (Carl)
16. A.Roberts (Melb)
17. M.Edwards/W.Green (North)
18. A.Reid (Ess)
19. W.Green/M.Edwards (Pies)
20. Tholstrup (WCE)
21. T.Jiath (Adel)
22. Sanchez/Collard (Freo)
23. L.Morris(Syd)
24. G.Stevens (Ess)
Click to expand...
Superb attempt. Seems eminently credible.
 
Caligo said:
Superb attempt. Seems eminently credible.
Click to expand...
Hawks wouldnt go in with many points

Pick 48 and 65 = 392 Points

Would likely be 46 and 59 = 489 Points at time of bid

Will then also be the chance to trade out 46 for say eagles 52 and 54 (which is what they'd be in this scenario at bid)

Which is an extra 135 points = 624
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Keystone agony said:
Hawks wouldnt go in with many points

Pick 48 and 65 = 392 Points

Would likely be 46 and 59 = 489 Points at time of bid

Will then also be the chance to trade out 46 for say eagles 52 and 54 (which is what they'd be in this scenario at bid)

Which is an extra 135 points = 624
Click to expand...
I wouldn't want to actually do the deal as a Hawks fan. Happy just to trade 28 for a few lower picks to cover McCabe and try to get some good players with 3 (duursma?) and F1.

But I still really respect the effort. Seems pretty fair all round.
 
JGreezy said:
I don't know. I haven't spoken to them. I don't even know if Reid does or doesn't want to go.

I'm just saying that WC would be weighing up more than if they can get him to not demand a trade. They would be weighing up how much the away from factor will impact his personal development.
Click to expand...
Isn't a problem or discussion with any other eastern state player we recruit.

He's already toured WCE facilities, so let's knock all this fantasy on it's head.
 
Keystone agony said:
WCE In: Pick 2 and 4
WCE Out: Pick 1, F3

North In: Pick 5, 11,
North Out: Pick 2, 39

WBD In: F1 (Hawks)
WBD Out: Pick 11 and 18

Hawks In: Pick 1, 65
Hawks Out: Pick 4, 29 and F1

GC Suns In: F1 (Crows), 29, 39
GC Out: Pick 5, 65

Adel In: Pick 9, F3 (WCE)
Adel Out: F1 and 23

Ess In: Pick 18 and 23
Ess Out: Pick 9

Who kicks and screams?

1. H.Reid (Hawks)
2. D.Curtin (WCE)
3. Duursma (North)
4. Mckercher (WCE)
5. N.Watson (North)
6. C.Osullivan (Melb)
7. R.Sanders (GWS)
8. N.Caddy (Geel)
9. C.Windsor (Adel)
10. D.Wilson (Adel)
11. O.Murphy (North)
12. Hardeman (Swans)
13. Demattia (Saints)
14. J.Leake (GWS)
15. C.Edwards (Carl)
16. A.Roberts (Melb)
17. M.Edwards/W.Green (North)
18. A.Reid (Ess)
19. W.Green/M.Edwards (Pies)
20. Tholstrup (WCE)
21. T.Jiath (Adel)
22. Sanchez/Collard (Freo)
23. L.Morris(Syd)
24. G.Stevens (Ess)
Click to expand...
Every non Essendon list manager would say no - imagine Dodoro with that many moving parts
 
Hawks_4478 said:
When did he tour WCE facilities?
Click to expand...
WA v Vic Country game at Perth. The VC team had use of the club’s facilities which are top shelf

Harley also spent time with his mate Noah Long who told him how great life was in Perth
 
Priddis Is Done said:
Isn't a problem or discussion with any other eastern state player we recruit.

He's already toured WCE facilities, so let's knock all this fantasy on it's head.
Click to expand...
I think that it would be a topic of discussion with every interstate recruit to every side. And they would tend to recruit the ones that they are comfortable with.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

RanaNaved said:
Big gap between them and O'Sullivan imo
Click to expand...
Murphy performed better at the champs. I really think he'll be as good, will just take longer as he's not as physically developed.
 
AsterixTheGaul said:
WA v Vic Country game at Perth. The VC team had use of the club’s facilities which are top shelf

Harley also spent time with his mate Noah Long who told him how great life was in Perth
Click to expand...
Liar. Longy told him he hates it and they spent their time together looking at Webjet for flights out of there.

Longy was probably actually telling him about the Hip-E-Club.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top