Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[Kenzie101]

Ive got Krak as my sixth forward. I think he will score pretty well, its just a matter of him staying on the park.

Swan + Gibbs + Mackay vs Corey + Gibbs + Skipworth vs Swan + Kornes + Skipworth

Currently have Mackay in the team, but looking at getting Skippy in. Looks like scoring better, just a question on whether he is best 18/22 or not. Im not sold on Kornes this year, so Corey + Gibbs looks a good option. Would complement Ablett nicely.

Corey + Gibbs + Skipworth i think this is the best option of the three, it has a Premium(Corey), some1 pushing for a premium status at a good price (Gibbs),and a good cash cow in skipworth.

Swan + Kornes + Skipworth is tempting aswell with the 2 premiums and the cash cow, but i see more value in option 2.

Ive got a few (sorry if they've been done i dont know how to use the search thing)

S Fisher VS C Enright
Suban VS Broughton
Mundy VS Drummond VS Adcock
Ziebell VS Yarran VS Hentschel VS Sidebottom
Brown VS Walker VS Grant VS Gumbleton VS Ballantyne (Pick 2)
Thanks

 

[kangaroo19]

Corey + Gibbs + Skipworth i think this is the best option of the three, it has a Premium(Corey), some1 pushing for a premium status at a good price (Gibbs),and a good cash cow in skipworth.

Swan + Kornes + Skipworth is tempting aswell with the 2 premiums and the cash cow, but i see more value in option 2.

Ive got a few (sorry if they've been done i dont know how to use the search thing)

S Fisher VS C Enright
Suban VS Broughton
Mundy VS Drummond VS Adcock
Ziebell VS Yarran VS Hentschel VS Sidebottom
Brown VS Walker VS Grant VS Gumbleton VS Ballantyne (Pick 2)
Thanks

I've bolded my picks...

Fisher was a lock in my team as he is very consistent and drives the saints backline.

Broughton, simply due to the fact he got elevated and is 22yo so should get games...

Adcock - as long as he can regain some form he should be a good pick, with less injury concerns than Drummo. Also, Brisbane appear to be playing possession style footy, and you can never trust a docker unless it's pav or a rookie!

Hentschell - Just because he's a bit more experienced and is assured of games.

Brown & Walker - both have shown a lot in the PS, so should be definitely in the 22 for their teams.

 

[kangaroo19]

Selwood & Krakouer (as 6th fwd)
or
Swan & Hill (as 7th back)
or
Swan & Yarran (as 6th fwd)

???

 

[iluvparis]

Need to replace Veszpremi in my forwards so was thinking

Lucas or R.Houlihan

Thoughts on the better of those two?

 

[Grover]

Douglas & Mcintosh or O'Keefe & Leuenberger

 

[dewey13]

Two tough ones:

mid:

Dane Swan & mitch Robinson OR

Scott Thomson and Daniel Rich

Fwd: Reiwold and Chapman OR

Gia & Franklin

 

[bulldogsman]

Two tough ones:

mid:

Dane Swan & mitch Robinson OR

Scott Thomson and Daniel Rich

Fwd: Reiwold and Chapman OR

Gia & Franklin

Thomson & Rich

Gia & Franklin


Andy Otten vs Daniel Rich

 

[Stormer]

Swan and Robbo
Riewoldt and Chapman
Otten

 

[dewey13]

Of the kids - GIBBS v SALOPEK v DALZEIL v SELWOOD?

You can only pick one, who do you stake your reputation on?

Our office is torn right down the middle (or quarter)

 

[kangaroo19]

A couple of scenarios here for thought...

Scenario 1:

Defence: Raines & Houlihan as 6th/7th defenders, with Suban and Broughton on the bench.
Mids: Rich, Otten, Hill, Anthony as 5th-8th mids
Fwds: Hentschell, Ziebell, Walker, Brown as 6th-9th forwards

+ $32k

Scenario 2:

Defence: Raines & Hill as 6th/7th defenders, with Suban and Broughton on the bench.
Mids: Rich, Otten, Robinson, Anthony as 5th-8th mids
Fwds: Hentschell, Houlihan, Walker, Brown as 6th-9th forwards

 

[Grover]

Douglas & Mcintosh or O'Keefe/Walker & Leuenberger

 

[iluvparis]

One MF spot left and I honestly have NFI who to pick between these guys:

Van Berlo v Boak v Lewis v Cousins v Judd

My heart says Juddy but who should my head say?

 

[Juddtastic]

One MF spot left and I honestly have NFI who to pick between these guys:

Van Berlo v Boak v Lewis v Cousins v Judd

My heart says Juddy but who should my head say?

Juddy out of those 5 as he is the most likely too play all 22 games this year, Van Berlo will miss first few games, Lewis in doubt for the opening round and cousins & Boak come with injury risks...

On pure game average though I'd rank them:

VB
Lewis
Juddy
Cus
Boak

 

[quirky]

HOULI V ADCOCK

Is Bachar Houli fit? i've had adcock this whole time but i think i would quite like to get a unique player and i think houli will smash it.

i know adcock could too but something tells me whichever way i go i'll regret it

 

[Maestro15]

I only have room for one injury prone player in my side:

Drummond Vs Malceski Vs Houlihan

Which player is better value?

 

[dylan123]

HOULI V ADCOCK

Is Bachar Houli fit? i've had adcock this whole time but i think i would quite like to get a unique player and i think houli will smash it.

i know adcock could too but something tells me whichever way i go i'll regret it

well i dont think houli has had a very good preseason/did not score too well in the nab cup games while adcocks last 2 games were decent scores for his price. i would recommend adcock because his definitely in the team while im not so sure on houli.

should i go cox + white and have 170k to spend on my team
or
downgrade cox to petrie and get hille as well with about 20k left?

im not so big on cox now since he did not play the last 2 nab cup games and none of the ruck have scored high this nab cup with the new rule. with having petrie and hille they can both get goals which might boost up their scores.

 

[kerplunky]

i originally had stevy J and lockyer, but i am thinking is lockyer being hyped up? this leads me to the question:

Stevey J & Lockyer

Franklin & Adcock?

or are any other defenders around that price a better pick?

thanks a lot in advance.

 

[lmaohelp]

id go adcock and franklin

franklin can go nuts and score very high scores and i feel you can rely on adcock to hav a solid season

 

[lmaohelp]

what do u guys think is better

n.brown didak gia - this i hav $0 in the kitty
vs
fev delidio harvey ? - this i hav 21,700

 

[Wilso]

Houli has the potential to become a supercoach star, but he just doesn't get it enough in DT to warrant selection for mine.

 

[kangaroos3]

Hmm whos a better option out of

Kane Cornes and Hamish McIntosh

or

Ryan Griffen and David Hille?

 

[Robbo123]

i think the most dangerous positions this year will be the 7th 8th 9th backline players.
Lots of people seem to be going with
Hill, Suban, Petrenko
Personally i have gone with Collier instead of Petrenko just to be safe
What has everyone else done?

 

[buddymania]

Hmm whos a better option out of

Kane Cornes and Hamish McIntosh

or

Ryan Griffen and David Hille?

Kane Cornes and Hmac out of those maybe even j.selwood and ottens

 

[kangaroos3]

Kane Cornes and Hmac out of those maybe even j.selwood and ottens

Yeah im leaning towards that option. I already have Joel Selwood tho.


And BTW its my 2nd ruck too

 

[buddymania]

Yeh definitely kornes and hmac then if its 2nd ruck. I think port will be in for big scores this year especially with the two cornes waxing off each other