Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[Rod Stroker]

Malceski or McLeod?
These 2 look like great value to me. One has a sus knee but has the potential for a good year if his knee holds up, the other perhaps getting past his best but still fairly solid and dependable with the numbers and getting the job done.

Goodes or James McDonald?

Brad Johnson or Ryan O'Keefe?

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Who are the best defenders under 400K? I am also including Mackie.

All of them have question marks so it is extremely hard atm.

 

[timmeh]

Lol you'd be lucky to get a defender's leg for less than 4k


Oh who would people pick out of Danny Stanley and Ed Lower? In terms of scoring and games, with price and position put aside.

 

[bulldogsman]

Who are the best defenders under 4K? I am also including Mackie.

All of them have question marks so it is extremely hard atm.

Fisher and Goddard. Goddard will probably be the better scorer

 

[bulldogsman]

Lol you'd be lucky to get a defender's leg for less than 4k


Oh who would people pick out of Danny Stanley and Ed Lower? In terms of scoring and games, with price and position put aside.

Stanley i've never heard of so can't see him playing much. Lower might play most games, but i'd choose neither

 

[wookie_goldberg]

sylvia v hall?

saw barry play the other night and he looked good, both are risks though. sylvia being suspended does not bode well but i'm probably leaning towards him at the moment.

 

[Coach Bombay]

sylvia v hall?

saw barry play the other night and he looked good, both are risks though. sylvia being suspended does not bode well but i'm probably leaning towards him at the moment.

Both are risks but only a few players aren't these days. I would choose Hall. He is still a very good footballer and can see him being a bit more consistent than Sylvia.

S.Johnson Vs M.Stokes? Can't decide between the two Geelong forwards.

 

[Captain23]

Both are risks but only a few players aren't these days. I would choose Hall. He is still a very good footballer and can see him being a bit more consistent than Sylvia.

S.Johnson Vs M.Stokes? Can't decide between the two Geelong forwards.

Although I think they will end up with similar averages at the end of the season I would go with Johnson as i think he is capable of some really big scires.

Guys i need a little help deciding between Keeping Riewoldt of Franklin.
I think I want to swap one of them for Chapman but cant make up my mind.

I know they are both coming back from injuries but not sure where they are currently at??
Can anyone shed some light please?

 

[buddymania]

Buddy... dominated first game back with no signs of injury. Reiwoldt always starts slowly as well if i remember correctly, as i picked him up on the cheap last year

 

[mightymagpie1999]

thoughts on the following

Sam Gilbert or Ryan Houlihan

Sam Gilbert is in his 3rd or 4th year with the Saints and should play more of a forward role this year. has had some positive scores in the pre-season.

Ryan Houlhian should be a regular in the Carlton lineup but im not to sure how big he will score.

Whats everyones thoughts? who would you have?

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Skipworth or Nath Krakour

 

[dicleo]

Guys im tossing up between Drummond or Adcock, opinions please. Hoping Adcock can bounce back from last year but drummond has potential to score massive. What yous think?

 

[Dynamite_DJ]

My team is pretty much settled now about from finalising my emergencies once I get a better picture of whos in and out for round 1.
The final decision I have to make is in the mids:

Knights, Cousins, & Winderlich vs Gibbs, Foley and T Tuck

Any thoughts would be appreciated guys

 

[bulldogsman]

Guys im tossing up between Drummond or Adcock, opinions please. Hoping Adcock can bounce back from last year but drummond has potential to score massive. What yous think?

Adcock. To me Drummond has a big score then is hyped up (in all the games i've seen anyway). Adcock looks to be getting better every game and i think he can score just as much as Drummond.

 

[srekcarc]

My team is pretty much settled now about from finalising my emergencies once I get a better picture of whos in and out for round 1.
The final decision I have to make is in the mids:

Knights, Cousins, & Winderlich vs Gibbs, Foley and T Tuck

Any thoughts would be appreciated guys

I would recommend gibbs, foley, tuck out of the 2 options.

 

[sossy19]

mcmahon vs newman

not much diff, can anyone see the gap growing this year and why??

also DDDDaliziell vs Boyd

"***** only played 7 games" will opponents figure him out, or do they need to?
Boyd- will he be given tighter run with roles with higgins and grif popping up in the engine room??

help appreciated

 

[the egg]

Skipworth or Nath Krakour

Skipworth. Krakour has only played one good pre-season game and will be fighting for his spot all year down there.

Guys im tossing up between Drummond or Adcock, opinions please. Hoping Adcock can bounce back from last year but drummond has potential to score massive. What yous think?

Our guess is as good as yours mate. Adcock can get 120's aswell, just look at his breakout year.

My team is pretty much settled now about from finalising my emergencies once I get a better picture of whos in and out for round 1.
The final decision I have to make is in the mids:

Knights, Cousins, & Winderlich vs Gibbs, Foley and T Tuck

Any thoughts would be appreciated guys

Gibbs, Foley and T Tuck easily.

 

[Artie Bucco]

Peter Burgoyne or David Mundy?

 

[Richo63]

Bryce Gibbs and Matthew Kruezer vs Trent Cotchin and Brad Ottens??

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

I reakon Burgoyne will have a good year, but he is risky considering how he struggled last year. Mundy looks good atm and is around 60K cheaper.


My two questions:

Drummond vs Adcock vs Mundy

Also who is the best defender under $400,000 including Mackie? Not including Cornes and Goddard who I already have.

 

[Cale for Captain]

Richo63, i'd go cotchin and ottens as a long-term prospect, just because kreuzer as a second ruck isn't strong enough. however cotchin is injured atm...


just wondering who you guys think is the best mid under the 380k mark, so pretty much comparing:

judd vs boak vs knights vs cousins vs foley vs any others...


the other comparison is:

geary (bac) vs zieball (fwd) (because houlihan can move)

thanks

 

[dicleo]

yeah when adcock was like 85 k and had a brilliant season, best value pick at the time. Who do u think will get a game 1st round out of Beams, Robinson and Swift. Havnt heard much about Swift who should i swap him for?

 

[catsdynasty]

Greg Broughton or Nick Suban?? Thoughts? My other bench is Petrenko?

 

[Crimson King]

I would go for Suban. They need someone to replace Black.

 

[kangaroos3]

Hey guys who would you rate 1-4 of the following players,

H. Ballantyne vs M. Brown vs T. Walker vs J Grant?