Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[fatmungus]

Not sure all this comparison between players with more than 20,000 price difference.


But here are my direct swap change comparisons:

Hentschel vs Ziebell

Selwood vs Tuck

Probably been done before but i think ziebell and selwood.

 

[Makedonija]

I have $86,600 spare at the moment, however i think my midfield is a bit weak.

Selwood, Judd, Foley, Dyson, Hasleby Hartlett (Rich, Swift)

Any obvious improvements? Was considering getting knights or upgrading hartlett but i need some advice.
Cheers.

 

[NashvsDyson]

defs hentschel and selwood..

help me out r. houlihan or t. hawkins

 

[NashvsDyson]

I have $86,600 spare at the moment, however i think my midfield is a bit weak.

Selwood, Judd, Foley, Dyson, Hasleby Hartlett (Rich, Swift)

Any obvious improvements? Was considering getting knights or upgrading hartlett but i need some advice.
Cheers.

get rich on ur ground and get a cheap interchange. Then with the money you got distribute mit to hartlett and particularly dyson.

foley i bet u could a better player maybe adcock? from that u'll get some more money in which u can use to invest in hartlett.

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Brent Harvey or Daniel Giansiracusa

 

[kangaroo19]

Brent Harvey or Daniel Giansiracusa

Gia. Think this is the year that Harvey will get more assistance inthe midfield, so may not be right up there in terms of DT scoring.

Newman or Bock?

 

[mightymagpie1999]

Gia. Think this is the year that Harvey will get more assistance inthe midfield, so may not be right up there in terms of DT scoring.

Newman or Bock?

I would probably go Chris Newman

I think he will take on his new leadership role at Richmond and have a really good year! Mind you its hard to go wrong either way with Bock and Newman to be honest

 

[BigLance]

How will the following players go ??

Simon Black ?

Lenny Hayes ?

Nick Dal Santo ?

Chris Judd ?

Alan Didak or Dale Thomas +100k ?

 

[happy_eagle]

Grant or Thompson for 9th forward ?

 

[Masss#10]

I got no idea who they are but why not go with Garlett or Brown?

My turn, if someone can help me out with his, legend!!

Gibbs and Ablet or Swan and Cross ??? Ballbreaker this one...

 

[gothedons]

I got no idea who they are but why not go with Garlett or Brown?

My turn, if someone can help me out with his, legend!!

Gibbs and Ablet or Swan and Cross ??? Ballbreaker this one...

Gibbs and Ablett, Gibbs has the capacity to improve on his scores, where as swan will stay around the same or go back a bit (might be used more negatively this year) cross and ablett both very consistent, with ablett averaging 10-15 more

 

[Decipher]

Gibbs and Ablet or Swan and Cross ??? Ballbreaker this one...

Gibbs and Ablett personally.
Ablett wants a brownlow should rip this year up.
Gibbs inline for a breakout this year.

Swans a good choice but I dont see Cross improving he also likes handballing alot.

My Turn.

Butler + M. Hurley on the pine
vs
T. Tuck + Petrenko on the pine. Thoughts?

 

[Wrenny]

Hey guys just a quick one

Heath Shaw or Newman or do i downgrade furthur to birchall or gram to free up some cash.

Then with the last forward pick stokes, O'Keefe, brad johnson, jon brown or goodwin!!

I dont know about their pre seasons!

Opinions would be greatly appreciated asap!

 

[lifelike_]

Gibbs and Ablett personally.
Ablett wants a brownlow should rip this year up.
Gibbs inline for a breakout this year.

Swans a good choice but I dont see Cross improving he also likes handballing alot.

My Turn.

Butler + M. Hurley on the pine
vs
T. Tuck + Petrenko on the pine. Thoughts?

Depends on your backline. If you've got a couple of risky players then I'd go the first option. The second option's more viable if you've played it safe in the backline.

Also depends on who you think will make more money on the bench.

FWIW I'd go with option one.

 

[lifelike_]

Hey guys just a quick one

Heath Shaw or Newman or do i downgrade furthur to birchall or gram to free up some cash.

Then with the last forward pick stokes, O'Keefe, brad johnson, jon brown or goodwin!!

I dont know about their pre seasons!

Opinions would be greatly appreciated asap!

If the 10-20k will make a big difference then it might be worth considering. IMO the 360k mark is the cutoff for the genuinely good backs though. Birchall's had some hamstring troubles though.

All forwards have had decent pre seasons. FWIW I'd take Goodwin, Brown Johnson, Stokes then O'Keefe in that order.

 

[lifelike_]

My turn!

Enright/Swan/Hille v Hodge/Ablett/McIntosh.

First one is safer, second one has a higher ceiling. I really want to get Ablett in my team but I'm not a fan of McIntosh.

 

[fryingpan]

My turn!

Enright/Swan/Hille v Hodge/Ablett/McIntosh.

First one is safer, second one has a higher ceiling. I really want to get Ablett in my team but I'm not a fan of McIntosh.

Second one easily. Expensive but Ablett is a must (even though I don't have him lol)

Gibbs or Palmer? (I have Judd in my team, no freo mids)

And is McDonald from the Dees worth picking up? I remember him getting plenty of tackles ..

 

[JuddyisGod]

Hodge or S.Tuck in the middle?

probably smarter to save Hodge for the backs?

 

[Jimhouse]

Scotland and Lucas

vs

Hill and Gia

If I dont get hill as a starter, I miss the boat...

 

[fryingpan]

If you want opinions on your team it's probably best to comment on other peoples queries, like everyone else has been doing.

 

[Jimhouse]

My turn!

Enright/Swan/Hille v Hodge/Ablett/McIntosh.

First one is safer, second one has a higher ceiling. I really want to get Ablett in my team but I'm not a fan of McIntosh.

I would go with option 2


Scotland and Lucas

vs

Hill and Gia + 60k

If I dont get hill as a starter, I miss the boat...

 

[roostersgal4eva]

Im having trouble with defenders

So far im tossing up Ash Hansen, Schulz, Jake Edwards, Croad

 

[fryingpan]

Im having trouble with defenders

So far im tossing up Ash Hansen, Schulz, Egan, Jake Edwards, Croad

Well I think Egan is injured my luv

Out of those I'd probably have to go Hansen.

 

[kangaroo19]

Last 2 decisions are starting to bug me...

Newman v Bock

Beams v Robinson

Cheers!

 

[Jab]

Second one easily. Expensive but Ablett is a must (even though I don't have him lol)

Gibbs or Palmer? (I have Judd in my team, no freo mids)

And is McDonald from the Dees worth picking up? I remember him getting plenty of tackles ..

I'd go Gibbs, Surely Palmer is freo's best or second best mid and will more than likely get a bit more of a tag as a result