Player Comparison Thread - Part 2

[kangaroo19]

Yeah, that's what I was thinking. I'm not sure if Knights would be a keeper, and at that price it'd be hard to justify upgrading him to someone like Bartel later on.

Re: Grant. I'd need a 3rd 86k player in the forward line to be able to do this combination, so I just put Grant's name out there as an option. I've Got Brown and Walker already, so one of those would go on the field if I didn't have Zball. Hogan, maybe?

Other option would be to get Adcock in the backs, keep Ziebell, and then I'd have $426k to spend on a mid (not touching Dalziell, and already have Gibbs & Selwood).

 

[banana_bus]

Not sure on the first, but probably Suban.

Barring injury, Brown will play most games out of that group.

FWIW the Freo board think Broughton is a lock for the back pocket in rd 1.

 

[Lord_Travis]

S. Fisher and J. Gram VS C. Enright and H. Shaw

Keep in mind I already have Goddard and Cornes, so that would be 3 Saints defenders if I took the first option. This would be for my other higher end defenders spots.

Any thoughts?

 

[buddymania]

Think shaw is out for round 1, so fisher and gram

 

[buddymania]

Lockyer + Kerr

or

Drummond+ Gibbs

Backline has 400k, 400k, 300k, 250k, 200k, Hill
Midfield has one of ABC, 400k, 380k, 250k, Rich

 

[Hodges]

FWIW the Freo board think Broughton is a lock for the back pocket in rd 1.

Will he keep his spot past that though? They have a few players coming back. Im not sold that either of them will keep their spots actually.

 

[favourites]

Think shaw is out for round 1, so fisher and gram

Gram is under a cloud as well... so Fisher lol

 

[Jimmza Oner]

Jed Adcock vs David Mundy
Both are lookin to assert themselves in there respective midfields with both basically the same prices but hoo shuld i pick?
Any response wuld be appreciated greatly

 

[buddymania]

Will he keep his spot past that though? They have a few players coming back. Im not sold that either of them will keep their spots actually.

Like who... they're a shambles. Broughton and Suban will hold there spot in the freo team

 

[Souup]

Gram is under a cloud as well... so Fisher lol

With all the outs in St Kildas backline, i get the feeling Fisher will probably have to play FB. Not sure if this will hurt his score, as he will run off his direct opponent regardless.

 

[Frozenwaste]

Bradshaw+Drummond vs Thomas+Adcock

I currently have Daniel Bradshaw and Josh Drummond, and am not sure whether to change this combination to Dale Thomas and Jed Adcock.
I believe Daniel Bradshaw is more likely on the decline than the rise. And it could be Dale Thomas' break out year.
Jed Adcock and Josh Drummond are likely to average around the same, and are basically the same price.
But choosing Dale Thomas would go against every single moral fiber i have in my body.
Please, help me

 

[S3XDONS]

ok.... so i've had T.Tuck in my team for ages... but reading from threads and looking at his stats last yr... can he sustain a place long enough if injured players return???

so im thinking Tuck vs Grigg

from all i've read Grigg seems as though he will play rnd 1 and he seems more likely of a game and gametime each week than tuck.. and i feel they have similar scoring potential....

thoughts??

 

[Frozenwaste]

ok.... so i've had T.Tuck in my team for ages... but reading from threads and looking at his stats last yr... can he sustain a place long enough if injured players return???

so im thinking Tuck vs Grigg

from all i've read Grigg seems as though he will play rnd 1 and he seems more likely of a game and gametime each week than tuck.. and i feel they have similar scoring potential....

thoughts??

Im not quite sure, but either Tuck or Ben McGlynn will take over Crawfs role, now that hes retired. And i feel it will probably be Tuck.
Just my Opinion

 

[Tigerman_12]

Gibbs K. Cornes
or
Swan C. Cornes
???

 

[gta007]

Bartel + Foley or

Scott Thompson + Gibbs (already have Kornes, 2k short of Swan)

 

[kangaroos3]

Bartel + Foley or

Scott Thompson + Gibbs (already have Kornes, 2k short of Swan)

Option 2 IMO. Its more reliable.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Bradshaw+Drummond vs Thomas+Adcock

I currently have Daniel Bradshaw and Josh Drummond, and am not sure whether to change this combination to Dale Thomas and Jed Adcock.
I believe Daniel Bradshaw is more likely on the decline than the rise. And it could be Dale Thomas' break out year.
Jed Adcock and Josh Drummond are likely to average around the same, and are basically the same price.
But choosing Dale Thomas would go against every single moral fiber i have in my body.
Please, help me

*copies and pastes same answer he gave to same question in DT squads thread*

Ignore your moral fibres when picking your Dream Team. I had Nick Stevens last year and he was one of the pickups of the year, I don't regret it for a second. But I still hate the Judas prick.

And yes, you should definitely make that switch. Or if you're a risk taker keep Drummond and downgrade Bradshaw anyway, because I'd be very surprised if Bradshaw outscores Thomas.

 

[dylan101]

With all the outs in St Kildas backline, i get the feeling Fisher will probably have to play FB. Not sure if this will hurt his score, as he will run off his direct opponent regardless.

Zac Dawson will be full back, at least for round 1. Lyon seems pretty keen to play him and he will be starting on Hall. I'd say Blake would be next in line for Hall and then Fisher so I don't think his scores should be affected too much.

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

s.fisher or enright?

 

[Frozenwaste]

*copies and pastes same answer he gave to same question in DT squads thread*

Ignore your moral fibres when picking your Dream Team. I had Nick Stevens last year and he was one of the pickups of the year, I don't regret it for a second. But I still hate the Judas prick.

And yes, you should definitely make that switch. Or if you're a risk taker keep Drummond and downgrade Bradshaw anyway, because I'd be very surprised if Bradshaw outscores Thomas.

Yeah, thanks. I put it into the other thread first, then i saw this one, and thought it would be better

 

[Schulzenfest]

Will he keep his spot past that though? They have a few players coming back. Im not sold that either of them will keep their spots actually.

If they can't keep their spots over players like Scott Thornton, they won't be good enough for me to care whether they're playing anyway.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

s.fisher or enright?

As pointed out by Lakey in his captain post, Enright normally starts quite slow, so I'd go with Fisher.

 

[Richo63]

corey enright + bryce gibbs + 8k in bank v luke hodge + nathan foley + 20.3k in bank

 

[Hodges]

If they can't keep their spots over players like Scott Thornton, they won't be good enough for me to care whether they're playing anyway.

I was thinking more of Ibbotson and the like.

 

[coast2coast]

Swan and Beams, or Dalziell and Rich?

I'm leaning towards the Collingwood pair because Swan is the only proven performer of the four.