That's my point Martin...in other circumstances neither melbourne or St.Kilda would do this deal. The fact that you guys look like ending up with Judd changes the playing field. It raises the value of pick 9 significantly and increases what Melbourne would be prepared to give up as well.
That's why I raised the point that Frawley is a good starting point. Adding Sylvia, Bate, etc would get the deal done.
Having said all of that we're just speculating on media speculation.