Pick 2 Update...

[eliasd82]

I hope that Jake Carlisle is still available at pick 18 and we take him.

Pick #1: Tom Scully
Pick #2: Jack Trengove
Pick #18: Jake Carlisle
Pants creamed: Dez

Agreed.
But would prefer Panos at 18 if he was available.

 

[CM Sean]

What about Lewis Jetta? Is he worth 18 or is it possible he could slip to our next pick?

 

[Dez!]

What about Lewis Jetta? Is he worth 18 or is it possible he could slip to our next pick?

He may still be available at 18 but after getting Scully and Trengove which it looks like what we will be doing I don't see why we should select Jetta, 18 should be used on the best KPF remaining.

 

[CM Sean]

He may still be available at 18 but after getting Scully and Trengove which it looks like what we will be doing I don't see why we should select Jetta, 18 should be used on the best KPF remaining.

I spose your right, but that's IF we take Trengove. Which in all honesty, I hope we do.

 

[Punchy Demons]

Been in the Trengove camp for a while now & the more I see - the more I like. We have to take the best player and I don't think there is any doubt now that Scully & Trengove are the best two available.

 

[pwdrock]

jetta's performance in the wafl final on the weekend was pretty average to say the least.. couldn't shake his man and had very little impact.. not worth pick 18 imo

 

[Fairtex09]

jetta's performance in the wafl final on the weekend was pretty average to say the least.. couldn't shake his man and had very little impact.. not worth pick 18 imo

you base all this off one game? I'd hate to see what you'd do as list manager of melbourne.

 

[Dez!]

jetta's performance in the wafl final on the weekend was pretty average to say the least.. couldn't shake his man and had very little impact.. not worth pick 18 imo

Surely you aren't basing your opinions of a player on one game are you?

He's definitely worth pick 18 but we should be going with a KPF at 18 should we select Scully and Trengove at 1 and 2.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

He's definitely worth pick 18 but we should be going with a KPF at 18 should we select Scully and Trengove at 1 and 2.

Which KPFs do we want?

Players who I have heard bandied around (yet know not alot about are):

Panos - Forward
Carlise-Utility
Talia -CHB/Swingman

I would be happy to have any.

 

[Captain Jack]

Which KPFs do we want?

Players who I have heard bandied around (yet know not alot about are):

Panos - Forward
Carlise-Utility
Talia -CHB/Swingman

I would be happy to have any.

well from what i've seen, panos seems destined for port or carlton, talia likely to hawthorn, carlisle should get through to pick 18. scully, trengove, carlisle - stoked.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

well from what i've seen, panos seems destined for port or carlton, talia likely to hawthorn, carlisle should get through to pick 18. scully, trengove, carlisle - stoked.

That would be good. I also want Grimes Jnr with pick 34, nothing wrong with depth in the squad, though people will argue we have surplus there is nothing wrong with pressure for spots.

 

[Dez!]

Daniel Talia
[YOUTUBE]Xv8PN_msTcw[/YOUTUBE]

Jake Carlisle
[YOUTUBE]8OKDb_RRrWk[/YOUTUBE]

Matthew Panos
[YOUTUBE]cWI_Vy4vxBo[/YOUTUBE]

Those are three main ones that people seem to think will still be around the 11-20 mark although I have heard talk about Panos going top 10. I'm the same as you though, I'd be happy with any just so long as we can pick one of them up.

Jack Fitzpatrick is another potential one but he's a ruckman/forward who seems like a gamble, he was unbelievably rake-like when I saw him at the U/18 Championships and did seem to go missing quite a bit but could potentially be a very good player but could just as easily be a flop.

 

[master bate]

Maybe start a best talls (preferably forwards) for Pick 18 thread.

Butcher, Panos, Talia, Carlise, Fitzpatrick, Griffiths etc.

 

[pwdrock]

not on one game, seen a few, didn't look overly impressive, but thats just my opinion..

 

[Demon 16]

Which KPFs do we want?

Players who I have heard bandied around (yet know not alot about are):

Panos - Forward
Carlise-Utility
Talia -CHB/Swingman

I would be happy to have any.

Talia would be the first choice for sure, then probably Panos only just ahead of Carlisle.

If all 3 are gone (and this is what Im worried might happen), there will still be some quality midfielders left and I dont think Griffiths or Fitzpatrick are good enough to pass up on guys like Tapscott, Duncan, Gysberts etc.

I am worried we might not get the tall forward we are hoping for - but Carlisle is the most likely.

 

[Dez!]

Maybe start a best talls (preferably forwards) for Pick 18 thread.

Butcher, Panos, Talia, Carlise, Fitzpatrick, Griffiths etc.

Griffiths was the one I forgot, so it's almost certain we will have a KPF available for us at pick 18.

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

I want Temel from the cannons with a late pick.

 

[KTLK]

Talia would be the first choice for sure, then probably Panos only just ahead of Carlisle.

If all 3 are gone (and this is what Im worried might happen), there will still be some quality midfielders left and I dont think Griffiths or Fitzpatrick are good enough to pass up on guys like Tapscott, Duncan, Gysberts etc.

I am worried we might not get the tall forward we are hoping for - but Carlisle is the most likely.

This is where Butcher should be drafted at Pick 2

 

[KTLK]

Griffiths was the one I forgot, so it's almost certain we will have a KPF available for us at pick 18.

Griffiths is an injury prone with OP problems.

No Thanks Dez

 

[Dez!]

Griffiths is an injury prone with OP problems.

No Thanks Dez

Oh well, could be worse he could have question marks over his kicking.

He'll be right.

 

[KTLK]

Oh well, could be worse he could have question marks over his kicking.

He'll be right.

If MFC is heading to Trengrove at Pick 2, I am happy with any one of Panos, Talia or Carlise at Pick 18. (Besides Butcher at Pick 2 of course )

However, for Griffiths at Pick 18 is a BIG BIG NO and is NOT worth the risk

 

[Dez!]

Also forgot Aaron Black, there's a lot more safer options in KPF's than Butcher that we could get at pick 18.

Panos, Talia, Carlisle, Griffiths, Black and Fitzpatrick.

We are pretty much guaranteed one of them, any one of the first 5 will do me and only select Fitzpatrick if the other 5 are gone.

 

[richskee]

I'd happily trade pick 2 for Tippett, that way Adelaide would get there boy Trengove and we would get a gun forward.

thoughts?

 

[Dez!]

I'd happily trade pick 2 for Tippett, that way Adelaide would get there boy Trengove and we would get a gun forward.

thoughts?

Sounds good but Adelaide wouldn't go for it, as much as they'd love Trengove they'd love to keep Tippett even more.

I mean if they agreed to it though, I'd definitely support it.

 

[omit]

it's been said before hundreds of times on this forum before. Tippet is worth more than just pick 2