Croft will nominate
Pick 4 on the table?
- Thread starter Enviable Tradition
- Start date
- Tagged users None
No way you are bidding on Reid at 3
Why?
He’s what we need and there’s no way you don’t match anyway.
Clarko seems spiteful enough to me
500-600 points or so - nothing major. Clarko can whinge about Suns all he wants
You don't blackmail teams.
500-600 points or so - nothing major. Clarko can whinge about Suns all he wants
As I said, it could be 1,000 points.
It’s not really a blackmail, because if he had pick 1 and could use it on Walter we would.
Read looks very impressive and we need KPP so I could totally see us bidding on him at 3 or 4.
I agree the angry dwarf is spiteful, has no reason to be against the Suns. All I would say is what goes around comes around
Caligo
Premiership Player
- Aug 18, 2023
- 3,556
- 2,846
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
He does have reason to hate the Suns. They were pretty nasty during the JOM trade.
Retrospectively, Hawthorn should have walked away when GC kept demanding more indefinitely.
Pick 17 is equal to the 1000 points you’re quoting. Doable and would give us reason to raid your club or help others that want to. Not sure North or any club wants that heat.
The Suns have a different view on that trade, JOM was considered to be the next big thing across the league and our club was getting raided by the VIC clubs left and right. We had to make someone pay to put a line in the sand. It happened to be Hawthorn, but as you said you could have walked away at anytime.
Let's say North get pick 3 for Mckay and bid on Walter and Read with pick 2, 3 = that's 3800 points to match after 20%.
If North don't bid and Hawks bid on Walter with pick 4 and other team on Reads with pick 6. That's 3028 after discount. Difference 772 points (pick 25).
By trading pick 4 to WB as suggested is around 800 points overs. The follow-on trading pick 10, 17 will bring more points as overs.
I hope I got numbers correct.
And to be honest, we’ll probably want the pick 10, so unlikely we bid early on read
If Dees and Adelaide team up for pick 4 to trump dogs what would it take from
9,13,20,23,24,33, Grundy combo, Doedee Compo, Harmes compo, Jordan Compo and 2x F1s available.
What’s realistic is most doing to help GC from that haul? (And is reasonable).
Just thinking 3way trade if Oliver happens.
9,13,20,23,24,33, Grundy combo, Doedee Compo, Harmes compo, Jordan Compo and 2x F1s available.
What’s realistic is most doing to help GC from that haul? (And is reasonable).
Just thinking 3way trade if Oliver happens.
- Feb 12, 2008
- 10,448
- 20,175
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I bet you would. That's almost Harley Reid territory
So 3 way
Adelaide in: Oliver
Adelaide out: 9,20, 23 F1, Doedee Compo
Dees in: 4,9, Doedee compo
Dees out: Oliver, 24
GC in: 20,23,24 and Crows F1
GC out: 4
- Oct 2, 2022
- 4,372
- 5,739
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Adelaide in: Oliver
Adelaide out: 9, F1, 20, 23, McAdam
Dees in: 1, McAdam
Dees out: Oliver, 5
GC in: 9, 20, 23
GC out: 4
WCE in: 4, 5, F1
WCE out: 1
It's a lot for Reid but an option ...
Adelaide out: 9, F1, 20, 23, McAdam
Dees in: 1, McAdam
Dees out: Oliver, 5
GC in: 9, 20, 23
GC out: 4
WCE in: 4, 5, F1
WCE out: 1
It's a lot for Reid but an option ...
Gold Coast already have a better offer than that why would they accept that?
- Oct 2, 2022
- 4,372
- 5,739
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Yeah, true.
If they actually get the three firsts offered, they'll take it.
I'm assuming the WB deal needs them to trade picks back, and this may be as attractive to them.
- Feb 14, 2023
- 1,283
- 1,124
- AFL Club
- Essendon
You have a father son at around Pick 10 so really it’s just about trading up so you don’t lose your picks to bids.
The Suns pick just happens to be the most available and in a range where your guaranteed one of the top 8 players
10/17/F1 for 4 and a pick 10 FS is good value for you
they will also throw in some mid rounders back to give us the points for Croft so yes the value is fine
- Feb 14, 2023
- 1,283
- 1,124
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I suppose it becomes about which F1s you think have more value aka who will finish worse out of Dees, Crows and Dogs.
Dees we’re good without Oliver and Crows will only be better with him.
Dogs are a bit of a mess under Bevo. So is their F1 still the most desirable?
I’d guess suns would want both F1s + enough points to go close to matching bids
- Jun 14, 2017
- 3,519
- 5,610
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, AC Milan, North Adelaide
Reid is not worth more than Oliver
- Aug 15, 2014
- 10,398
- 21,449
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
I think Reid is clearly worth more than Oliver. Oliver is a superstar but is clearly coming with serious baggage at nearly 27. Would you rather 12-15 years of Reid or 5 years of Oliver?
Blackas87
Brownlow Medallist
Dogs really offering 10, 17 and F1 for 4? That’s such a bad deal for them, 17 and F1 to move 6 spots up.
Pick 4 and Croft.
A better deal for them would be pick 10 and 17 to Geelong (who only have one pick in the top 80) for 7 and F2
Pick 7, Croft, keep F1 and add F2
Pick 4 and Croft.
A better deal for them would be pick 10 and 17 to Geelong (who only have one pick in the top 80) for 7 and F2
Pick 7, Croft, keep F1 and add F2
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
