Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[Mordecai]

Stevey J vs Nathan g Brown. These are they types of questions you ask when you stare at your team for too long.

 

[Bombsaway08]

Gibbs, Fraser, J.Brown
or
Foley, Hille, J.Brown
or
Haselby, hille, richo/didak/delideo/n.brown

 

[Da Gangsta]

Who will average more, Ziebell or Hill

 

[chopperduck]

T.Tuck / P.Hasleby / S.Butler

Are Butler or Tuck going to stay in the 22 long enough ??

 

[chopperduck]

Stevey J vs Nathan g Brown. These are they types of questions you ask when you stare at your team for too long.

thats a tough one... both in teams that benefit the player as well. this is one of those toss the coin type questions, you just dont know.

 

[kangaroo19]

Broughton IMO. Sounds like he will play.

I'm thinking of switching Hill to the mids so I'll play Hill and Anthony, with Rich and Beams on the bench, and starting no back rookies.

Thoughts? ATM I have just Anthony in the mids, and Hill on the field in the backline with Petrenko and Broughton backup.

Anyone have thoughts on this?

 

[Mordecai]

Cross and Knights or Bartel and Butler?

 

[Mr.Jingles]

Grrrrr Robinson or Beams....

Trade hentchel for walket and get cash to get rich????

KILLING ME!!

 

[Mr.Jingles]

Cross and Knights or Bartel and Butler?

Cross and knights...knights will dominate this year!!

Butler not soo certain about!

 

[Mordecai]

Grrrrr Robinson or Beams....

Trade hentchel for walket and get cash to get rich????

KILLING ME!!

Hentschel to Walker - they're the same player. One is cheaper.

Get Rich.

Do mine

 

[Tman24]

Anyone have thoughts on this?

I have a similar issue. Not happy with my back rookies and having to start hill.

Currently i have as my cheap backs and mids:

Backs - Hill, Broughton, Cheney
Mids - Butler, Rich, Otten, Anthony

I am thinking i should trade Butler down to another rookie mid (ie. Beams) and then upgrade Cheney to Petterd.

Really not sure!

Rookie backs look problematic so it might be best to only have more rookies in the mids instead?

Thoughts??

Cheers

 

[Tman24]

Grrrrr Robinson or Beams....

Trade hentchel for walket and get cash to get rich????

KILLING ME!!

Id get Walker and Rich.

 

[Mordecai]

Cross and knights...knights will dominate this year!!

Butler not soo certain about!

Butler and Knights are both injury risks and could both average the same.

It also gives me the cash to upgrade McIntosh to Simmonds.

 

[Mr.Jingles]

Butler and Knights are both injury risks and could both average the same.

It also gives me the cash to upgrade McIntosh to Simmonds.

Knights not so much though!
I have knights...so i believe he will dominate..have watched him precariously throughout the offseason..i rate highly!!
Butler will provide some benefit..but i see knights outclassing him!!

Also Mcintosh to simmonds..nbot much of an upgrade!!
Cant see simmonds doing to much tonight!!
Hope im right!

 

[Mordecai]

Knights not so much though!
I have knights...so i believe he will dominate..have watched him precariously throughout the offseason..i rate highly!!
Butler will provide some benefit..but i see knights outclassing him!!

Also Mcintosh to simmonds..nbot much of an upgrade!!
Cant see simmonds doing to much tonight!!
Hope im right!

Perhaps you're right. What about Hentschell to Skipworth?

 

[Benno_900]

Feel uneasy starting Hill with no decent backup now especially with these Goddard rumours ...

Travis Tuck/Petrenko vs Butler/Collier

Will probably have Collier on the bench.

 

[Mordecai]

Bartel, Butler, Skipworth
or
Cross, Knights, Hentschel

Ziebell + McIntosh
or
Thompson + Ottens

 

[BartBart]

Goodwin v B.Johnson?

 

[Benno_900]

Bartel, Butler, Skipworth
or
Cross, Knights, Hentschel

Ziebell + McIntosh
or
Thompson + Ottens

First option for both

 

[Mordecai]

Goodwin v B.Johnson?

Former. Couple of poor scores during last year saw his average dip.

 

[Mordecai]

Feel uneasy starting Hill with no decent backup now especially with these Goddard rumours ...

Travis Tuck/Petrenko vs Butler/Collier

Will probably have Collier on the bench.

Ill be honest I don't know a lot about Collier. Petrenko I can't trust to retain his spot with all the players set to return.

If you think Butler is a good option for me then you should go him as well

The latter.

Edit: I already have Ablett and Selwood. Is that an issue?

AND w.thompson or ziebell or hentschell?

 

[Strachuniee]

Last spot i am undecided about in my team. Rich or ottens as a the last starting mid.

 

[Benno_900]

Ill be honest I don't know a lot about Collier. Petrenko I can't trust to retain his spot with all the players set to return.

If you think Butler is a good option for me then you should go him as well

The latter.

Edit: I already have Ablett and Selwood. Is that an issue?

No, won't be an issue at all. I'd have gone first just because Bartel/Skipworth are superior to Cross/Hentschel. Butler is definitely the weak link in that.

Waiting for the Brisbane team to come out. Collier definitely has greater job security but he does cost 70K more.

Bit uncertain about Butler's durability but I only really need him to play first 6-8 games before I upgrade him. And he could average similar to Travis Tuck so not losing much there.

 

[Mordecai]

No, won't be an issue at all. I'd have gone first just because Bartel/Skipworth are superior to Cross/Hentschel. Butler is definitely the weak link in that.

Waiting for the Brisbane team to come out. Collier definitely has greater job security but he does cost 70K more.

Bit uncertain about Butler's durability but I only really need him to play first 6-8 games before I upgrade him. And he could average similar to Travis Tuck so not losing much there.

so does Knights>butler offset Skipworth>hentschel and Bartel>cross? Who knows.

Also, I'll have to trade Butler but I'd keep knights.

I'm worried I have too much risk. I've drawn a line through Tuck... just too expensive for what you think he'll do.

Hentschel or ziebell for seventh forward? thats how risky it is.

 

[Strachuniee]

so does Knights>butler offset Skipworth>hentschel and Bartel>cross? Who knows.

Also, I'll have to trade Butler but I'd keep knights.

I'm worried I have too much risk. I've drawn a line through Tuck... just too expensive for what you think he'll do.

Hentschel or ziebell for seventh forward? thats how risky it is.

Definately think ziebell has better scope. IMO knights does offset the above situation. Really rate the kid