Pick your 4 to build a team around

[donkeypunchd]

Building for the long term and using the OP's positional template

Ruckman: Grundy
Midfielder: Cripps
Defender: Andrews
Forward: Daniher

Daniher ?

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Daniher ?

Reasonable on potential I think. Young key forwards you'd expect to be a bit inconsistent. To nlme the best they've shown is the level they can get to in their prime years, character and body permitting

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Lot of people over rating Jamie Cripps in this thread...

 

[branedotorg]

Dusty
Dylan Shiel
Paddy Cripps
Jesse Hogan

why even have a defence

 

[eth-dog]

McGovern
Grundy
Oliver
Hogan

 

[Ricky Vaughn]

I'll just need 2.

Alistair Clarkson
Stephen Wells

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Brendan Bolton
Stephen Silvagni
Patrick Cripps
Charlie Curnow

 

[Masqualero]

Grundy
Hogan
McGovern
Cripps

 

[coryne]

If we are going by the OP format and long-term success

Ruckman: Grundy
Midfield: Cripps
Defender: Andrews
Forward: Hogan

OP format and win the flag this year

Ruckman: Gawn
Midfield: Cripps
Defender: Rance
Forward: Flanklin

Long-term success and ANY players
Cripps
Kelly
Oliver
Hogan

Win the flag, this year
Dangerfield
Cripps
Fyfe
Martin


(Yes I am probably showing my bias with Cripps but he is the #1 inside mid IMO and will only be getting better. Controlling the clearances is vital these days thus why he is #2 in the AFLCA award playing in a team which has won 1 game ...........)

 

[Jonts]

Brown
Martin
Fyfe
J Mcgovern

 

[Scotland]

Richmond won the 2017 flag so applying Richmond fan logic:

Ruckman: Toby Nankervis
Midfield: Dustin Martin
Defender: Alex Rance
Forward: Jack Riewoldt

 

[Cold Sober]

Kruzer
Cripps
Hogan
Yeo

 

[Archiemcd19]

Nic Nat, Dusty, Rance, Ben Brown

 

[jacksgh]

Dawson Simpson
Hugh Goddard
Jimmy Toumpas
Mason Cox

 

[BG__]

Building for instant success...
DEF: McGovern
MID: Fyfe
RUC: Naitanui
FWD: Buddy

Building for future sucess...
DEF: Barass
MID: Kelly
RUC: Grundy
FWD: Hogan

 

[DapperDon]

Daniher ?

Yeah man, can't believe it hey!

It's like he chose on potential rather than a 6 week injury fuelled run of matches.

whatachump!!!

 

[tugga]

To build a team around?

Ben Brown
Brodie Grundy
Patrick Cripps
Harris Andrews

 

[RedVest4]

And...

 

[captain cotch 9]

Lynch - best fwd
Martin - best midfielder
Rance - best defender
Cotchin - best captain

2019 Tigers

 

[Plat]

Hogan
Oliver
Cripps
Embiid

 

[jacksgh]

Richmond won the 2017 flag so applying Richmond fan logic:

Ruckman: Toby Nankervis
Midfield: Dustin Martin
Defender: Alex Rance
Forward: Jack Riewoldt

I think you mean
Ruckman: Ivan Soldo
Midfield: Jack Graham
Defender: Ryan Garthwaite
Forward: Noah Balta

 

[juss]

Build my side, I'm looking long term, so there is bias toward younger players who have more years left, but balanced with proven performance.

Ruck: Brodie Grundy
Midfielder: Patrick Cripps
Defender: Harris Andrews
Forward: Ben Brown

 

[juss]

To build a team around?

Ben Brown
Brodie Grundy
Patrick Cripps
Harris Andrews

Oh wow, good minds think alike.

 

[dean33]

Cotchin would make a terrible ruckmen.

Wouldn’t be so sure, the man can do most things he tries.

 

[Checkered]

Ruck: Billy Longer
Back: Sam Docherty
Mid: James Aish
Forward: Elliott Yeo