List Mgmt. Pick 9

[Blue__Balls]

Happy to nab either Flanders or Serong.

If both are gone, wouldn't be against trying to send 9 and 43 to Brisbane for 16 and 21. Or to Geelong for 14 and 24.

Then grab Robertson and either Weightman or Taylor.

 

[Bringbackeddie]

Weightman, but not at 9 @14-19 after switching out 9 for 2 picks.

Small forwards tend to go lower in the draft than mids and kpp.

 

[reubsblues]

Always best available but my order of preference would be
Sam Flanders
Dylan Stephens
Deven Robertson
Cody Weightmen

 

[slowhand clape]

Spoke to someone who follows the u18s and he says split for a 1st and 2nd and go Robertson and Bergman/Williams. Solid mid and x-factor mid/hf

 

[FRUMPY]

Anybody but a small fwd - just for the melts

 

[jd2010]

1. Serong
2. Flanders
3. Ash

If those 3 are available we will be saying Tom who.

 

[james Dean]

Any chance we trade this pick for say 15 and 20 (along with our future 3rd) to Gold Coast, so we can pick up Jack Martin in the ND? Possibly 17 and 24 from Geelong?

 

[Blue__Balls]

Any chance we trade this pick for say 15 and 20 (along with our future 3rd) to Gold Coast, so we can pick up Jack Martin in the ND? Possibly 17 and 24 from Geelong?

Doubt we'll be dealing with GC for a few years.

Geelong and Brisbane have suitable picks.

 

[gbatman]

Flanders, Henry, Weightman. I'm guessing we will end up with one of them?

Think we will end up with a good one all the same and potentially with some more project types.

Hopefully target speed and ability to kick goals and apply pressure.

A midfielder in the draft is probably not necessary unless our recruiting has failed.

 

[PostPaolo]

Flanders, Henry, Weightman. I'm guessing we will end up with one of them?

Think we will end up with a good one all the same and potentially with some more project types.

Hopefully target speed and ability to kick goals and apply pressure.

A midfielder in the draft is probably not necessary unless our recruiting has failed.

Henry will go to Fremantle, they'll match any offers.

 

[1981]

Trading it for a future first has merit, gives us a good hand to hopefully actually seal some big trade/s next year.

 

[Trent McNeely]

Splitting pick 9 for two future 1st would help getting trades through next trade period. Try for Tom take 2, if still keen.

You hope relationship hasn't become strained because of this experience for Papley.

On HTC 2PZF1 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[La Dispute]

Trading it for a future first has merit, gives us a good hand to hopefully actually seal some big trade/s next year.

Don’t mind this idea.

Flick it across to a club that doesn’t need an early pick next year and obtain a second or third back too.

Splitting the pick also makes sense, but do does cherry picking a player of need at Pick 9, like Flanders.

 

[Zlatan]

Not opposed to idea....

But, split to which picks and then which draftees do we select?

If Geelong still want to get into the top 10, I’d offer 9 + 43 for 14 and 24. That looks reasonably fair.

 

[Arr0w]

If Geelong still want to get into the top 10, I’d offer 9 + 43 for 14 and 24. That looks reasonably fair.

Slight unders for us, normally clubs pay slight overs, but certainly an option

If I was doing the deal

Pick 9 + future 1st for 14 + 17 + future 1st. About 300 - 400 points in our favour. Cats get 2 mid round 1sts, we have picks this year in better/less compromised draft, while still holding a position in the 1st round next year

 

[LemmingMaster]

Trading it for a future first has merit, gives us a good hand to hopefully actually seal some big trade/s next year.

Only problem with next years picks is the high amount of top end talent being linked to FS, Academy, NGA players. If your pick is in the late first round it could drift out.

 

[Zlatan]

Slight unders for us, normally clubs pay slight overs, but certainly an option

If I was doing the deal

Pick 9 + future 1st for 14 + 17 + future 1st. About 300 - 400 points in our favour. Cats get 2 mid round 1sts, we have picks this year in better/less compromised draft, while still holding a position in the 1st round next year

Only risk being that our 2020 1st may not be mid round and closer to the bottom. We’d have to be confident in our ability to achieve a 10 win season

But with the compromised draft etc, it’s definitely viable.

And if we can get a ready made small forward and possibly a winger with 14 and 17, I’d be wrapped.

 

[slashin_velvet]

Not opposed to idea....

But, split to which picks and then which draftees do we select?

Port probably a possibility if they want to move up, and get back points for Mead (and we had them on the phone for a live swap last year, so theres a clear relationship there....and theyre probably thrilled we didnt go hard after Ollie Wines)
9 + 57 for 18 + 29
9 + 43 + 57 for 12 + 29 + 68 (that late pick will slide in after the academy bids)

 

[bmaurizio]

Should we retain pick 9.


Tehany My preference, most gifted talent in this draft pool.
Serong X factor, address an urgent need
Flanders Hard nut midfielder, safe pick to add to Stocker and develop.

 

[mochacinolatte]

Some fun, the Pick 9 history. Some decent operators in the previous years.

9	Mitch Clark	Brisbane Lions	East Fremantle	2005
9	David Armitage	St Kilda	Morningside	2006
9	Ben McEvoy	St Kilda	Murray U18	2007
9	Jack Ziebell	North Melbourne	Murray U18	2008
9	Andrew Moore	Port Adelaide	Eastern U18	2009
9	Dion Prestia	Gold Coast	Calder U18	2010
9	Adam Tomlinson	Greater Western Sydney	Oakleigh U18	2011
9	Nick Vlastuin	Richmond	Northern U18	2012
9	Christian Salem	Melbourne	Sandringham U18	2013
9	Darcy Moore	Collingwood	Oakleigh U18	2014
9	Sam Weideman	Melbourne	Eastern U18	2015
9	Will Brodie	Gold Coast	Murray U18	2016
9	Aaron Naughton	Western Bulldogs	Peel Thunder	2017
9	Chayce Jones	Adelaide Crows	Launceston	2018

 

[FRUMPY]

Some fun, the Pick 9 history. Some decent operators in the previous years.

9	Mitch Clark	Brisbane Lions	East Fremantle	2005
9	David Armitage	St Kilda	Morningside	2006
9	Ben McEvoy	St Kilda	Murray U18	2007
9	Jack Ziebell	North Melbourne	Murray U18	2008
9	Andrew Moore	Port Adelaide	Eastern U18	2009
9	Dion Prestia	Gold Coast	Calder U18	2010
9	Adam Tomlinson	Greater Western Sydney	Oakleigh U18	2011
9	Nick Vlastuin	Richmond	Northern U18	2012
9	Christian Salem	Melbourne	Sandringham U18	2013
9	Darcy Moore	Collingwood	Oakleigh U18	2014
9	Sam Weideman	Melbourne	Eastern U18	2015
9	Will Brodie	Gold Coast	Murray U18	2016
9	Aaron Naughton	Western Bulldogs	Peel Thunder	2017
9	Chayce Jones	Adelaide Crows	Launceston	2018

Not a small forward amongst them

 

[Aphrodite]

We already have a draft thread. I suggest you post there.

Thread is fine & different to the draft thread Robbo.

 

[Bluebag13]

Anybody but a small fwd - just for the melts

Give me a KPD

 

[LFTWNG11]

Anybody but a small fwd - just for the melts

I am secretly hoping for another KPP, simply for the melts.

 

[Robertio]

Not opposed to idea....

But, split to which picks and then which draftees do we select?

Sokol from WA, he any good?