Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[Juddy88]

Can't decide who to start - Rich or Anthony?

 

[WeninRome]

who would you pick out of rich or ziebiel?

 

[WeninRome]

Can't decide who to start - Rich or Anthony?

start both

im starting anthony and ottens.

 

[Juddy88]

start both

im starting anthony and ottens.

Brad?

Or do you mean, Otten.

 

[WeninRome]

Brad?

Or do you mean, Otten.

you got it.

so rich or ziebiel?

 

[Juddy88]

you got it.

so rich or ziebiel?

Both similar options will prob give you around 50-60. Can't really lose either way.

 

[Hodges]

Beams vs Robinson

Who have people got as their 8th mid? I have Beams currently, but he hasnt been named. Looks like he will find it tough to break into the Pies side unless they get some injuries. Robinson is there for the moment, but for how long? If he plays well he could cement a spot though.

 

[WeninRome]

who will score higher out of otten or rich?

 

[Hodges]

I would say Otten.

Hentschel + Beams + Hurley vs Collier + Ziebell + Shoenmakers

Hawks have gone for Boots to replace Croad (ahead of Thorp/Dowler). Shows a bit of faith in the kid, and he could be in the side for a while. Collier made the squad too, just a matter of how long for. Beams isnt playing so Ziebell would be the better option...

Thoughts?

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

I would say Otten.

Hentschel + Beams + Hurley vs Collier + Ziebell + Shoenmakers

Hawks have gone for Boots to replace Croad (ahead of Thorp/Dowler). Shows a bit of faith in the kid, and he could be in the side for a while. Collier made the squad too, just a matter of how long for. Beams isnt playing so Ziebell would be the better option...

Thoughts?

First option.


GUYS, please help me with this one:

Hurley (safe bench option) + Zibell (starting) or Cheney/Suban + Krakouer?

 

[Hodges]

First option. Hurley has been my smoky back all pre-season, I think he will kill it (games wise ). Dont hold much hope for Cheney or Suban getting many games.

My above trade didnt quite work out value wise, so its now:

Hurley + Beams vs Shoenmakers + Ziebell

One named rookie vs two. Hurley is more likely to get games than Boots though.

 

[swans4eva]

Once i get onto dream team!

Beams or Anthony or another player who is 86k or less and playing round one
Note- Already have Robinson

 

[Mordecai]

First option.


GUYS, please help me with this one:

Hurley (safe bench option) + Zibell (starting) or Cheney/Suban + Krakouer?

Do you have Hill as well on your bench. I'm leaning towards option 2.

Bartel + Skipworth + Butler vs Cross + Knights + Hentschel?

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

Just let me trade in ziebell! Stop timing out

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

YESS finally

 

[johncocksasuperstar]

Do i downgrade hentschel to anyone below 118000 so i can upgrade chappy/franklin to deledio?

 

[DLab]

Tuck, Robinson, Broughton
vs
Mackay, Otten, Suban

Thoughts???

 

[DLab]

Other than the rookies johncock, i can see any value under 118000, brown and walker are the best options. ziebell is 600 off your price

 

[catsdynasty]

could anybody pleasssssssssseeeeeee help me have everything finalized except my bench, atm I have Suban and Broughton only reason for Broughton is he could make more money thatn having Petrenko. So:

Suban+ Broughton
or
Suban+Petrenko

And could you please help me with my forward line bench, atm I have Ballantyne and Walker and am thinking of having Mitch Brown (WCE). IO know Ballantyne is injured but I only have him on my bench and I think that Brown is a good player to have so out of these three which one

Ballantyne+ Walker
or
Ballantyne+Brown
Or
Brown+ Walker

Would really appreciate a hand here

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

could anybody pleasssssssssseeeeeee help me have everything finalized except my bench, atm I have Suban and Broughton only reason for Broughton is he could make more money thatn having Petrenko. So:

Suban+ Broughton
or
Suban+Petrenko

And could you please help me with my forward line bench, atm I have Ballantyne and Walker and am thinking of having Mitch Brown (WCE). IO know Ballantyne is injured but I only have him on my bench and I think that Brown is a good player to have so out of these three which one

Ballantyne+ Walker
or
Ballantyne+Brown
Or
Brown+ Walker

Would really appreciate a hand here

Mate get Suban + Broughton to save money, Broughton should be playing soon.

And Brown and Walker since they're both playing and Ballantyne will be a perfect downgrade target.

 

[Makedonija]

Due to the crap dream team servers, i was unable to make a few late changes. One cahnge i was going to do was hartlett for ziebell. Hartlett isn't playing round 1 and ziebell has been named in the starting 22 for the kangas. Can anyone shed any light on hartlett in the long term? as i don't know enough about the player.
Cheers.

 

[Lakey91]

Due to the crap dream team servers, i was unable to make a few late changes. One cahnge i was going to do was hartlett for ziebell. Hartlett isn't playing round 1 and ziebell has been named in the starting 22 for the kangas. Can anyone shed any light on hartlett in the long term? as i don't know enough about the player.
Cheers.

I thought he did a shoulder?

 

[54Dogs]

Due to the crap dream team servers, i was unable to make a few late changes. One cahnge i was going to do was hartlett for ziebell. Hartlett isn't playing round 1 and ziebell has been named in the starting 22 for the kangas. Can anyone shed any light on hartlett in the long term? as i don't know enough about the player.
Cheers.

I thought he did a shoulder?

Hit up forward who played Rd 1 last year before being suspended for a couple, then getting injured, coming back for 1 and getting injured again then coming back for 2 and gone again and so the story goes.

Hartletts injury history makes JWS, Drummond and Demsey look like durable rocks.

 

[bigjb]

Petterd or Cheney?

raines has gotta go, is cheney likely to play a good part of the season?

 

[chadleverington]

Hartletts injury history makes JWS, Drummond and Demsey look like durable rocks.

That is Adam Hartlett? I hear Hartlett and Shoulder and i think Hamish

Hamish Harlett's shoulder injury wasn't too bad, played SANFL last week, for anyone interested.

Hamish Hartlett (for West v South @ Noarlunga) – Played on a half forward flank for the Bloods and applied himself well with some very effective kicking. Got through the match unscathed and looked good, finishing with 9 kicks, 6 marks, 5 handballs and 1.1.