Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[Deestroy]

One last difficult choice for my team, Cross and Pavlich or Swan and B.Harvey?

 

[Mordecai]

One last difficult choice for my team, Cross and Pavlich or Swan and B.Harvey?

Swan and B. Harvey.

I really worry about the zone for Pav when he's forward and he's not the best scorer when he does go to midfield.

I have Christopher Cross - to be honest I'd go Cross and Harvey.

 

[AjsGuns]

i have Swan, Cross and Harvey.
if i had to choose i would go Swan + Harvey.
You get a good captain choice in Swan and i can see Harvey averaging as much if not more than Pav for the first few rounds. Pavs also more expensive and a KPP and will surely drop in price.

 

[Juddy88]

Swan > Cross. Easily.

Both are good, consistent players but Swan has those massive games mor eoften.

 

[Deestroy]

Thanks guys, reassured me I wasn't crazy for getting rid of Pav.

 

[westcoast929406]

Gibbs + Stevie J

or

K.Simpson + Buddy

 

[WeninRome]

One last difficult choice for my team, Cross and Pavlich or Swan and B.Harvey?

I think Pav will kill it this year. Go for number 1.
Cross will have more upside than harvey.

 

[Mordecai]

Gibbs + Stevie J

or

K.Simpson + Buddy

Former.

 

[WeninRome]

ok guys my final issue.

am happy to answer everyones after this one...

I have in my mids ..

A,B and Dalziel.

Now i can downgrade Pav to harvey/ gia and then upgrade dalziel to swann..

what does everyone think?

 

[WeninRome]

former.

definately agree!

 

[Mordecai]

ok guys my final issue.

am happy to answer everyones after this one...

I have in my mids ..

A,B and Dalziel.

Now i can downgrade Pav to harvey/ gia and then upgrade dalziel to swann..

what does everyone think?

Do it for Harvey for sure.

My turn - Kornes/Cross and Knights or Boyd and S.Tuck?

 

[AjsGuns]

ok guys my final issue.

am happy to answer everyones after this one...

I have in my mids ..

A,B and Dalziel.

Now i can downgrade Pav to harvey/ gia and then upgrade dalziel to swann..

what does everyone think?

Yes do it.
imo harvey will avg just as much as pavlich for the first 5-7 rounds.
there is so much more upside in swan than dalziel its riduclous.

 

[WeninRome]

Do it for Harvey for sure.

My turn - Kornes/Cross and Knights or Boyd and S.Tuck?

Boyd and tuck

Cross = Boyd

tuck will out score cornes this year i think

 

[AjsGuns]

Kornes + Knights.

 

[Juddy88]

tuck will out score cornes this year i think

Doubt it.

 

[Mordecai]

Wow.. a lot of varied responses. Boyd is very close to being Cross, I agree. It comes down to Knights and Tuck. I think Knights could get more gametime this year.

 

[happy_eagle]

Grant or Thompson
Leaning towards Thompson

 

[AjsGuns]

Neither ...
If u have to go one Thompson.

 

[JSF24]

Suban or Broughton

 

[kangaroo19]

Suban or Broughton

Broughton IMO. Sounds like he will play.

I'm thinking of switching Hill to the mids so I'll play Hill and Anthony, with Rich and Beams on the bench, and starting no back rookies.

Thoughts? ATM I have just Anthony in the mids, and Hill on the field in the backline with Petrenko and Broughton backup.

 

[WeninRome]

Doubt it.

sorry wrong tuck.

 

[WeninRome]

Robinson vs Beams vs Zibiel vs sidebottom...

i know a lot to consider.

 

[kangaroos3]

Last move to finalise my team.

Boomer or Gia.

I have Boomer ATM but thinking of changing to Gia.
Thoughts??

 

[WeninRome]

Last move to finalise my team.

Boomer or Gia.

I have Boomer ATM but thinking of changing to Gia.
Thoughts??

to be honest i dont think you can lose either way.

 

[johncocksasuperstar]

kangaroos I would go Boomer, IMO Gia can just not crack triple figures enough. Pretty much a wash though.

Ok now this is probably my last dilemma.

Its either:
Gibbs, Haselby, Deledio

OR


Kornes, Butler, Chapman/Franklin/NG Brown

What are peoples thoughts?
I think the bottom one is riskier but not really too sure.