Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[Quazza]

Yeah I have Raines, but not Hill

So u reckon Ablett and Hill over Kerr and Hodge?


Not sure about that one

 

[mushda]

Harvey or Gia?

 

[Fuddnuddler]

Harvey or Gia?

harvey for mine...

pav or buddy?

 

[JuddyisGod]

Adcock and N.G. Brown

Or

Lockyer and Sylvia?

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Sam Gilbert, Dean Cox & Hamish Mcintosh

Or

Ryan Houlihan, David Hille, Drew Petrie

 

[favourites]

Go the first one.

 

[Murphinator]

RICH + 70k vs HARDING in 22.
WHICH IS BETTER OPTION?

how do you think harding will go this yeaR?

 

[Jimhouse]

Well I have Adcock, but obviously have Houlihan as well. Hard to say really. I think Adcock will average more, but then both players are underpriced IMO. Personally, I'd probably get Houlihan.

Can I get some thoughts on the following?

1) Hill, Selwood, Adcock, Enright + $40k
2) Hill, Swan, Bock, Adcock
3) Hill, Selwood, Bock, Newman
4) Krakouer, Selwood, Adcock, Bock


ATM I have option 2, but really not sure now.

Thanks mate I think that's what I'll do!

For you im leaning towards option 2.
You just know Swan is going to do well...

 

[samwise]

Ablett Houlihan. Easy!

Deledio and Goodwin.

VS

Chapman and Didak

deledio and goodwin. chapman has injury risk and deledio is as good as him with more improvement chance whilst goodwin is a good smokey with good preseason and will be one of the best unique picks

harvey for mine...

pav or buddy?

cant really go wrong. personally i would go buddy cuz he is still young and can improve and is possibly playing a richo type role for parts of games this year which will help if the zones make him do a bit worse for some parts of games in forward line. hawthorn also get more possesions than freo and better delivery into fwd line

Adcock and N.G. Brown

Or

Lockyer and Sylvia?

adcock is better than sylvia and brown is better than lockyer

RICH + 70k vs HARDING in 22.
WHICH IS BETTER OPTION?

rich+70k as it is not just the 70k you free up pre rd1 it is also the extra money you make from him rising in price more than harding as i cant see harding being a keeper.

k my turn please..
dalziell / montagna / tuck and why? im leaning towards montagna as i think his stats are as good as dalziell's and tuck only did awesome when richmond kept winning last year and dont rate him as dream teamer.

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

Really dont know what to do here...
Rich or Otten?

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Really dont know what to do here...
Rich or Otten?

Why would you start with rich or otten when you can get robinson, beams and anthony who are cheaper and will get games, therefore make more cash?

 

[Jonny27]

Got a tough one here

Chapman(or another 400k+ player) + Spanger

or

Adcock + Houlihan

 

[Juddy88]

Mackay v T.Tuck v Reilly

Reilly has been injury prone in the past, Mackay is somewhat an unknown in terms of DT potential and Tucks place may not be secure when injured players return.

 

[samwise]

Got a tough one here

Chapman(or another 400k+ player) + Spanger

or

Adcock + Houlihan

very tough but i think adcock and houlihan would score more. think this one is extremely tough. leaning against richo as i cant see him not missing at least 1 game. deledio will improve again and i think he handled tag last year very well so i think i would go him.


richo vs pavlich vs deledio

also think im gonna pick enright instead of chornes. is 100avg make you about 500k?

 

[LemmingMaster]

Why would you start with rich or otten when you can get robinson, beams and anthony who are cheaper and will get games, therefore make more cash?

Maybe Rich and Otten are more secure in their respective teams best 22?

That would be a good enough reason to select those players, if that is the case.

 

[lmaohelp]

ok got a couple here guys

i got leon davis as my 4th strong FWD and im now thinkn should i downgrade him to either - Henschel or Krakouer to gain money ?

then i can upgrade either Tuck or Haselby

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

RUCKMAN ROOKIES!!!

I am looking for two and am struggling to pick out of these four:

Jacobs
Spencer
Pyke
Browne

Jacobs and Browne are both named for round one.

 

[NT.Thunder]

My concern with Jacobs being named is Hampson being named an EMER

Currently Spencer and Jacobs but tough 1.

My predicament is

Ablett + Foley/Griffen
OR
Swan + Gibbs

Thoughts. My worry is starting of and not having ABC, however the 2nd mid pick above is my going to be my 4th mid. Going in with strong mids.

Thoughts

 

[force65]

i can only make 1 of these upgrades

Murphy --->Chapman
Adcock----> Johncock (ive got a hunch)
HMAC---->Ottens

which one is the most important do u reckon?

 

[Stormer]

Adcock --> Johncock.

Johncock will demolish Collingwood this week, you can be sure of that. I predict >120 DT points.

 

[$tylez]

this is my final decision. Help appreciated.

dazziel franklin and hille

or

corey pavlich and Hmac

??

 

[Piikeyyy]

lol you cant be an Adelaide supporter if your considering that

 

[lmaohelp]

ok got a couple here guys

i got leon davis as my 4th strong FWD and im now thinkn should i downgrade him to either - Henschel or Krakouer to gain money ?

then i can upgrade either Tuck or Haselby

 

[Athomas]

Deledio is going to get r*ped by Joseph. <70 points.
Franklin will tear up Geelong's Defense. > 100 points.

It is very short term thinking, but I think I'm picking Buddy.

 

[Lakey91]

i can only make 1 of these upgrades

Murphy --->Chapman
Adcock----> Johncock (ive got a hunch)
HMAC---->Ottens

which one is the most important do u reckon?

Johncocks out of round one mate - his mother (?) passed away recently, and he is on personal leave for now.