Player Comparison Thread - Part 3

[CRAWF 08]

ottens or rich ?????

both should get games barring injury who is more likely to score better??

 

[Lakey91]

That is Adam Hartlett? I hear Hartlett and Shoulder and i think Hamish

Hamish Harlett's shoulder injury wasn't too bad, played SANFL last week, for anyone interested.

Hamish Hartlett (for West v South @ Noarlunga) – Played on a half forward flank for the Bloods and applied himself well with some very effective kicking. Got through the match unscathed and looked good, finishing with 9 kicks, 6 marks, 5 handballs and 1.1.

Ah, yeh i was thinking hamish...

 

[chadleverington]

ottens or rich ?????

both should get games barring injury who is more likely to score better??

Rich more likely to play and more likely to score better

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Bump.

Lockyer v Hodge

 

[94_Eagles]

ottens or rich ?????

both should get games barring injury who is more likely to score better??

Its easy when you have had both from the start

 

[Benno_900]

Bump.

Lockyer v Hodge

Surely you're not going to trade Hodge for Lockyer?

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Surely you're not going to trade Hodge for Lockyer?

No, I'm looking to upgrade Buckley.

 

[Peake 2 Murphy]

Both are good players
Hodge is the safer option, but lockyer could go back to his 2007 form

 

[Lakey91]

Both are good players
Hodge is the safer option, but lockyer could go back to his 2007 form

I would actually say lockyer is safer.

More durable, less likely to get suspended, in better form, less likely to lose significant value....

Thats just my opinion though.

 

[Jab]

You make some good points Lakey91 but....

Who will you want by years end?

If the answer is both, buy Locky now, Hodge later

If that is not your answer, buy the guy who you want to be in your team at the end of the year.

 

[Lakey91]

$235,000 + Flexibility v 195 points + One Trade

Now a trade is said to be worth 100k, or 300 points (on average).

So this could be reduced to:

135k + Flexibility v 195 points

or

235k + Flexibility v 495 points

Now flexibility is I suppose an objective term. What its meant to mean is that I would be more able to make trades whenever i wanted, as ive got significantly more cash in the bank.

A bit random and complicated, but your thoughts?

Somehow, i can see this relating alot to the value of a trade, so hopefully this scenario can generate some discussion.

 

[Ben the Gooner]

I think that 'philosophical' questions like that, Lakey, are worthy of their own thread.

I know I'm happier with my SC team, where I have 350k in the bank, but worse rookies.

Well, the same rookies, but they're better suited to DT.

I think the cash and the flexibility is great, and means you can capitalise on a break-even without having to harvest a cow too early.

 

[deano the hawka]

Stephen Hill or Greg Broughton

Got a dilemma for my backline. Got Cheney with the 6th back position most likely, but who should i pick for the 7th? Gamble with Hill, or go with Broughton?

 

[54Dogs]

Re: Stephen Hill or Greg Broughton

Merged to Player Comparison Thread

 

[deano the hawka]

just found out that broughton is out for this week, so don't worry

 

[94_Eagles]

Re: Stephen Hill or Greg Broughton

Got a dilemma for my backline. Got Cheney with the 6th back position most likely, but who should i pick for the 7th? Gamble with Hill, or go with Broughton?

I traded Hill for Cheney last round but am regretting it already

 

[Peake 2 Murphy]

Re: Stephen Hill or Greg Broughton

Tossing up between onfield positions this week
Should i start

Rich or Beams (cant split them)

Brown or Walker (leaning towards brown, because of the geelong factor)

 

[speedpeck23]

G. Birchall or H. Shaw

As they are both out this week (Birchall for 4 with broken thumb) and (Shaw suspended) i need to get rid of one. I want to use my trade wisely and while Birchall is performing very well he is out for longer time than the underachieving Shaw. Who should i get rid of? and who should i pick up? i am am really unsure any help would be greatly appreciated.

 

[Juddy88]

Re: G. Birchall or H. Shaw

Trades thread.

 

[panga]

Re: G. Birchall or H. Shaw

Adcock v M.Clarke

Who do you think is going to score more over the course of the year?

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Adcock.

 

[IbbosBFF]

Rance VS Cheney.

Who will play more games. Will Rance mature to 300k as estimated?
Cheney will only mature to around 200ish according to FF Genie, been dropped this week as well.

Now has to contend with veteran backs.

 

[LemmingMaster]

Just had to bump this thread, it was getting lost on page 2.

 

[desTROY]

Need to bring in a player for Wells.

Kornes ($410,700, Ave. 95, B.E. 137) vs Hayes ($395,700, Ave. 97, B.E 89) vs Lewis ($368,300, Ave. 101, B.E. 75)

Kornes-
Highest scoring potential
Most consistent
High break even

Hayes-
Low break even
Saints dominating

Lewis-
Low break even
Underpriced
Discipline issues

 

[LemmingMaster]

desTROY, you seem to have all the information. It is now up to you, which option to take. Personally, I don't think you should pick someone based on what a person on BF tells you.

All options are valid, personally, I would prefer Ablett > Bartel > Swan > Corey -> Then your selections

If you can't afford some of those options, then by all means make your own choice.