Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[$tylez]

mundy and hasleby

or

birchall and butler

???

 

[swans4eva]

mundy and hasleby

or

birchall and butler

???

Birchall is injured therefore mundy and haselby but i dont think that that would be the best option to take anyway. Haselby could turn out to be a gun this year or he could dislocate his knee in the first 5 mins of round one! no one knows! If you dont have many risky players in your team at the moment then maybe haselby would be a very good option. In my opinion jed adcock or drummond would be abetter option then mundy but it is up to u.

 

[Jars458]

Gibbs or Judd. Just can't decide.

 

[pieman123]

q.lynch, leon davis or sylvia?

 

[JimmyRecard]

johnson vs brown vs goodwin

 

[Juddbemetron]

Gibbs or Judd. Just can't decide.

gibbs
will only get better
gets some amrks and a lot of tackles

 

[scotty4]

goodwin, more consistent, do you mean jon brown or nate?
enright or mackie or burgoyne?

 

[sossy19]

id go enright coz not sold on purgs and macks may have to play a more involved role in the defence

Cooney vs Boyd vs Selwood vs STuck

note if i get cooney ill have exactly $0 dollar in the bank

 

[catsdynasty]

I have Dalziell and Selwood as well as GAblett and Bartel. I also have Rich and Anthony on the field but will maybe upgrade Mitch Robinson who’s on my bench to maybe Sidebottom or Dangerfield and bring either of them on the field for Anthony

What do you think I should do with my team upgrade Dalziell, to Thompson, Swan or Kornes
Or
Upgrade Selwood to Thompson, Swan or Kornes.
Or Should I keep my team as it is.
I have 105 k in the bank? Would really appreciate some feedback.

 

[Souup]

I have Dalziell and Selwood as well as GAblett and Bartel. I also have Rich and Anthony on the field but will maybe upgrade Mitch Robinson who’s on my bench to maybe Sidebottom or Dangerfield and bring either of them on the field for Anthony

What do you think I should do with my team upgrade Dalziell, to Thompson, Swan or Kornes
Or
Upgrade Selwood to Thompson, Swan or Kornes.
Or Should I keep my team as it is.
I have 105 k in the bank? Would really appreciate some feedback.

Starting Anthony is a tad too risky imo.

 

[timmeh]

Okay. Who cares about price, position and etc. Just scoring potential and number of games.

Tredrea or Hadley?

 

[timmeh]

Okay. Who cares about price, position and etc. Just scoring potential and number of games.

Tredrea or Hadley?

anyone?

 

[catsdynasty]

anyone?

Probs Treadrea I reckon m8 seems to be alright...so far, this year and will get constant games for port.

Can anyone help me on mine?

 

[DLab]

Coming close to a final copy now. My quandry is a 2nd ruck, 4th defender combo. Here are the options i'm considering:

211 (Sandilands) and Mundy
- Durable combo. Taking one or two risks in the back (like most) and like the idea of a durable member who is looking at a change of role into the midfield.

Ottens and Defender >354,100
- Liked the look of Ottens as a leading forward and tap ruckman on Friday night. Showed good speed and presence. Issue with the defender here is that the best options (Birchall, Gram are injured). McPhee has been bandied around but was generally rubbish last year and burnt me considerably. Perhaps Scott Stevens??

Thoughts?

 

[favourites]

Scott Stevens will be playing full back while rutten is out, i would go option 1.

 

[timmeh]

I have Dalziell and Selwood as well as GAblett and Bartel. I also have Rich and Anthony on the field but will maybe upgrade Mitch Robinson who’s on my bench to maybe Sidebottom or Dangerfield and bring either of them on the field for Anthony

What do you think I should do with my team upgrade Dalziell, to Thompson, Swan or Kornes
Or
Upgrade Selwood to Thompson, Swan or Kornes.
Or Should I keep my team as it is.
I have 105 k in the bank? Would really appreciate some feedback.

Selwood looks to have a great year this year.

Dalziell is slightly risky as we don't know if he can reproduce the same numbers as last year, also not sure if he's coped with a tag. Scott Thompson on the other hand will likely be consistent as he has been around that mark the past few years.

 

[Juddbemetron]

franklin+roughead vs Franklin + Porplyzia vs Deledio/richo + Porplyzia vs Deledio+roughead

 

[kangaroos3]

Coming close to a final copy now. My quandry is a 2nd ruck, 4th defender combo. Here are the options i'm considering:

211 (Sandilands) and Mundy
- Durable combo. Taking one or two risks in the back (like most) and like the idea of a durable member who is looking at a change of role into the midfield.

Ottens and Defender >354,100
- Liked the look of Ottens as a leading forward and tap ruckman on Friday night. Showed good speed and presence. Issue with the defender here is that the best options (Birchall, Gram are injured). McPhee has been bandied around but was generally rubbish last year and burnt me considerably. Perhaps Scott Stevens??

Thoughts?

What about Gilbee?

 

[ohhhBigMalcho]

nathan krakour and chad cornes

or

jack grimes and leon davis> or someone else below him

 

[Crimson King]

Rich or Beams or Sidebottom for the midfield bench spot.

 

[favourites]

Rich - If you've got the money
Beams - will play round 1
Sidebottom - downgrade target, cant see him playing 3 of the first 10.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Krakouer and Chad, but I'd try to find a spot for Grimes too.

DLab, I like Ottens more than Sandi but Mundy (or Adcock, or Drummond if you weren't already taking risks as you said) is just as good as any of the options around 350k. Personally I'd go Ottens ahead of Sandi for the extra value you get (IMO they'll both score about 80 but Ottens is a lot cheaper) but also pick Mundy and use that money somewhere else.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

SJohnson vs Chapman vs NBrown rate 1,2,3 plz 1 being best

 

[Hodges]

SJ, Brown then Chappers. I dont trust Chappies hammies.

Corey + Waite + Bruce vs Ablett + Mundy + Swan

Im looking to get Ablett in the team, and Waite is on the block. I think he will average 85 this year, but Mundy should average 75+ and is more durable. Swan also holds the edge over Bruce on durability.

Thoughts?

 

[joelselwood#14]

whats with the big raps on L.Anthony

i have heard nothing about him but alot of people have him on the bench..

is it just people copying players on team or is he going to be a good dreamteamer