Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[kangaroos3]

2 easily.

Daniel Cross vs Bradd Dalziell

Im really leaning to Dalziell because he's unique but he's still young and I dont know if I can trust him..

Thanks porps.

IMO i would go for Cross. Simply because he will be able to maintain that average and even go better. Were as Dalziell will be a little risky.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Thanks porps.

IMO i would go for Cross. Simply because he will be able to maintain that average and even go better. Were as Dalziell will be a little risky.

Thanks Kangaz

Since you explained mine, i'll explain yours.

Hille IMO will be the second highest scoring ruckmen, and I will defiently be getting him in my team is Cox is out for round 1. Also Selwood looks ready to take the next step, and as many people have noticed he already looks like he is part of the ABC's.

 

[kangaroos3]

Thanks Kangaz

Since you explained mine, i'll explain yours.

Hille IMO will be the second highest scoring ruckmen, and I will defiently be getting him in my team is Cox is out for round 1. Also Selwood looks ready to take the next step, and as many people have noticed he already looks like he is part of the ABC's.

Agreed.

Also i'm stuck on whether to take Buddy or Pav.

Buddy has a lot of potential but sometimes hurt me last year with the occasional low score. Plus Pav will be more consistent but I cant see him improving his average by more then 5-10ppg.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

CHAPMAN vs STEVIE J

This has been fustrating me sooo much

 

[geelong16]

Agreed.

Also i'm stuck on whether to take Buddy or Pav.

Buddy has a lot of potential but sometimes hurt me last year with the occasional low score. Plus Pav will be more consistent but I cant see him improving his average by more then 5-10ppg.

Go buddy, he is only getting better, Pav has reached his prime (but still a bloody good footy player).

If the Nab challenge match on the weekend is anything to go by for the year, it could be scary how much he dominates.

Also I dont know which two out of these three i should choose?

Gibbs, Judd, Pendlebury

Any thoughts?

 

[kenny712]

CHAPMAN vs STEVIE J

This has been fustrating me sooo much

Got the same dilemma. If your willing to take a risk for more points, then Chapman. If not, SJ.

 

[kangaroos3]

Go buddy, he is only getting better, Pav has reached his prime (but still a bloody good footy player).

If the Nab challenge match on the weekend is anything to go by for the year, it could be scary how much he dominates.

Also I dont know which two out of these three i should choose?

Gibbs, Judd, Pendlebury

Any thoughts?

I would go Gibbs and Pendelbury because they most likely will improve a bit.
Judd is more of a SC player.

CHAPMAN vs STEVIE J

This has been fustrating me sooo much

Porps I would go Stevie J.
Chappys hammys are a little too risky IMO.

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Andrew Lovett Or Dale Thomas

Scott Thompson or Daniel Cross

Jared Petrenko or Nick Suban

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Got the same dilemma. If your willing to take a risk for more points, then Chapman. If not, SJ.

Yeah I know, and I dont usually take risks but I always have been a fan of Chappy since he can score 100 regulary (and plays midfield), as Stevie J can be unconsistant...

 

[kangaroos3]

Andrew Lovett Or Dale Thomas

Scott Thompson or Daniel Cross

Jared Petrenko or Nick Suban

Id go;

Thomas

Thompson

Suban

 

[kenny712]

Yeah I know, and I dont usually take risks but I always have been a fan of Chappy since he can score 100 regulary (and plays midfield), as Stevie J can be unconsistant...

I wouldn't really call SJ inconsistant. He consistently puts up 80-90 ppg and can score 100's here and there. Chappy I reckon can average 105 but not sure if he'll play all 22. He has before but those hammies of his...

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Lindsay Gilbee or Jed Adcock

 

[jezza you beauty]

Yeah I know, and I dont usually take risks but I always have been a fan of Chappy since he can score 100 regulary (and plays midfield), as Stevie J can be unconsistant...

Chappy is looking very good at the moment, but can those hammy's hold out for a whole season. Im looking to pick him up later in the season

Im looking to pick 3 premuim forwards and at the moment im looking for 3 small forward/mid style players,

Currently Deledio, harvey, Didak.

My thoughts are that they can move into the midfield, and aren't as reliant on delivery like a bigger forward might be. Anyone else picking on this basis?

Seeing Buddy last weekend has got me interested, but think theres a better chance of him having an off week (especially early on with the hawks draw) and his price dropping.

my question: which 3 out of deledio, N Brown, harvey, Goodwin, Didak, S Johnston, giansira

 

[I luv Schofield]

What are peoples thoughts? Looking at filling my final midfield spot?

Brent Reilly (Adel) $284,000 OR Travis Tuck (Haw) $276,200

 

[lfctorres9]

Tossing up between mundy and adcock got no idea who to pick out of the two? suggestions??

 

[RU486]

Tossing up between mundy and adcock got no idea who to pick out of the two? suggestions??

Adcock, all the way. Much more consistent and his role is more established.

Sandilands vs Simmonds vs Other (Under 370k)

 

[geelong16]

Adcock, all the way. Much more consistent and his role is more established.

Sandilands vs Simmonds vs Other (Under 370k)

Ottens, will be a very solid scorer if he can hold fitness.

If not, sandilands over simmonds.

 

[ziggys_band]

Steele Sidebottom or Wade Thompson?

Thompson would free up cash for my weak mids but then Sidebottom probably looks the better player, more likely to string games together (or am i wrong?). If i went Thompson would mean i could swap Kornes to Swan...

Any thoughts appreciated

 

[Richo63]

In terms of the forward line I need some opinions on the following...

Koschitzke + $35k or Roughead??

 

[favourites]

Steele Sidebottom or Wade Thompson?

Thompson would free up cash for my weak mids but then Sidebottom probably looks the better player, more likely to string games together (or am i wrong?). If i went Thompson would mean i could swap Kornes to Swan...

Any thoughts appreciated

K Cornes is fine.... what about Mitch Brown, Taylor Walker... imo they are definate starting 18 players for their sides.

 

[Rod Stroker]

Im looking to pick 3 premuim forwards and at the moment im looking for 3 small forward/mid style players,

Currently Deledio, harvey, Didak.

My thoughts are that they can move into the midfield, and aren't as reliant on delivery like a bigger forward might be. Anyone else picking on this basis?

Of course, although none of my forwards any of those 3 above

 

[ziggys_band]

K Cornes is fine.... what about Mitch Brown, Taylor Walker... imo they are definate starting 18 players for their sides.

Great advice. So much so that I already have both

Just feel as though Swan may have a better year than Kornes. Would keep either for the whole year so want to choose wisely. The problem remains i guess, Thompson and Swan or Sidebottom and Kornes, haha

 

[Eagle_Rock]

Im looking at Gilbert and Geary, who should i pick??? Opinions would be helpful, thanx

 

[Richo63]

K Cornes is fine.... what about Mitch Brown, Taylor Walker... imo they are definate starting 18 players for their sides.

Mitch Brown should just about be a definite in most peoples teams. Spent all of last yr bulking up while recovering from his knee reco and will be massive for the Eagles. Is ready to roll this yr and will be a definite in the side unless injury hits. Question is will he play forward or back...your guess is as good as mine

 

[Daysy_12]

Swan and Stokes V Cross and Harvey